Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

September 2026

All years and months

  • Izzat Maxing

    X.T.M answers Q’s claim that India–Pakistan wars will stay short, arguing that allies matter only for the fifth day. He tests this against 1971, Kargil, Operation Sindoor and the Gulf…

    X.T.M30 September 202616 comments
  • A Pakistani Hindu is not content but is Content

    X.T.M argues that social media rewards rarity: a Hindu in Pakistan or a Jew in Iran becomes a story, while the same people in India or Israel are absorbed into…

    X.T.M28 September 202613 comments
  • The Peshawar Review

    X.T.M lists the contents of the October issue of The Peshawar Review, including pieces by Anjum Altaf on September Eleven and Harbans Mukhia’s memoir of Dr K. M. Ashraf, and…

    X.T.M25 September 20263 comments
  • Open Thread: What’s new?

    Open Thread, 24 September 2026. Agni opens with the Tata Sons and Tata Trusts dispute, the IIT Bombay student death and its politics, the US–Iran conflict and Indian energy, Trump…

    BP Admin Team · opened by Agni24 September 202680 comments
  • Racial curve fitting analysis

    Indosaurus questions the popular claim that Arab culture explains Arab military defeats, noting that the same traits appear in Japanese corporate life and that Houthis and Hezbollah have outperformed. He…

    Indosaurus23 September 202671 comments
  • The iPhone, Babur & are sons sold in shops?

    A Dalit with an iPhone 16 has purchasing power, not the end of caste. And a Turkic sword at the birth of Indo-Islam is not a claim over South Asian…

    X.T.M23 September 202663 comments
  • IIT Bombay Says It Followed Procedure. A Student Is Dead.

    Sahil Wakode was caught with his phone in a midterm at IIT Bombay and was dead by evening. The institute says he was counselled and reassured; the family alleges threats…

    X.T.M21 September 2026119 comments
  • FlyDie, Volume Two

    Nineteen more FlyDie comments across six threads: the three pillars of caste, what the Mughals took from the land, how the Rig Veda got written, Kerala’s three-cornered trade, and Bollywood…

    FlyDie21 September 20262 comments
  • The Gender Protocol Has Teeth

    X.T.M announces that a commenter, KB, has been fined 20 comments under the Gender Protocol for remarks about a Pakistani female politician that the admins describe as misogynistic. The post…

    X.T.M19 September 20266 comments
  • Pakistan Punches Above Its Weight. Blame Aligarh.

    X.T.M asks how Pakistan produces so much culture for its income, crediting Lucknow and Aligarh rather than Bollywood. In his account the Urdu-speaking salariat carried that culture west in 1947,…

    X.T.M19 September 202640 comments
Brown Pundits