Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Open ThreadWhat’s new?81 comments · last comment agoAdd your thoughts →

Geopolitics, security and conflict

Inter-state relations, wars, militaries and world affairs.

  • Izzat Maxing

    X.T.M answers Q’s claim that India–Pakistan wars will stay short, arguing that allies matter only for the fifth day. He tests this against 1971, Kargil, Operation Sindoor and the Gulf…

    X.T.M30 September 202616 comments
  • Racial curve fitting analysis

    Indosaurus questions the popular claim that Arab culture explains Arab military defeats, noting that the same traits appear in Japanese corporate life and that Houthis and Hezbollah have outperformed. He…

    Indosaurus23 September 202671 comments
  • Xi, Putin and Pezeshkian Walk Into Delhi

    X.T.M reads the BRICS summit in Delhi, with Xi, Putin and Pezeshkian present during a US blockade of Iran, as the West’s non-Western partners rerouting around it. He sees BRICS…

    X.T.M12 September 202633 comments
  • Open Thread: Nepal Floods + 20 months since Assad

    Open Thread, 27 August 2026. X.T.M opens by suggesting that Middle Eastern hybrid regimes balance the great powers nimbly, while democracies such as Israel and India pursue grander foreign policies,…

    X.T.M27 August 202641 comments
  • The Failure of Pakistani Alliances & The Instability of the Middle East

    0M-3 examines why alliances involving Pakistan, CENTO, SEATO and the recent Saudi Arabia and Turkey pacts, have failed, arguing that regional infighting and diverging interests, not colonial-drawn borders, are the…

    0M-310 August 202657 comments
  • Bangladesh-India Open Thread

    A reproduced news report, source not named, on Bangladesh’s anger at India for letting the ousted Sheikh Hasina address journalists in New Delhi; the post is titled an open thread…

    X.T.M8 August 202623 comments
  • Open Thread – Iran & CJP

    Open thread from X.T.M on the war in Iran and the continuing CJP protests in India, asking about Sonam Wangchuk and why the Education Minister has not resigned, with praise…

    X.T.M24 July 202646 comments
  • Reading Dawn in Delhi.

    X.T.M reports Beena Sarwar’s talk at Mela Nordic’s Stockholm Partition event, tracing the end of Aman ki Asha to Sapan, a volunteer network with a minimum common agenda that bans…

    X.T.M7 July 20263 comments
  • The Meltwater Carries No Passport

    X.T.M reports Anuradha Bhasin’s talk at Mela Nordic’s Stockholm Partition event, which proposed cross-border newsrooms, a shared archive and arts as empathy, and weighs it against earlier attempts such as…

    X.T.M5 July 202621 comments
  • Geography is Power

    A reply to X.T.M’s post, this essay argues from realism that geography has shaped South Asian states’ trajectories, citing Mackinder and Spykman, Pakistan’s Cold War and GWOT frontier role, and…

    0M-31 July 20268 comments
Brown Pundits