Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

September 2018

  • American Caste (a)

    Defending his phrase ‘caucasian intelligentsia’, the author draws on Malcolm X and Muhammad Ali on the ‘white liberal’, and argues that postmodernism, a colonial tool, damages the self-confidence of Black…

    AnAn9 September 20184 comments
  • Ancient Indian Genetics At ASHG

    Previewing Niraj Rai’s ASHG poster on ancient genomes from the Indian subcontinent, the author says he is most interested in the South Indian samples, and shares a comment exchange on…

    Razib Khan8 September 201815 comments
  • Various Thoughts on Iran & Islam

    A string of thoughts on Iran and Islam: the author sees Dubai as a despotic trading hub for Asians, argues geography shapes Iranian ethno-linguistic fault lines, stresses Khorasan’s importance to…

    X.T.M8 September 201844 comments
  • “Islamic Chains”

    Prompted by Atif Mian’s removal from an advisory council, the author argues Pakistani Muslim liberals tolerate injustice yet bristle at any criticism of Islam, citing izzat and weak outrage over…

    X.T.M7 September 201832 comments
  • Perhaps India is not special in resisting Islamicization

    Reading on imperial China, the author reconsiders why India, unlike Iran, resisted total Islamicisation, arguing that Han resilience makes India less exceptional, and that conversion of some elites and oppressed…

    Razib Khan7 September 2018121 comments
  • What the f*ck is Pakistan/PTI doing

    Reacting angrily to a Facebook post about the PTI government’s agenda for Pakistani television drama, the poster calls it self-destructive and says a culture that defames martyrs to freedom such…

    X.T.M6 September 201856 comments
  • Thoughts on Section 377

    Reacting to India’s decriminalisation of homosexuality, the poster sees India and Pakistan diverging, applauds the Indian model, asks whether wealth requires being Western, and calls Western identity wars tiresome, a…

    X.T.M6 September 201852 comments
  • They make Nazis look good

    A comment on the New Yorker’s withdrawal of Steve Bannon’s debate invitation, noting that most objectors opposed debating white ethno-nationalism itself rather than the platform.

    Shafiq R6 September 20180 comments
  • Culture can be more powerful than biology

    Sharing an interview with the author of a memoir on honour in Pakistan, the geneticist author argues honour killing shows that culture and kinship incentives can override biology, since fathers…

    Razib Khan5 September 2018125 comments
  • Turan seeks peace..

    An extract from a news report that Pakistan’s army, under Gen. Qamar Javed Bajwa, quietly reached out to India about resuming peace talks and trade, and that the response was…

    X.T.M4 September 201853 comments
Brown Pundits