Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

  • Iran and Pakistan Are Not the Same Kind of State

    X.T.M argues that Iran cannot be analysed like Pakistan because it is a civilisation-state some three thousand years old. He says authority there rests on inherited ideas, from monarchy to…

    X.T.M29 January 202618 comments
  • Why is the Pakistani consumer so poor?

    Bombay Badshah notes that India’s GDP is about 11 times Pakistan’s, yet its cricket revenue, league rights and forex reserves are many times larger. He suggests Pakistan’s oversized military distorts…

  • Listening to Iran

    X.T.M reports what he heard from people in Iran: severe economic strain, worst in provincial towns, with no wide appetite for monarchy. He argues that China cannot absorb partners’ failures…

    X.T.M27 January 20265 comments
  • Tamil Islam Is Not a North Indian Story

    X.T.M argues that a Tamil Muslim politician waving an LTTE flag is unremarkable, because Islam reached South India through trade and Tamilness outweighs religion. He says North Indian assumptions wrongly…

    X.T.M27 January 202610 comments
  • Report on Op-Sindoor

    Nachiketa posts an extract from a report on Operation Sindoor concluding that India achieved air superiority by 10 May 2025, while Pakistan won the information contest. His own summary is…

    Nachiketa27 January 202621 comments
  • Borderline Bloodpressure

    X.T.M describes borderline high blood pressure and a raised resting heart rate at 41, a nosebleed and his usual January check-up in India. He argues that health must become a…

    X.T.M26 January 202613 comments
  • Why It Is Still Acceptable to Insult India

    A chance encounter in Cambridge exposes how casually India remains a socially acceptable target of disdain in Western conversation—revealing the link between microaggression, diasporic self-erasure, and the discomfort provoked by…

    X.T.M24 January 20260 comments
  • Is Hinduism Pagan ?

    The author asks whether Hinduism is Pagan. He argues that it is not under the historical, pejorative meaning, but that the Atman doctrine fits the broader neo-pagan sense, viewing Brahman…

  • F*ck Your Algorithm, My People Are Still Colonised

    X.T.M argues that a Google Gemini summary on French West Africa repeats colonial language, framing Islam as an obstacle to a civilising mission. He calls this Islamophobia by default and…

    X.T.M22 January 20260 comments
  • Pakistan, the deciding hinge between the West & CRINK

    X.T.M argues that Pakistan is one of the most dextrous middle powers, sitting at the hinge between the West and the China-Russia-Iran bloc. He says its position, professional military and…

    X.T.M22 January 20268 comments
Brown Pundits