History
Posts whose main purpose is to explain the past.
-
Politics
History of modern India (without scare quotes)
Praising Chandrahas Choudhury’s precis of modern Indian history, the poster adds that majoritarianism stays a danger until minorities gain strength, notes Manipuris face harsh laws, and expects Bengal and Kerala…
-
Politics
Ummah firster vs. Dharma firster
Casting India’s contest as Ummah-firsters against Dharma-firsters, the poster says the former expect a lower caste-Muslim alliance to topple upper-caste rulers, and warns with the case of Jogendranath Mandal, who…
-
Politics
“Prime minister of people of all faiths”
Reading British advice that Modi should drop religious talk for economics, the poster is cautiously hopeful but doubtful. It argues divide and rule worked because Indians were already divided, and…
-
Politics
Muslims are over-represented only in jails
Reacting to Saba Naqvi on the state of secularism, the poster argues that ideologies are more poisonous than events, naming the two-nation theory as the chief source, and that secularists…
-
The Middle East at night from space or the ancient borders of Cyrus’s Empire
A Vox map of the Middle East at night, with its text on viewing the region without political borders. The poster adds a map of Cyrus the Great’s empire at…
-
Culture
Meeting your lost brother (after 42 years)
The poster adds to a columnist’s account of visiting Bangladesh and old Bengali schoolmates that the key contrast is cricket: Pakistan has hosted no international matches since the 2009 attack…
-
History
Sikhs (15th Ludhiana infantry) save Sahibs
The poster notes that Britain gained hugely from Indian soldiers in the world wars and that a few words of gratitude would be welcome, citing David Cameron’s praise for a…
-
History
(Surya Devi lied) Mohd Bin Qasim died
A post on the Chachnama’s account of Muhammad bin Qasim’s death, which the poster calls fairy tales, adding that conversion changed little for lower castes, with an excerpt from a…
-
Bangladesh war hero is history
On the sale of INS Vikrant, the poster argues India has never written proper history and that the 1971 war should be retold around its victims, mainly Hindus driven out…
-
Geopolitics
Reihan Salam- neocon unlimited
The poster is puzzled by Reihan Salam’s defence of American policy on the 1971 Bangladesh war, noting that Nixon never told the Pakistan Army to stop, though Salam admits a…
