Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Rig Veda

  • The Unravelling of the AMT

    The author argues that the textual evidence of the Rigveda, centred on Punjab, Haryana and western Uttar Pradesh, gives no support to an extra-Indian Aryan homeland. He challenges Vagheesh Narasimhan’s…

  • Memory outlives flesh

    Answering why Indo-Aryans dominate debate despite contributing perhaps 10 to 30 per cent of northern South Asian ancestry, the author argues through St Perpetua and Polish Catholics that language and…

  • The Vedic People: Their History and Geography

    A recommendation of Rajesh Kochhar’s The Vedic People: Their History and Geography, called short, dense and impressive in command of scholarship, though not to be taken as gospel.

    Razib Khan14 February 201923 comments
  • Afghanistan’s History

    The author gathers proposed etymologies for Afghanistan’s name, from ‘Upa-Gana-stan’ to Panini’s Ashvakana, and repeats a linked article’s claims that Pashtuns descend from Vedic tribes and that Hindu rulers and…

    AnAn14 July 2018140 comments
  • Book Review: The RigVeda

    Reviews Ralph Griffith’s translation of the Rig Veda, read through selected hymns from all ten books as a window onto the Indo-European ‘heroic age’ rather than as scripture, noting the…

    Omar Ali11 January 201831 comments
  • Aryan Migration and its Discontents

    Recapping new genetic findings that Indo-European herders migrated into the subcontinent about 4,000 years ago, the author focuses on the politics, arguing that the Hindutva reaction to political uses of…

  • A Glance at the AIT, OIT, Rig Veda..

    Not a Vedic scholar, the author shares first impressions from reading selected Rig Veda hymns in Ralph Griffith’s translation as a window onto the Indo-European world, and invites readers to…

    BP Admin Team · opened by Omar Ali12 June 20170 comments
Brown Pundits