Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Shubh Ganesh Chaturthi

X.T.M14 September 20261 min read9 comments

Co-AdminX.T.MX.T.M is a writer, editor, and investor working between Cambridge and the Persian Gulf.@XerxestheMagian995 posts →

The argument continues

9 commentslast comment
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

9 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
RecoveringNewsJunkie
RecoveringNewsJunkie
27 days ago

Until my teen years I was in Bombay, and grew up with Ganesh Chaturthi around. Still one of my favorite festivals.

Agni
Editor
27 days ago

Happy Ganesh Chaturthi to all!

Pandal hopping used to be a thing. No more with the loud ungodly music and the crowds.

If anything, I believe Vighnaharta himself will stay away given the crass commercialization of this festival.

RecoveringNewsJunkie
RecoveringNewsJunkie
26 days ago
Reply to  Agni

>Pandal hopping used to be a thing.

Yes, I have memories of doing this with friends as a middle schooler. Simpler times.

Agni
Editor
26 days ago

Touché…I miss those days…

Saat Bangla to Juhu Chowpati used to be so easy to get around and fun in those double decker buses…summer hols fun.

formerly brown
formerly brown
26 days ago

To begin with in South karnataka towns(including Bangaluru ), sarvajanik Ganapathi pendals were few, they were big (but not in Mumbai scale), they were more about providing platforms for local talent for music, classical dance, mimicry etc.
The processions were big, orderly. Everything looked rather upper crust lead , etc (well… ), provided a platform for upcoming leaders etc, while reinforcing old elite.

Now, the trend has caught on, become more “democratic”, there is jostle for leadership and more often one up manship. The appetite for lite culture has gone out, it had become very assertively awe”hindu”, giving a wider section more action and participation than before.

In between, the “masses”,had sort-of down sized the Ganapathy festival in favour of celebrating nada devates (Maari, etc) on the same metric.

Now it looks like Ganapathy has made a come back.

In Many smaller towns where there was no tradition of public Ganapathy, have become centre of brash display, polarisation, and what not.

I am sure even RSS will be ill at ease here and cannot control neither the narrative nor the action.

Need some serious society studies on these movements.

S Qureishi
S Qureishi
25 days ago

Marathis in Karachi celebrating the festival

https://x.com/Shekharcoool5/status/2100192699546788348

Last edited 25 days ago by S Qureishi
Brown Pundits
9
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x