Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Hindus in America: Xenophobia on the Right, Suspicion on the Left

X.T.M16 November 20261,006th post5 min read3 comments
President Trump seated at the Resolute Desk with Indian American officials and Indian diplomats, a lit brass lamp and flower rangoli in front

Hinduphobia on Brown Pundits has usually meant Pakistan: “Hinduphobia Exists, But Pakistan Was Not Born from It”, “The Long Defeat: How Hinduphobia Hollowed Out Pakistan” and “Bin Qasim’s Thousand-Year Wound”. There the argument is about a state and its history. In America it is about a prosperous minority and its neighbours, a quarrel the site took up in 2022, in a Browncast, “Caste, Hindus in America and Hinduphobia”, and in “Being anti-Brown is anti-Hindu”.

On Saturday 7 November 2026, children were performing at “Diwali: Lights of India” in the Seattle Center Armory when two far-right activists walked in carrying placards that read “Deport All Dot Heads”. They were escorted out and the festival went on. Representative Pramila Jayapal called it “this vile and racist display”. A year earlier, in October 2025, masked protesters in Irving, Texas, carried signs calling Hindu gods “foreign demons” and Diwali “garbage”.

The disruption at the Seattle Center Armory, 7 November 2026, as filmed and posted on X.

It is interesting that it is white Americans who push back at the two men in the video, and hard; the Hindu families stay in their seats. A community taught not to make a scene lets others fight for it?

The age of the model minority is ending. Hindus in America did what was asked of them: they studied, worked, married and stayed out of trouble. Now parts of the right call them foreigners and parts of the left treat them as suspects.

The right: foreigners

The far right’s quarrel with Hindus is less about religion than about who gets the good jobs. In December 2024 a row over H-1B visas split the Trump coalition: one side wanted skilled Indian workers, the other called them a threat to American jobs and culture. The Seattle and Irving protesters went further and attacked the religion itself. Indian American Republicans who post Diwali greetings have drawn racist abuse from their own side, even as the President lights the lamp in the Oval Office.

Vivek Ramaswamy speaking on stage, finger raised
Vivek Ramaswamy in July 2023. His post blaming American “mediocrity” widened the December 2024 row over skilled-worker visas. Photo: Gage Skidmore, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

The left: caste

The left’s suspicion is quieter, and harder to accept, because it comes from people who say they defend minorities. In February 2023 Seattle became the first American city to ban caste discrimination by name. California’s legislature passed a similar bill, SB 403, which Governor Newsom vetoed in October 2023, saying existing law already bars discrimination by ancestry. The California State University system added caste to its anti-discrimination policy in 2022.

Kshama Sawant speaks at a lectern, surrounded by supporters holding rent control placards
Kshama Sawant, the Seattle councilmember who sponsored the city’s caste ordinance, at a rally for her “People’s Budget”, October 2019. Photo: Seattle City Council, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.

The Seattle ordinance names no religion and covers caste in every faith. But Americans link caste with Hinduism, so to many Hindus a law against caste reads as a law about them. Supporters, among them Dalit activists and some Hindus, said caste discrimination is real in American workplaces. Hindu American groups, among them the Hindu American Foundation and the Coalition of Hindus of North America, opposed these measures, arguing that they treat Hindu Americans as suspects.

Zohran Mamdani in shirt and tie, hand on heart, greeting voters on a street in Flushing, Queens
Zohran Mamdani campaigning in Flushing, Queens, June 2025. Photo: InformedImages, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0.

Parts of the left also read Hinduism through Indian politics: Islam as the faith of a minority persecuted under Hindu nationalism, Hinduism as the faith of the government doing it. In May 2025 Zohran Mamdani, now mayor of New York, said he would not meet Narendra Modi and called him a war criminal over the 2002 Gujarat riots. On its face his quarrel is with Modi, not with Hindus; Hindu American groups called it bigotry all the same.

The people in between

Hindu American success is not mysterious. It follows the same playbook as every model minority. Asian families tend to plan in decades, not years: marriages hold, children are pushed hard, and parents learn exactly how admissions work and play them well. Call it a natural advantage or call it gaming the system; it works.

A woman at an outdoor rally holds a sign reading Harvard: Stop Asian Quota
Asian Americans rally in Copley Square, Boston, in October 2018 behind the lawsuit against Harvard’s admissions. The Supreme Court struck down race-conscious admissions at Harvard and the University of North Carolina in June 2023. Photo: Whoisjohngalt, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The numbers show the scale of that success. About half of Indian Americans are Hindu. Pew puts the median income of Indian American households at $151,200 in 2023, against about $80,600 for all American households, and finds that 77 per cent of Indian Americans aged 25 and older have a bachelor’s degree or higher (Pew). Federal figures do not count Indian Americans on their own, but the group they fall in, Asian and Pacific Islander adults, is the least imprisoned of any the Justice Department reports: in 2023, 88 per 100,000 were serving sentences of more than a year, under half the white rate of 231 (BJS). Selection plays its part: American visas favour educated, skilled migrants, so the community starts ahead.

In the Seattle Center Armory that Saturday, families were watching their children perform.

The end of the model minority?

AI threatens the pattern Asian Americans have lived by: work long hours, keep a stable home, and your children will do better than you. If a machine can write the code and pass the exam, those habits count for less, and more white Americans may decide the top jobs are open to them too. They may admire Asian families less for it. Seattle may have been an early taste of that resentment. No one can prove it yet.

Students in kurtas and saris dancing with arms raised at a Diwali celebration
Students dance at a Diwali celebration at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, October 2019. Photo: University of Michigan School for Environment and Sustainability, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.

What follows

The harder fight for Hindu Americans is likely to be with their friends. The attacks on Diwali came from outside the Democratic coalition; the fight over caste runs inside it. In October 2026, 46 per cent of Indian Americans called themselves Democrats and 19 per cent Republicans (Carnegie). Hindu American groups must make their case on caste to the party most Indian Americans support.

That party will also ask them a harder question, and they should expect it. As Hindu Americans move into the elite that runs the English-speaking world, they will be tested on one point: are they left in America and right in India? Many vote Democrat here and cheer Modi there. Carnegie’s 2020 survey found Indian Americans “more liberal on issues affecting the United States and more conservative on issues affecting India”, among them the equal protection of religious minorities (Carnegie). Even among those who disapproved of Trump, 41 per cent approved of Modi and 38 per cent disapproved. In 2024 a near majority still approved of him (Carnegie).

Indian Americans in a packed stadium cheer as a man holds up a large American flag
An American flag among the 50,000 at “Howdy, Modi!”, NRG Stadium, Houston, September 2019. Photo: The White House, Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Some of that scrutiny is fair. A community that asks America to protect its minorities will be asked how India treats its own, and India’s government is judged abroad by how it treats Muslims and Christians. Some of it is not fair. Muslim Americans who back conservative governments at home rarely face the same test; successful Hindu Americans do. That is a post for another day.

Co-AdminX.T.MX.T.M is a writer, editor, and investor working between Cambridge and the Persian Gulf.@XerxestheMagian1,007 posts →

The argument continues

3 commentslast comment
5 1 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

3 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Agni
Editor
14 hours ago

Scary. Reminds me of the time primarily in the late 80’s when a hate group called the Dotbusters was actively targeting Hindus in NJ. The name of the group referring to the bindi worn by Hindu women.

Hindus need to start fighting for themselves instead of freezing and expecting others to point out the injustice and fight on their behalf.

Last edited 14 hours ago by Agni
RecoveringNewsJunkie
RecoveringNewsJunkie
10 hours ago
Reply to  Agni

NJ has been home for decades. I think over-reacting to social media hate is unnecessary.

RecoveringNewsJunkie
RecoveringNewsJunkie
9 hours ago

>Some of that scrutiny is fair. A community that asks America to protect its minorities will be asked how India treats its own

The logic here is…questionable. To say the least.

Are Americans of Russian descent ‘responsible’ for Putin’s war in Ukraine?

Are Persian Americans ‘accountable’ for why the Iranian regime sentences women to death for refusing to wear the hijab?

This is even allowing for the questionably shaky presumption built into the insinuation.

Sorry, but this sort of ‘both sides-ing’ is incredibly silly.

Last edited 9 hours ago by RecoveringNewsJunkie
Brown Pundits
3
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x