Brown Pundits

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Open ThreadWhat’s new?78 comments · last comment agoJoin →

India

  • India vs. Pakistan in one graph

    X.T.M argues that GDP per capita, not total GDP, is the right India–Pakistan comparison. India overtook Pakistan after 2009, he says, because Pakistan’s higher fertility grew its population faster, while…

    X.T.M18 August 202633 comments
  • 80 achievement of the Modi government on the 80th Independence Day 2026

    Calvin D’Souza, in his first post, lists what he calls 80 undeniable achievements of the Modi government for Independence Day 2026, from the national grid, trade deals and ports to…

  • Not yet a requiem for the Deities of rural India

    Indosaurus argues that folk Hinduism, practised mainly by lower castes and centred on sacrifice and possession, is more exposed than its scriptural form to conversion, Sanskritisation and urbanisation, and fears…

    Indosaurus14 August 202658 comments
  • The Lutyens Brahmin & the Indian Muslim

    X.T.M borrows the Boston Brahmin to describe India’s apex elite, admitted by assimilation, presentation and marriage, and asks whether the new Hindu order’s explicit loyalty tests for Indian Muslims expose…

    X.T.M9 August 2026205 comments
  • The Brahmin Civil War

    Pattanaik gives us a priesthood in service — Baniya capital commanding, Brahmin ideology obeying. Look closer at the temple queue: the priesthood is in schism. Hindutva as an upper-caste revolt…

    X.T.M8 August 2026104 comments
  • Bangladesh-India Open Thread

    A reproduced news report, source not named, on Bangladesh’s anger at India for letting the ousted Sheikh Hasina address journalists in New Delhi; the post is titled an open thread…

    X.T.M8 August 202623 comments
  • Qawwali in Chennai

    X.T.M notes the launch of the Unruly Bodies Art Exhibition in Chennai, with Tamil, Sanskrit and Hindi heard, and a friend’s correction that the music was Carnatic rather than Hindustani.

    X.T.M7 August 20265 comments
  • For Gandhiji

    Indosaurus, once unconvinced of Gandhi’s importance, defends him against attacks from the liberal left, which Indosaurus argues lack context, and links a longer Substack defence of his most contested behaviour…

  • 30 seconds please

    k jayas’s open thread of four quick takes: a JNU professor’s 30-second TV interjections, a BJP spokesperson’s resignation, Modi’s Instagram presence and Rahul Gandhi’s street theatre, plus an admin note…

    k jayas1 August 202665 comments
  • What would Braj Pradesh look like?

    In 1961 ten mother tongues were grouped under Hindi. In 1971 the grouping widened to forty-eight, and Hindi’s share of India rose from 30 to 37 per cent in a…

    X.T.M31 July 202627 comments
Brown Pundits