Omar Ali
Omar Ali is a Pakistani-American physician with an interest in history and especially the history of Pakistan and the ideology of Pakistan. He used to be more active on BP, but now writes occasionally when he finds the time. He is also active on X as @omarali50.
Most popular · Most recent
-
India and Pakistan, Back to the Future..
Omar Ali sets out why Pakistan might have been behind the Pahalgam attack, or why it might not, after Pulwama and Balakot reset the red lines. He weighs the generals’…
-
Interview with Radcliffe
Omar Ali reproduces an extract from Kuldip Nayar’s book Scoop, in which Nayar recalls Cyril Radcliffe saying he nearly gave India Lahore but kept it for Pakistan because it would…
-
Rape Culture, Indian Edition
Omar Ali responds to excerpts on sexual violence against Dalit women in East Punjab, accepting that such cases occur across the subcontinent with police often another source of oppression, and…
-
Why do Muslims React More to France Than to China?
After two beheading attacks in France, the author asks why Muslim anger over perceived blasphemy is directed at France rather than China, and argues Western leaders and outlets avoid crossing…
-
Indian Religious Landscape Survey
Omar Ali invites readers to take a three-question survey on what they think will happen to India’s religious landscape and why, as input to a later post, and asks for…
-
Are the (TV) Mahabharata and Ramayan “Right Wing”?
Asks whether the 1980s Doordarshan Ramayan and Mahabharata serials paved the way for Hindu nationalism, as many Left-liberal Indians argue. The author is fascinated that this view is respectable, and…
-
Guest Post: India, a wounded civilization
Rohit Pradhan argues that the Bangalore Karachi Bakery episode, where a mob forced it to cover the Karachi name, reveals India’s psychological wounds. He blames a nihilistic nationalism that the…
-
Pakistan and India: Why Did They Diverge?
Omar Ali reproduces a Twitter thread by @FrankBullit67 on why India and Pakistan diverged after Partition, with his own comments under each section, and adds that the two may not…
-
Book Review: The Quetta Experience: A Study of Attitudes and Values Within the Pakistan Army by David O Smith
Hamid Hussain reviews David Smith’s The Quetta Experience, praising its study of the Pakistan Army’s Staff College based on American officers’ accounts from 1977 to 2014, and agreeing that fear…
-
Book Review: Dominion, by Tom Holland
Omar Ali reviews Tom Holland’s Dominion as well written and researched but ultimately Christian apologetics from a liberal angle, challenging its thesis that humanist values such as equality, care for…
-
For “Strategic Reasons”, Did Britain Want Pakistan in 1947?
An anonymous correspondent’s points, posted by Omar Ali, argue that Britain preferred a divided India for strategic reasons after 1945, with the Soviet Union ascendant and Congress refusing to grant…
-
India and Pakistan; the Fog of War
An account of the 14 February 2019 Pulwama suicide bombing, claimed by the Pakistan-based Jaish-e-Mohammed, and the escalation that followed. It sets out Masood Azhar’s history and the background to…
-
Kargil War
Omar Ali reposts his argument that Musharraf and a few cronies launched the Kargil operation without thinking it through, calling it a strategic and tactical disaster that cost hundreds of…
-
The North-West Frontier in 1947
Military historian Hamid Hussain examines frontier policy at independence in 1947, including Governor George Cunningham’s role, the order of battle and the mobilisation of Pakhtun tribesmen to attack Kashmir, a…
-
Authors, please dont post against each other
Omar Ali asks authors not to write posts against each other and to settle disputes in comments, and asks Kabir to limit himself to one post a day.
-
Book Review: The Universal History of Numbers
Omar Ali reposts a review he wrote 20 years ago of Georges Ifrah’s Universal History of Numbers, recounting how a schoolteacher’s pupils’ question about the origin of numbers sent Ifrah…
-
Allama Iqbal’s Dream Fulfilled; West Pakistan Defends India Against the Barbarians..
Omar Ali proposes that Iqbal’s 1930 idea of a northwest Muslim state defending India from invaders has proved partly right, with Pakistan a buffer against the Middle East. He argues…
-
Does India have a “once in a millennium chance”?
Omar Ali argues India has a rare chance to become a developed power because of its capable people, intact cultural strengths and the inherited machinery of the Raj, and that…
-
America’s Brilliant Strategy in Afghanistan
Major Amin argues the US exit from Afghanistan is a brilliant strategic move that leaves the problem to Pakistan, China, Russia and Iran; the poster, uneasy at such cynicism, asks…
-
What is in a Name? Al Qadir University
The author questions why Imran Khan’s Sufi-inspired university is named ‘Al-Qadir’, the name of God, when it honours Abdul Qadir Jilani, and sees it as the neo-Punjabi habit of adding…
-
Recent Spats
Omar Ali sets out house rules after recent arguments: authors may delete comments only on their own posts, personal attacks on other authors should be avoided, and no single ideology…
-
Sikh Society: forged in the frontier
Using Mackinder’s Geographical Pivot of History thesis, which he calls imperialist and reductionist yet useful, the author begins an argument that Sikh society was forged on the Punjab frontier, as…
-
Thoughts That Shape Power
In a guest essay shared by Omar Ali, Varun argues that universities and think tanks train a country’s elite, and that lax standards and borrowed Western and Soviet theories, plus…
-
USA, India, Pakistan.. an eternal prickly braid
Omar Ali argues that the US–India relationship has soured since May 2025 as Trump attacks India’s protectionism, probably over Russian oil, while Pakistan benefits. He sets out his guesses on…
-
Pakistan Elections 2018
Omar Ali previews Pakistan’s July 2018 election, arguing that the army, through its intelligence agencies and ISPR, has spent a year and a half campaigning against Nawaz Sharif and his…
-
How Pakistan Got Divided
Major Amin reviews General Rao Farman Ali’s How Pakistan Got Divided and finds it another disappointing book that whitewashes the real causes of 1971. He argues ethnicity was decisive, tracing…
-
Interview with a Mujahid: Maj Gen Tajammal Hussain Malik
An interview Major Amin conducted in 2001 with the late Maj Gen Tajammal Hussain Malik, a devout officer who planned to assassinate Zia, posted with a long introduction as a…
-
Book Review: The RigVeda
Reviews Ralph Griffith’s translation of the Rig Veda, read through selected hymns from all ten books as a window onto the Indo-European ‘heroic age’ rather than as scripture, noting the…
-
Lata Mangeshkar 1929-2022. End of an era
Omar Ali marks the death of Lata Mangeshkar, calling her the queen of Indian playback singing for over fifty years, and quotes Ishtiaq Ahmed on how old Bollywood songs preserve…
-
Review: Directorate S: The CIA and America’s Secret Wars in Afghanistan and Pakistan
Hamid Hussain reviews Steve Coll’s Directorate S as an excellent, mainly American-sourced account of the Af-Pak region, stressing that CIA-ISI relations were not black and white, that ISI is not…
-
Are Sikhs Exceptional?
Prompted by a Twitter discussion, the author relays a Mumbai doctor friend’s view that Sikhs are the only group about whom two positive generalisations can be made, that they do…
-
Book Review: The 1965 War by Shaukat Riza
Major Agha H Amin reviews Major General Shaukat Riza’s officially sponsored 1984 history of the 1965 war, judging it sanitised and uncritical but valuable for its orders of battle and…
-
The Historic Task of the Pakistani Bourgeoisie
Omar Ali argues that the Two-Nation Theory is a dangerous basis for Pakistan, and that the Pakistani bourgeoisie’s historic task is to defang it or watch the state break up.…
-
1947-48 Kashmir War
Extracts from Major Agha Humayun Amin’s history of the 1947-48 Kashmir war, arguing it was a war of lost opportunities in which Pakistan’s army was closer to victory in 1947…
-
Pakistan’s Hybrid Government and the Aasia Bibi Fiasco..
A detailed account of the Aasia Bibi case, from her 2009 arrest after a village dispute to Salmaan Taseer’s assassination and the court rulings, arguing it exposes Pakistan’s harsh blasphemy…
-
The Inward Turn: Muslim Politics in the Indian Subcontinent from the Fall of the Mughals to the Present
Omar Ali reposts, with permission, vidurascounsel’s Substack essay of 13 April 2026 on the inward turn in Muslim politics in the subcontinent. It traces the arc from Mughal decline through…
-
Book Review: The Anarchy (William Dalrymple)
A short review of Dalrymple’s The Anarchy by Major Amin, who argues the East India Company restored order in a subcontinent already in anarchy. The host adds that Dalrymple’s books…
-
Ahmedis and Pakistan. Some background..
Prompted by economist Atif Mian’s removal from Imran Khan’s advisory council, the author gives background on the Ahmedi movement: its origins in 19th-century Punjab, its role in the Pakistan movement,…
-
Nadir Ali 1936-2020, RIP
An obituary of Colonel Nadir Ali (1936-2020) by his son, recounting a Punjab childhood, helping rescue kidnapped girls during Partition, Pakistan Army service, a 1971 East Pakistan deployment that left…
-
Review: The Army and Democracy by Aqil Shah
A review of Aqil Shah’s The Army and Democracy, supplied by Major Amin, who agrees with the thesis but disputes Shah’s view of Jinnah, arguing that the 1916 Lucknow Pact…
-
Trump Finds Hafiz Saeed..
The author argues that Pakistan’s latest arrest of Hafiz Saeed on terror-financing charges is no ‘finding’ and may not last, noting the charges are unrelated to the Mumbai attacks and…
-
An Unfair Comparison: Modi and Liaqat Ali Khan
Objecting to a tweet comparing Narendra Modi with Hafiz Saeed, the author argues that Hindu nationalists want what Liaquat Ali Khan and Jinnah demanded and got: a state privileging one…
-
Afghanistan; Graveyard of Western Policy Wonks (but certainly NOT the graveyard of empires)
The author doubts that the US is consciously trapping Pakistan, China, Russia and Iran in Afghanistan, as Major Amin argues, and expects the same Western policy experts to return to…
-
Leadership in Crisis Times; Who is your Wallfacer?
Using Cixin Liu’s ‘wallfacers’ as a metaphor for leaders who act without revealing their reasoning, the author asks which world leaders handle the COVID-19 crisis well, calling Trump corrupt and…
-
Letter of General Akhtar Malik (Re Grand Slam)
A 1967 letter in which General Akhtar Hussain Malik gives his account of why he lost command during Operation Grand Slam in 1965, introduced with a short note on the…
-
Homoeroticism, Blasphemy, and Classical Muslim Society
Omar Ali posts a Twitter thread by Irfan Muzammil on homoeroticism and blasphemy in classical Muslim society, starting from the Abbasid poet Abu Nuwas, and adds his own brief comments…
-
Afghanistan, Next Round
Hamid Hussain assesses Afghanistan after the February 2020 US-Taliban agreement, arguing that disputes over prisoner exchange and ceasefire continue to stall progress, the Taliban reject ceasefire calls to keep leverage…
-
Ghaznavids from 1021 to 1186
Shares pictures from Major Amin summarising 200 years of Ghaznavid plunder and warfare, then recalls a school history teacher whose textbook listing ‘loot and plunder’ among Mahmud’s motives provoked an…
-
Book Review: The Wellington Experience
Hamid Hussain reviews David Smith’s The Wellington Experience, a study of the Indian Army’s Staff College based on interviews with US officers who attended it. He reports its main findings…
-
Chandrayaan 2; if at first you don’t succeed..
The author argues that Chandrayaan 2’s lander failure was unsurprising given how hard autonomous lunar landing is, and that after heavy national hype the setback may still feed soft power,…
-
Review: The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam
Omar Ali reviews Muhammad Iqbal’s The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam, tracing its origin in lectures given in Madras, Hyderabad and Aligarh in the late 1920s and the book’s…
-
Macaulay, Macaulayputras, and their discontents
Omar Ali pastes an X exchange on Thomas Macaulay with Sadanand Dhume and other users. He argues that schooling in Indian languages would have served India better than English-medium education,…
-
Pakistan 2022; Things fall apart?
In a BP Podcast, Omar Ali talks to Ambassador Kamran Shafi and Dr Mohammed Taqi about Pakistan’s political crisis, asking whether the army is falling apart or just having a…
-
Covid Lockdown. Some Questions
Omar Ali questions lockdown strategy by comparing responses: Pakistan’s brief, ineffective lockdown followed by a surprising slowdown in cases, India’s stricter, longer one with rising numbers, and the US’s mixed…
-
Why Did the EIC Win in India
Major Amin argues that the East India Company won in India through European-trained officers drilling native troops around a small European core, and through naval power linking its three separated…
-
Kashmir, Analysis by Dr Hamid Husain
Hamid Hussain sets out possible scenarios after India’s 5 August 2019 change to Kashmir’s status, which split off Ladakh and removed Article 35A. This is the first part; the second…
-
Did the British Divide India?
Omar Ali argues that Pakistan was ultimately the Muslim League’s creation, but that some British rulers promoted it for their own ends: divide and rule, the Congress stance in 1939,…
-
Review: The Intellectuals who Remade Asia (Pankaj Mishra)
A long, reworked chapter-by-chapter rant against Pankaj Mishra’s From the Ruins of Empire. The reviewer argues the book is not about the intellectuals who remade Asia but about post-liberal virtue…
-
Review: Persian Fire
A review of Tom Holland’s Persian Fire, a history of the Greco-Persian wars. The reviewer finds it a fun read that covers both sides well, takes a star off for…
-
Political Engineering in Pakistan. The Military View
Omar Ali posts the first part of Hamid Hussain’s essay on political engineering in Pakistan, which sets out the army’s view after Nawaz Sharif’s July 2017 disqualification, alleging military hands…
-
What Happened to the Afghan Army?
Major A. H. Amin argues that critics of the Afghan National Army forget armies take centuries to build, holding that the traditional Afghan army was destroyed by a joint US-Pakistan…
-
RIP Fahmida Riaz
A note marking the death of the poet and scholar Fahmida Riaz, remembered for her fearlessness and an Indian exile under Zia, with Hasan Mujtaba’s tribute poem and a translation…
-
Dhurandhar Review
Omar Ali gives Dhurandhar four stars out of five, reading it as an Inglorious Basterds-style revenge fantasy rather than history, praising Akshaye Khanna’s performance and the music, and noting that…
-
Review: The Anarchy, by William Dalrymple
Major Agha Amin’s longer review of Dalrymple’s The Anarchy calls the author a jester who plays to the gallery, lists alleged factual errors on dates and places, and argues the…
-
Aryan Migration and its Discontents
Recapping new genetic findings that Indo-European herders migrated into the subcontinent about 4,000 years ago, the author focuses on the politics, arguing that the Hindutva reaction to political uses of…
-
Review: Arabs. A Three Thousand Year History of Peoples, Tribes and Empires
A review of Tim Mackintosh-Smith’s Arabs, a three-thousand-year history. The reviewer praises its scope and its insistence that Arab identity, defined above all by the Arabic language, long predates Islam.…
-
Pakistan, India, Israel..
Hamid Hussain doubts rumours of an Israeli pilot in Pakistani custody and cautions against fake news in nationalist fervour, saying Israeli help to India is likelier to be technical support…
-
Why Kill Jamal Khashoggi? (A personal view from Dr Hussain)
Hamid Hussain argues the Khashoggi killing must be read as part of a struggle inside the Saudi royal family, since Khashoggi was a mild critic with links to princes sidelined…
-
Pakistan and the Great War
Hamid Hussain, marking the centenary of the Great War’s end, traces the contribution of the areas and units of future Pakistan to the Indian Army, arguing the story cannot be…
-
Review: The Spy Chronicles
Omar Ali posts Hamid Hussain’s review of The Spy Chronicles, a transcript of conversations between a former ISI chief and a former RAW chief, a book neither memoir nor theory,…
-
Book Review: Genghis Khan and the Making of the Modern World
Omar Ali reviews Jack Weatherford’s very sympathetic, easy-reading account of Genghis Khan and his descendants, and argues that Temujin refutes the idea that individuals do not matter in history, noting…
-
Soldier Sahibs-Review
A review, written for Herald magazine and reposted unedited, calls Charles Allen’s Soldier Sahibs old-fashioned and unapologetically imperialist but accurate and readable on Nicholson, Lumsden and Edwardes, while noting it…
-
Film Review: Drone
A film review of Drone by Major Agha Humayun Amin, who draws on his research since 2006. He faults the film for showing Karachi’s skyscrapers as Waziristan and Karachi accents…
-
Can India and Pakistan Make Peace?
Major Agha H. Amin’s 2013 article argues that Pakistan’s military desire for peace with India is a tactical response to US pressure over Afghanistan, as with Musharraf’s earlier overtures. The…
-
Will the Sikhs Save India?
Omar Ali explains his tweet that Sikhs might restore balance to India: he argues Sikhism is an Indic religion, with Islamicate vocabulary but not Islamic in any strong sense, and…
-
Pakistan’s Pseudo-Revolution Marches on..
The author argues that Pakistan’s army put Imran Khan in office in 2018 and that the middle class’s belief in revolution is mistaken, since GHQ wants to harden the existing…
-
Shatranj Ke KhilaRi (The Chess Players)
A review of Satyajit Ray’s Shatranj Ke Khilari, which the reviewer now finds a funny, beautifully directed period piece rather than a profound statement. He argues it is not a…
-
Sangat and Society: the Sikh remaking of the North Indian Public Sphere
The author sets Guru Nanak’s founding of Kartarpur against Babur’s invasion of Punjab in 1519, arguing that the Sikh message of community and shared worship remade the North Indian public…
-
Review: 12 Rules for Life (Jordan Peterson)
Omar Ali reviews Jordan Peterson’s 12 Rules for Life, prompted by the author’s controversy and a long library hold list. He finds the rules generally sound, if some are obvious…
-
Science in Ancient India (aka “Hindu Science”)
Omar Ali argues in his tweets that dismissing Ayurveda wholesale is itself unscientific, since its prescriptions should be tested like any other treatment while its pre-scientific framework needs translation rather…
-
Clash of two Jats in the Indian army
Hamid Hussain says the reported clash between two senior Indian Army generals was a personality dispute of little significance, but uses it to trace the officers’ family backgrounds and military…
-
Political Engineering in Pakistan Part II
Omar Ali posts Hamid Hussain’s explainer on political engineering in Pakistan before the 25 July 2018 election, written for non-Pakistanis, which opens with quotations on the failings of political leaders,…
-
Constitutional Preambles in South Asia
A comparison of the preambles to the constitutions of South Asian states, reposted from the archive.
-
Punjabi Short Story by Nadir Ali
Laid up with Covid, Omar Ali translates ‘Grapes’, a Punjabi short story by his father Colonel Nadir Ali, who wrote on Punjabi literature and culture for forty years. He notes…
-
An Extension for General Bajwa
Hamid Hussain criticises the three-year extension Imran Khan announced for army chief General Bajwa, arguing it has nothing to do with national security and is bad for both the army…
-
Review: The Forge of Christendom by Tom Holland
A review of Tom Holland’s book on Western Europe’s recovery between 900 and 1100. The reviewer finds it entertaining but one-sided, presenting Christianity as a force for good and the…
-
Pahalgam and Aftermath
Replying to a question on Twitter, the author argues the Pahalgam attack was Pakistan-backed, that the IAF underestimated Pakistan’s air force and lost aircraft on day one, and that both…
-
Capsule Review: Mythos by Stephen Fry
A capsule review of Stephen Fry’s audiobook Mythos, praised as a humorous, learned and faithful retelling of Greek myths that makes their layered origin stories coherent, with the caveat that…
-
Review: Soldier Sahibs
Omar Ali’s 2002 Herald review of Charles Allen’s Soldier Sahibs finds it an old-fashioned, unapologetically imperial but accurate and readable account of the young British officers who took the Northwest…
-
Book Review: Blood Over Different Shades of Green: East Pakistan 1971 History Revisited
Hamid Hussain reviews Ikram Sehgal and Bettina Robotka’s Blood Over Different Shades of Green, praising a candid account by an army officer of mixed Punjabi and Bengali parentage, and noting…
-
Afghan Peace Process
Hamid Hussain assesses the Afghan peace process after the first direct United States and Taliban talks, drawing on regional travel and conversations with Pakistanis, Afghans, Americans and Indians. He frames…
-
Book Review: India’s Wars. A Military History 1947-1971
A review of Air Vice Marshal Arjun Subramaniam’s military history of India’s wars from 1947 to 1971. The reviewer finds it a pretty good summary, strong on the air force…
-
East Pakistan 1971
Prompted by Dawn’s summary and an Ahsan Butt article, the author gives his own view of 1971 in East Pakistan, covering the disputed death toll, Pakistani denial and Bengali reprisals…
-
Quick Review: Shahab Ahmed, What is Islam
Omar Ali reposts an old review of Shahab Ahmed’s What Is Islam?, finding the book unclear about its aim but a good rebuttal to monochrome views of Islam. His verdict…
-
ZA Bhutto Founds the Pakistan People’s Party in Lahore
Omar Ali reposts Hasan Mujtaba’s Facebook account of how Zulfikar Ali Bhutto founded the Pakistan People’s Party in Lahore, including the origin of its slogan and Bhutto’s later falling-out with…
-
Artificial Intelligence? A comment.
Shares a friend’s tweet on whether machines can be intelligent and adds a reply. It argues reasoning models and agents are advancing fast, but that machine intelligence will be fundamentally…
-
An Indian, a Pakistani and a World Bank guy talk Afghanistan
A BP podcast in which two hosts and Karol Karpinski, a World Bank ‘financial plumber’ with Afghan experience, discuss Afghanistan and the American pullout; the host’s own summary of events…



















































