
Since Sbarrkum (Sereno), RIP, had such passionate views about the post-colonial setup, I thought the first post after his obituary would be on this topic. In Memoriam to all the victims of 9/11 and its aftermath. May they all rest in Peace.
Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin and Masoud Pezeshkian sat in the same hall in Delhi this morning while an American fleet blockaded Iran’s coast.
Narendra Modi opened the 18th BRICS summit at Bharat Mandapam by saying the grouping is “not against anyone“. Xi had landed a few hours earlier, on his first visit to India in seven years. Prabowo Subianto came for Indonesia, the country that hosted Bandung. Abdel Fattah el-Sisi came for Egypt. The UAE was in the room, and so was Iran, which the UAE cut off from trade and finance in August after Iranian missiles landed on Emirati soil.
The New Delhi Declaration went to the wire because Tehran and Abu Dhabi both dug in. It passed on the first day. Pezeshkian said on his way to Delhi that the BRICS bank exists to free countries from the dollar. Modi used his closing remarks to say that outdated institutions cannot steer a changed world. Two men in one building, each alluding to the same hopes from a GS (Goldman Sachs) derived acronym for GS (Global Southern) based organisation (the irony). BRICS is the new non-aligned movement reborn except there is now only one hegemony to be non-aligned against.
The hurried decapitation that failed
On 28 February the United States and Israel struck Iran. Regime change was the stated aim. Ali Khamenei died in the strikes. In January, protests had spread across the country with Washington’s open encouragement. By every Western model the Islamic Republic should have fallen by March. It did not. Mojtaba Khamenei is Supreme Leader. Pezeshkian is in Delhi.
Iranians are suffering greatly. The rial was in free fall before the first bomb. But the state survived a killed leader, an uprising and a naval blockade. The Islamic Republic was never plugged into the global economy the way Dubai or Riyadh is. Sanctions since 1979 had already cut most of what could be cut. Iran came into this war poorer for it, and harder to shock. The sanctions built a fortress by accident, and in 2026 the fortress seems to have held.
The failed ceasefire that was made in Islamabad
Pakistan brokered the first pause on 8 April. JD Vance and Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf then sat across a table in Islamabad, the highest direct contact between the two states since 1979. The talks failed, the blockade came, and the talking carried on. On 12 June Shehbaz Sharif announced the final text. On 14 June Vance and Ghalibaf signed it electronically. On 17 June Donald Trump signed it at dinner with Emmanuel Macron at Versailles, Pezeshkian signed in Tehran, and Sharif’s name went on it as well. Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Egypt helped in the wings. The document has fourteen points, runs to a page and a half by Vance’s own description, and is called the Islamabad Memorandum. A billboard in Islamabad showed Sharif and Asim Munir under the words “the nation is grateful“. Now Asim Munir wants to spend that dividend on a 28th Amendment that redraws the provinces of Pakistan.
Trump declared it over on 8 July after Iran fired on ships in Hormuz. It lapsed in August. On 3 September Iranian missiles hit bases in Kuwait and the UAE, and Vance told reporters he would not call it a war.
Twenty-five years ago this week Pakistan was told it was with the United States or against it, and it chose the only option on offer. In 2026 the same state wrote the ceasefire between the United States and Iran and signed it as a party. Pakistan was one of the five governments that convened Bandung in 1955. It took seventy-one years to act like one.
On the eve of 9/11 the United States stood at the height of its prestige and its power. Twenty-five years on, misadventures in the Greater Middle East (Afghanistan, Iraq and Iran) have cost it both.
The Ummah’s quarrels are its own
The UAE has severed Iran. Iranian missiles have hit Riyadh and the Ras Tanura refinery, and Saudi jets have quietly struck launch sites inside Iran and militias in Iraq. On 8 September the Houthis hit oil facilities in the Saudi south and wounded 73 people.
Hormuz is near shut, so Saudi crude had been leaving through Yanbu on the Red Sea, about five million barrels a day. On Thursday drones launched from Iraq hit the pipeline that feeds Yanbu, and on Friday Riyadh shut it. Regional officials say the Houthis helped plan the strike. The Houthis now hold Yemen’s whole western coast and Mayun island in Bab al-Mandeb, the exit for whatever Yanbu still ships (Asir, Jizan and Najran were Yemen until the Treaty of Taif in 1934).
Pakistan, bound to Riyadh by the defence pact the two signed last September, stands with the Saudis on paper and hosts Tehran’s negotiators in person.
This is what post-coloniality looks like from inside. The old order gave Muslim states two roles, client and target. In 2026 they are choosing their own enemies. The right to fight each other without permission is a poor kind of freedom, and it is the only kind any post-colonial state has ever started with. India and Pakistan can confirm.
The West’s favourite non-Western power
On 17 June, the day Trump signed the Islamabad Memorandum at Versailles, Modi was at the G7 in Evian shaking his hand. India can do that. India can dissent from the West and stay inside the system. Iran cannot. Rajiv Bhatia, a former Indian ambassador, described Delhi’s BRICS posture this week as non-Western rather than anti-Western, and the phrase is exact. India chairs BRICS, thanks Xi for his support, buys Russian oil and stays welcome in the G7. Chietigj Bajpaee at Chatham House reads the last year as Delhi reinvesting in other relationships after strains with Trump. Reinvesting is a banker’s word.
India’s post-coloniality is licensed. It was earned at Bandung. The Ummah’s version is unlicensed, and it is paid for in a Hormuz that nobody controls. The rivalry in that hall was between two kinds of post-colonial, the approved and the unapproved.
Taste follows power
Post-coloniality arrives in stages: foreign policy first, then war, then aspiration, then taste. The elites of the Muslim world remain, in Jalal Al-e Ahmad’s word from 1962, gharbzadeh, westoxicated. I use the Persian because English has nothing as precise. The condition now lives in wardrobes and holiday plans rather than in parliaments. Modernity was sold to the global South as a lifestyle, and the lifestyle was measured by the ability to spend August in Paris.
The condition is most acute in the small Gulflet states the Great Powers dreamt up. The Arab states, which could have been one nation, were splintered instead and taught to take their taste from Western high culture. This may change.
A Saudi family that spends €15,000 in Paris can spend €5,000 in Istanbul and may have a better holiday culturally. Istanbul and Sarajevo already fill with Gulf families every summer. When enough of the South reroutes its August, the West stops being the place you arrive at once you have made it. London luxury houses already depend on Chinese, Gulf and Indian buyers. The hall in Delhi this morning was the political half of that switch. The shopping bag half is coming. Gharbzadegi ends at a till in Istanbul.

this piece was a reflection on a post 9/11 world..
Enjoyed reading the piece XTM.
The pieces on the geopolitical chessboard are moving at a pace nobody could have foreseen. I do see the clear emergence of a post-US world. The US is more fractured politically possibly for the first time since the Civil war. I’m just surprised nobody outside is capitalizing on the opportunity to deepen the fractures within.
India’s done well to seamlessly move across the Western and Eastern blocs. Much to the annoyance of the US, but who cares. BRICS is moving from strength to strength. They are approaching the situation cautiously, which is the right thing to do. West Asia, Asia, Africa and Russia have the most to lose in the current Iran fracas. Isolate the bully gradually and tighten the screws. Perhaps Xi finally sees the short term (if not long term) benefit in allying with Indian Russia on this.
yes I agree with that; I think PM Modi is definitely a very deft diplomat.
Modi is outfoxing the traps that fell IG(Punjab) and PN (China). He seems to have lost ground when tackling the Mandal quagmire. Lets see. No wonder this piece like most western gazes kvetches that India got licensed whereas Ummah’s is unlicensed. That glib sentence does a lot of work to hyphenate chalk and cheese.
Mandal quagmire?
what was so problematic about that sentence?
Your piece says that India is allowed/licensed to act as loyal opposition whereas the Ummah is not. Removes agency from both India/Hindus and Ummah on how they have responded.
Its important to remember that the status of India as being some kind of a licensed operator going both sides is hard fought and has to be constantly maintained. The reason it stays that way is that the Indians are willing to go through sanctions, and tariffs in ways no other country of its economic size can. This forces the west to either acknowledge India’s ability which it doesn’t want to do unless under duress therefore they act as though India’s autonomy is a function of their permission and not its own capabilities.
Our genius ex RBI governor Raghuram Rajan in his lalantop interview was asking why should India become a superpower? to bully others? He is clearly drawn from the retarded three quarters of the Tam Brams stock.
As India becomes rich and therefore leveraged, and as our export markets inevitably grow more and more dependent on the West, its sovereignty will be compromised.
Pakistan is a key, India should do shadow boxing with Pakistan for as long as possible. So that the great powers think India is boxed in and don’t actively work against India.
Hopefully India’s coming generations will be more industrious than the torpid billion alive today.
Even if we had a free run, militarily speaking, Indian armed forces have barely any expeditionary experience. Glorified colonial armed police, meant to keep a docile continent together. India’s army could not enforce it’s will on Sri Lanka.
I heavily doubt Rajan’s statements after he retired as RBI governor. They are more of political signaling than any real policy recommendations. He was a relatively competent RBI governor and I think its sad that he has to tow the Congress party line even in interviews when he clearly knows better for the sake of any relevance.
You know what compromises you sovereignty even more? Poverty, any citizen of the country will become a spy for a foreign govt for the right price if they aren’t living with an acceptable standard of living. Hell we’ve had RAW chiefs fleeing to America, if anything have more money will lead to more sovereignty not less.
They already are. That doesn’t even need to be debated, if in a decade or so a state like UP turns around to a net contributor instead of net recipient of aid from the center it will be a massive change in fortunes.
+1
Valid point.
https://theprint.in/national-interest/brics-india-china-russia-narendra-modi-xi-jinping-vladimir-putin/3040723/
Sorry for bringing in Guptaji once again.
## All governments, especially strongman-led, use summiteering for image-building. The Modi government has turned it into an art form. But, with BRICS, the elements don’t come together given its composition, balance, and contradictions.
The three strongmen in this breathless buildup share more contradictions than congruence. Each has a different worldview, as also a different adversary. Russia is China’s ally—dependent, too, to some extent. India sees China as an existential adversary. And China sees the other two as so weak that it can determine the rules of the game, and be the umpire; first, second and third.##
Well if china being richer, should lead, but we see no signs of it. It acts more like a bully.
I feel the original 5 should have not allowed anyone else into the group and become a compact trading community.
Now it is a talking club. But at least countries are meeting on the sidelines.
KSA (not part of the group )met Iran, etc.
India should become rich or very powerful irrationally.
it’s good for BRICS to bring in significant members.
Apparently China and Philippines having a very tough time in the South China Sea.
Very interesting
– Iranians are meeting kashmiri religious leaders.
Malaysian leader is meeting keralam Muslim leader.
Iran President met acharya balkrishna as well. Mahatir met RG and PG. 🤷♂️.
I’m sure Iran and Malaysia are top sponsors of CAA/shaheenbhag, farm protests and recently CJP and RHA protests.
I think these meetings are done under the watchful eyes of Indian govt. We shouldn’t pointlessly bristle at each turn and learn to trust the people in charge with their decisions.
Sarcasm 🤦♂️
Tbf its hard to sense sarcasm through text.
Ack.
This might be a very +ve development. I think the Iranians have some real influence there and they should leverage it if they can. Somehow I have more faith in the mullah’s to act for net mutual benefit than the other actors in the valley.
Malaysia I am not so sure, it has heavy influence of Chinese organised crime, hard to read.
Anwar is a convicted homosexual. Malaysian politics are just too volatile and kaleidoscopic to really comprehend.
Mahatir has Malyali ancestry although denied by him publically, probably for his politics of identifying as a bhumiputra.
Whatever ancestry he has, it’s got some high quality telomeres keeping him preternaturally young.
I had no idea he was still alive – wow
I think the idea is that Muslim and Maleness qualifies for that so presumably if Indian Muslims identify as Malay?
I’m not certain.
Very interesting indeed. There’s always been a connect between Kashmir and Iran.
The Malay politician met him while specifically saying he doesn’t agree with all his religious views. The disclaimer was pertinent.
I doubt Pakistan would do this.
Most definitely not! That is lovely gesture.
My Iranian friend has a small Ganesha gifted to him by a friend. He also wouldn’t hesitate to take the prasad post a Puja. Another Iranian friend loves her Durga pujas! She ended up marrying a Bengali!! Neither of these were the westernized expats.
In fact, the strongest resistance I’ve seen to even seemingly innocuous participation in Hindu functions were from Malays and recent S Korean converts.
Another example of FUD that seems to be afflicting some bjp/rw supporters. Folks don’t seem to realize the precarious situation that India is facing with respect to urea and energy supplies. They would rather India sign up to vassalage. For example ex imf economist complains that BRiCS-China share of global income/trade has decreased by roughly half a percentage point since 2011. He did not bother to look that the same data shows G7-US has shrunk from ~36% to ~18%.
people will get what they vote for and if current trends continue they will get it good.
Upper Caste BJP/RWs B-pillers are rightly called Bh*sa*a pillers. These people are always bitching and complaining even while being on the top of food-chain and having the best possible government their numbers allow. These people deserve PM Rahul Gandhi. Atleast their tears and wailing then will provide succor to the rest of us.
I always have some doubts regarding the actual intentions of such folks as they seem to do nothing but insult the BJP for no good reason with no real alternative platform of their own. If they had at least a couple principled position I’d at least be tempted to agree with them. But as of now they’re just the Congress B-team.
They are Bho***a pillers, period. There is nothing deeper than this politically, psychologically maybe there is some sexual frustration, or insecurity, or emotional block, but absolutely no principled arguments anywhere, just complains.
Gupta is an American shill, btw I am somewhat pro-America. China is not India’s existential enemy yet. Enemy yes, but Chinese don’t intend to mutilate India. Gupta and his incompetent political editor DK Singh pray for a hung parliament and resumed access.
Prakash Belawadi said something on the lines on Indians survived by fooling the white colonizer by pretending to be snake charmers and contortionists…
India plays intricate games, I feel like India does this on purpose to spoil the efforts of US, Europe, and China. India has no intention of giving away any concession, and subtly works to clog the machinery of all global organizations. Trump’s America has started to see through this (again), Russians always saw through this and focussed on selling stuff never immigration or other deeper ties, China who behave worse than Indians saw through this even before India thought about it. China plays a different game altogether : they are making alternatives to the UN and accepts India wasting their time as cost of doing business.
You are underestimating the penetration/sellout on both sides of the establishment.