Brown Pundits

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Open ThreadWhat’s new?76 comments · last comment agoJoin →

India

  • Why India will not lose her soul to missionaries

    X.T.M argues that India will not lose its Hindu soul to missionaries, because societies are shaped by elites, not headcount, and India’s elite is not converting. He starts from a…

    X.T.M6 September 202698 comments
  • Parsis, DNA and steppe incursions

    Indosaurus announces his long-promised article on Parsi matrilineal DNA and steppe ancestry, published on his Substack, and hopes Zoroastrians and Hindus can reclaim the name Aryan from racists.

    Indosaurus3 September 202694 comments
  • FlyDie on South India

    X.T.M reposts FlyDie’s comments on South India. FlyDie argues that Tamil Nadu’s elite traces to Telugu country through the Vijayanagara Nayaks, that pre-colonial empires ran on a shared elite culture,…

    FlyDie30 August 202660 comments
  • Are All Postcolonial Nations Brahmanical Constructs?

    X.T.M asks whether postcolonial states are Brahmanical constructs, arguing that every successor elite preserves the borders it inherits. He draws on caste mobility, Sanskritisation and Radcliffe’s line, and notes the…

    X.T.M30 August 202623 comments
  • Open Thread: Nepal Floods + 20 months since Assad

    Open Thread, 27 August 2026. X.T.M opens by suggesting that Middle Eastern hybrid regimes balance the great powers nimbly, while democracies such as Israel and India pursue grander foreign policies,…

    X.T.M27 August 202641 comments
  • “Tamil” CMs

    X.T.M, drawing on a News18 blog, notes that many Madras chief ministers were of Telugu descent, from Subbarayalu Reddiar onwards, and sees Tamil Nadu’s “distinct” identity as compatible with a…

    X.T.M27 August 202628 comments
  • 3 Graphs of Karnataka

    X.T.M observes from three graphs of Karnataka that many South Indian Muslims seem to be “Urdufying”, and wonders whether East Bengal might have followed a linguistic path to Urdu and…

    X.T.M24 August 202657 comments
  • Thoughts That Shape Power

    In a guest essay shared by Omar Ali, Varun argues that universities and think tanks train a country’s elite, and that lax standards and borrowed Western and Soviet theories, plus…

    Omar Ali24 August 202635 comments
  • South India funds India?

    X.T.M comments on a chart suggesting the southern states and the old Punjab subsidise the rest of India, links the south’s position to Partition’s contest over rich regions, and compares…

    X.T.M22 August 202656 comments
  • Did the British Divide India?

    Omar Ali argues that Pakistan was ultimately the Muslim League’s creation, but that some British rulers promoted it for their own ends: divide and rule, the Congress stance in 1939,…

    Omar Ali19 August 202618 comments
Brown Pundits