Israel, India, and the Rise of Defensive Asymmetry

Posted on Categories Geopolitics, India, Israel, Politics, Science, War, X.T.MTags , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , 86 Comments on Israel, India, and the Rise of Defensive Asymmetry

A Pause in the Offensive:

Without getting into the ideological or emotional dimensions of current conflicts, one point stands out: both Israel and India seem quietly surprised by the defensive resilience of their adversaries.

Whether it’s Iran-Israel, India-Pakistan, or even Russia-Ukraine, a pattern is emerging: offensive campaigns that assumed rapid success are stalling against increasingly capable—and surprisingly tenacious—defensive postures.

In classic military doctrine, a successful offense requires a 3:1 superiority. That logic appears to be inverting. What we may be witnessing is a shift in the scientific and technological balance—not just in weaponry, but in surveillance, cyber, and even psychological endurance as evidenced by the Iranians on national television in this clip, IMG_0631.

Continue reading Israel, India, and the Rise of Defensive Asymmetry

Brighter than a Thousand Suns

Posted on Categories America, Book Reviews, History, Politics, ScienceTags , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , 11 Comments on Brighter than a Thousand Suns

A personal history of the Atomic Scientists:

The issue of nuclear weapons, weighing on everyone’s mind given the latest Iran-Israel tensions as also the recent tensions between India-Pakistan and of course the Russia-Ukraine conflict, had me reaching out for this fantastic book to read once more.

The book Brighter than a Thousand Suns by Robert Jungk is a beautifully written history of the atomic scientists who were instrumental in the development of the atomic bomb. Of course, J. Robert Oppenheimer is the most well known and the star of the show with the Manhattan Project. This book however traces the entire chronology of the events leading up to the race of making the first atom bomb from 1918 onwards. The author personally corresponded with most of the scientists and wrote up this magnum opus. One of my personal favourites by far.

Some poignant takeaways; quoting directly from the book:

“The international family of physicists has kept together to the best of their ability, at all events better than men of letters and intellectuals in other fields, who bombarded each other with spiteful manifestoes.

Physicists who has worked together before the war, often for years, either by correspondence or side by side in the laboratory, could never become enemies at a command from above.

During these years most zealous efforts were made by the Soviet Union to make contact with Western Scientists. The Bolshevist state not only wished its scientists to learn from those “out there”. It also took care to have its own publications translated into English, French and German. Even that dictatorial state, in those days, imposed no rule of secrecy or censorship upon the field of research”. Continue reading Brighter than a Thousand Suns

Ongoing | Israel-Iran Escalation | Open Thread

Posted on Categories Geopolitics, Middle East, Open Thread, Politics, Religion, WarTags , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , 102 Comments on Ongoing | Israel-Iran Escalation | Open Thread
Editor Note: as this is still sadly ongoing I've made this top of page.

Overnight, Israel launched unprovoked (according to them “preemptive”) strikes on Iran.  Troubling times are ahead for the entire Middle Eastern region.

To lay my cards on the table: I am on Iran’s side on this issue. Though I  am not a fan of the “Islamic Republic”, there is no excuse for this kind of unprovoked attack on an entire country.  If Israel’s aim was to sabotage the ongoing US-Iran negotiations, it has certainly succeeded in doing so.  Further, escalation with Iran will distract the international community from the ongoing war crimes occurring in Gaza.

A good resource for further information is this liveblog from The Guardian

I am curious about others’ perspectives on this issue particularly those of X.T.M due to his part-Iranian heritage.

Brown Pundits