Brown Pundits

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Open ThreadWhat’s new?56 comments · last comment agoJoin →

All posts

  • Open thread: Open Season

    Since all the other threads keep getting derailed by pointless arguing, Admin has decided to open a weekly Open thread for those discussions. This thread will be moderator free so…

    Agni29 August 2026174 comments
  • Happy Rakhi – what is a race?

    The comment thread seems to have started speculating on race and genetics. It is interesting to understand how class, colour, creed, caste, genetics and community all coincide. I may expand…

    X.T.M28 August 2026154 comments
  • Open Thread: Nepal Floods + 20 months since Assad

    It seems to be a new and very pragmatic Middle East. In a way the hybrid regimes, who don’t necessarily have democratic mandates, are able to be wily and nimble…

    X.T.M27 August 202641 comments
  • “Tamil” CMs

    Many chief ministers in the past have been of Andhra descent, representing the borderless existence of the Telugu and Tamil speaking people under the broad umbrella of Madras (presidency and…

    X.T.M27 August 202628 comments
  • Why Can’t South Asia Move On?

    Why does South Asia litigate 2,000-year-old events as though they happened yesterday? Because almost nothing is lost between generations. The cure is neither the past nor the future. It is…

    X.T.M26 August 2026315 comments
  • 3 Graphs of Karnataka

    It seems that many South Indian Muslims are “Urdufying.” It’s interesting to reflect that if Partition hadn’t happened; the same thing might have happened to East Bengal. The Muslims of…

    X.T.M24 August 202657 comments
  • Thoughts That Shape Power

    This is an essay written by Varun (Bone of Empire @BotE85371688 on Twitter), an Indian-American friend who asked me to share it on brownpundits. I think it starts an important…

    Omar Ali24 August 202635 comments
  • South India funds India?

    It’s pretty astonishing to see that it’s the Southern fringe (and the erstwhile Punjab) that’s subsidising the rest of India. There is the Southern coastal theory that AASI moved via…

    X.T.M22 August 202656 comments
  • my 7,000th comment on Brown Pundits

    I believe the number 14 is associated with Lord Ram so this is a fortuitous comment (7, 14, 1,400). I have’t written as much since the Comments have been on…

    X.T.M21 August 202635 comments
  • Open Thread: Pakistani song goes viral in India..

    I’ll expand on this but enjoy the beautiful song in the meantime.

    X.T.M20 August 20268 comments
Brown Pundits