Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Hindutva

  • Why India looks West not East

    Answering Razib’s question on why India does not look towards China, the author offers three reasons: Sindhi diaspora ties, lingering colonial institutions, and the claim that India’s high culture was…

    X.T.M10 September 201849 comments
  • Genetics stories in India Today

    Shares an extract from an India Today piece on 4,500-year-old DNA from Rakhigarhi, adding that many Hindu nationalists are unperturbed by such findings and that the paper’s publication is still…

    Razib Khan31 August 201864 comments
  • Hinduism was not invented by the British (or Muslims)

    Disagreeing with the view that Hindu identity was manufactured by colonialism or by Muslims, the author argues Megasthenes, al-Biruni and Faxian already saw Indians as a distinct people, and that…

    Razib Khan15 August 201866 comments
  • Genetics is not about “dunking” on Hindu nationalists

    The author, a geneticist, says geneticists are not out to debunk Hindu nationalists, criticises anti-nationalist triumphalism that misreads the science, argues the Indo-Aryans were highly Indianised by the time their…

  • BJPization of Dalits

    X.T.M, with a deliberately provocative title, reads the Karnataka result as Dalit voters moving behind the BJP, and speculates that Hindutva, if it ended caste hierarchy, might be welcome, while…

    X.T.M17 May 201832 comments
  • Post Modernism in India

    A reader, froginthewell, answers why the BJP does little about alleged discrimination against Hindus, pointing to minority-affairs funding, namaz spaces and textbooks, and argues that politicians balance interest groups and…

    AnAn13 May 201814 comments
  • Can Hinduism Survive?

    Asking whether Hinduism can survive, the author contrasts liberal Hindus who say it is not in danger with Hindu nationalists who often fear that better-organised Abrahamic religions are taking over…

    Omar Ali25 March 20180 comments
  • Indian Diplomats in Pakistan harassed

    X.T.M quotes a report of Indian diplomats being harassed in Islamabad, then reflects on apologising for one’s community’s failings, contrasting Pakistani and Hindu defensiveness and tying right-wing Hindu mobilisation to…

    X.T.M18 March 201822 comments
  • Counter factual

    X.T.M poses a counterfactual: would a typical Shudra peasant in UP be better off today without British rule, without Turkish incursion, or if Ashoka had replaced Hinduism with Buddhism, noting…

    X.T.M14 February 201813 comments
  • Fair & Lovely

    X.T.M criticises the choice of a white egg donor for a Bollywood director’s children, arguing it sends a ‘white is right’ message in a colour-conscious society and contrasts with Hindutva’s…

    X.T.M7 February 201816 comments
Brown Pundits