Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Furqan Ali

Most popular · Most recent

  • Faiz, Subh-e-Azadi, and Pakistan’s 78th Birthday:

    On Pakistan’s 78th Independence Day, the author reflects on feeling little zeal for the occasion, and questions whether Faiz’s “Subh-e-Azadi” is a happy or sad poem, recalling a disagreement between…

    Furqan Ali14 August 202530 comments
  • Wag the dog?

    Playing devil’s advocate, the author argues that Pakistanis blame the military establishment for every failure, citing the false claim that half the budget goes to the army, and says that…

    Furqan Ali2 November 202526 comments
  • Budget season is here

    Reposts a column from The News International on Pakistan’s budget season, sceptical that more commentary on escaping the IMF’s conditions will change policymakers who keep the same economic management.

  • Two of my recent essays

    The author shares two essays: one on Iqbal’s birthday arguing we have misread him, and one on how book reviews and Bookstagram could build critical readership in Pakistan.

    Furqan Ali10 November 202514 comments
  • Quite Hectic Days

    Writing from fieldwork assessing the governance of 46 Pakistani universities, the author notes that universities grew from 95 to 269 and PhDs from 177 to 3,489 since 2002 without a…

  • A commentary: Ganesh, in a confectionery mill

    Furqan Ali annotates Afshan Shafi’s poem ‘Ganesh, in a confectionery mill’, reading its placing of the Hindu deity in an industrial setting as a surrealist, biting comment on consumerism, decaying…

  • Architecture of belonging

    Active Authors reposts an earlier opinion piece from The News International arguing that Pakistan’s cities are designed around men, excluding women from public and economic life, with falling female labour…

  • Sunday reads

    A shared piece on Bacha Khan and the Azad School he founded in Utmanzai in 1921, with the poster’s summary of its pupils and visitors and a long quotation on…

    Furqan Ali2 November 20256 comments
  • A flying peacock

    Furqan Ali describes seeing a peacock fly in a village near Peshawar and shares the poem it inspired.

  • Reading the Reader: On Ammar Ali Qureshi’s Views and Reviews

    Furqan Ali reviews Ammar Ali Qureshi’s Views and Reviews, a collection of essays on Punjab’s history, Pakistan, Iran and Iqbal’s love of Persia, praising its range and its melancholy portrait…

  • Two Pieces Worth Reading

    Two recommended reads: a Scroll.in review of Kabir Altaf’s book on Hindustani music in Pakistan, and a Dawn piece on the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan report about gender minorities…

    Furqan Ali14 September 20253 comments
  • Ghalib for Gen Z

    A young reader’s review of “Thinking with Ghalib” by Anjum Altaf and Amit Basole, praising its transcreations and its epistemological reading of Ghalib’s poetry as a way into a poet…

    Furqan Ali10 August 20253 comments
  • why romanticism?

    A poem defending romanticism in a capitalist, post-ideological world, with a note explaining Lacan’s “Real”.

  • Against Platonic Love

    The writer introduces an interview with the Urdu poet Ahmad Faraz, whom he ranks behind Faiz, and translates Faraz’s answer rejecting platonic love in favour of passionate, complete love for…

  • Koko, Williams, and me

    Furqan Ali shares an original poem written after watching a video of Robin Williams embracing Koko the gorilla.

  • Why Travelogues?

    A short post on why the author reads travelogues, recommending Shueyb Gandapur’s “Coming Back”, an account of a Pakistani chartered accountant’s 2017 journey through India, and asking readers for suggestions.

    Furqan Ali31 August 20251 comment
  • Obscure and Obscurity: Fatima Ijaz’s Shade of Longing

    Furqan Ali reviews Fatima Ijaz’s debut collection The Shade of Longing, reading its abstraction and repeated, unresolved lines as an indictment of language’s failure to capture memory and longing, and…

  • The Fading Red

    The author explains the context of a poem written from the perspective of The Communist Manifesto, prompted by a Žižek–Peterson debate and by memories of reading the book in 2019,…

Brown Pundits