Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Lahnda

  • Pakistan Has a Dosa and Nobody Told You

    “We Saraiki people make dosa,” my Urdu teacher told me. “We have a name for it: chilla.” A rice batter spread on a tawa and eaten with winter saag, in…

    X.T.M18 September 202611 comments
  • How Pakistan Punjabified Lahnda and Urdufied Punjab

    As Pakistan prepares to debate new provinces, X.T.M asks what Punjab is. He argues that colonial canals, Partition and the census folded Grierson’s Lahnda continuum into “Punjabi”, while the south…

    X.T.M14 September 202695 comments
  • Suno Punjab

    Watching the Pakistani drama Suno Chanda, the author hears Punjabi at length for the first time and asks why it is treated as a rustic Urdu, then explores the Lahnda-Eastern…

    X.T.M28 August 201836 comments
  • The Siraiki question

    Arguing the Siraiki language is the key question, the author sees Punjabi as a Hindawi pushback into the Lahnda-speaking West, notes Hindko and Siraiki as Lahnda remnants, and says a…

    X.T.M28 July 20182 comments
Brown Pundits