Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

November 2025

All years and months

  • Genetics open thread

    An open thread on two recent genetic studies, one of Kashmiris and Central Asians and one of Sri Lankans and South Indians, offered to the commentariat despite the author’s scepticism…

    BP Admin Team · opened by X.T.M2 November 20253 comments
  • The Earth’s Lost Industrial Heart

    If the Earth were one economy, where would its industrial heart be? An argument for the triangle between the Persian Gulf, the Red Sea and the Indo-Gangetic plain.

    X.T.M2 November 202519 comments
  • The hype over Yogi’s L&O record is justified

    A guest writer who was earlier critical of Yogi Adityanath’s economic record argues that his law-and-order record in Uttar Pradesh deserves the praise.

    Saiarav2 November 202518 comments
  • Islam the religion of Peace

    X.T.M notes that Malaysia’s Anwar Ibrahim brokered a ceasefire between Thailand and Cambodia, and argues that this was a case of Dharmic civilisation being helped by an Abrahamic one, adding…

    X.T.M2 November 202515 comments
  • New writing ideas

    Notes on possible future posts, including one on how the Hindu epics made geographical India into cultural India, and a commenter’s argument that coastal connectivity explains why some Indian states…

    X.T.M2 November 20250 comments
  • Zia-Era Pakistan & Today’s India

    Commenting on a reader’s dismissal of comparing Zia-era Pakistan with Modi’s India, X.T.M notes both pair economic growth with cultural conservatism, and asks whether right-wing politics is how societies answer…

    X.T.M2 November 202553 comments
  • Saffron Strike

    X.T.M reads the recent silence as a deliberate ‘Saffron Strike’, explains why he lifted Kabir’s interdiction, and says he will not interdict left-liberal authors just to bring back traffic.

    X.T.M2 November 20259 comments
  • Sunday reads

    A shared piece on Bacha Khan and the Azad School he founded in Utmanzai in 1921, with the poster’s summary of its pupils and visitors and a long quotation on…

    Furqan Ali2 November 20256 comments
  • Too Much Masala Ruins the Curry

    X.T.M says he agrees with Kabir that people should not be brought back merely as bait, but that caste, class and other structural realities are fundamental topics, and that BP’s…

    X.T.M2 November 20250 comments
  • Loki has come to Asgard once again

    X.T.M announces that Kabir has been made an editor with rights to onboard new authors, sets expectations for civil comments and no flame wars, and says he will mediate disputes…

    X.T.M2 November 202523 comments
Brown Pundits