History
Posts whose main purpose is to explain the past.
-
History
The (unsung) mutiny (1946)
A 94-year-old eyewitness’s account of the 1946 Royal Indian Navy mutiny, with the poster noting the mutineers were never employed by either the Indian or Pakistani navy.
-
History
1857
An extract on the 26th Native Infantry’s 1857 mutiny at Mian Mir and the Ajnala well where the mutineers were killed, which the poster calls shared history of Hindus, Sikhs…
-
Geopolitics
Crimean War part II
The poster compares Russia’s move to send troops to Crimea with the Crimean War of the 1850s, and expects Crimea’s Muslim Tatars to resist.
-
History
The Taj is Indian..or is it?
Extracts on Pakistani undergraduates debating whether the Taj Mahal is part of Pakistan’s history, with the poster saying it shows how much studying history matters to national symbols.
-
History
A world built on Slavery
A comment, with a Juan Cole link, that Haiti spent most of its budget until 1940 compensating slave-owners for its emancipation, and a reader’s question on the one-drop rule and…
-
Jab We Met: Encounters between Islam and Hinduism in Early-Medieval Punjab
Prompted by a bilingual Ghaznavid dirham in his collection, the author argues that Pakistanis forget the layers of history beneath them and examines the first extended encounters between Islam and…
-
the Sanskrit tongue was chilled at 500metres
Notes on a book’s geographic account of Eurasia, including how Indian civilisation was a lowland phenomenon, Sanskrit’s reach, and Pakistan and Iraq as illogically drawn states.
-
Geopolitics
Is Pakistan the reason why India is not yet a Great Power?
Inspired by Robert Kaplan’s The Revenge of Geography, the author asks why India obsesses over Pakistan and Islam when Southeast Asia and the Indian Ocean are the real prize, and…
-
A stirring reminder of India’s role in the British Empire
A shared fact that India paid £479 million for Britain’s First World War, with the poster amused that an ancient civilisation is billed as a ‘young lion’ beside Australia, Canada…
-
Culture
The Act of Killing
The poster recommends the documentary The Act of Killing without having seen it, and reflects that Indonesia openly honours mass killers in a way India’s 1947 and 1971 killers were…
