<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	>

<channel>
	<title>History &#8211; Brown Pundits</title>
	<atom:link href="https://www.brownpundits.com/category/history/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link>https://www.brownpundits.com</link>
	<description>A discussion of all things Brown..</description>
	<lastBuildDate>Mon, 09 Nov 2026 23:26:09 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<language>en-US</language>
	<sy:updatePeriod>
	hourly	</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>
	1	</sy:updateFrequency>
	<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4</generator>

 
	<item>
		<title>Where Punjab Ends: What the 1947 Map Shows</title>
		<link>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/11/09/where-punjab-ends-1947-map/</link>
					<comments>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/11/09/where-punjab-ends-1947-map/#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 09 Nov 2026 09:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Colonial era]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics and public life]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Bahawalpur]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[british raj]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Haryana]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Himachal Pradesh]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Multan]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Partition]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Punjab]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Punjabi]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Saraiki]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.brownpundits.com/?p=26474</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[In Cholistan, Marwari has become a Hindu identity and Seraiki a Muslim one. A 1947 map shows where Punjab’s rivers, speech and borders part.]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Everyone knows that Marwari and Seraiki are different languages. In Cholistan, the desert of the old Bahawalpur State, they have also become labels of religion. Marwari has become a Hindu identity and Seraiki a Muslim one, whatever a family speaks at home: the Hindus call themselves Marwari and speak Seraiki, and their Muslim kin call themselves Seraiki and still speak Marwari among their own. As <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/04/03/cholistan-the-desert-at-the-edge-of-everything/">I wrote in April</a>, Hindus and Muslims there are hard to tell apart; the name of a language is now how they do it. Is either of them Punjabi?</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal.jpg"><img fetchpriority="high" decoding="async" width="1024" height="768" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-1024x768.jpg" alt="A still green canal with reeds and a dirt road along it, trees and fields beyond, under a pale sky" class="wp-image-28345" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-1024x768.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-300x225.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-768x576.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-1536x1152.jpg 1536w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal.jpg 2048w" sizes="(max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" /></a><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">A canal in my Urdu teacher’s village in Cholistan, November 2026. Photo: my Urdu teacher</figcaption></figure>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">A reader posted a map in our WhatsApp group in October: “Pre-Independence Punjab, Partitioned in 1947”, with Dera Ghazi Khan and Multan circled in red. His father’s family is from Bahawalpur State and his mother’s from Montgomery. Another reader said his family spoke Seraiki. I sent the same map to my Urdu teacher, a Seraiki speaker, and he picked out “Bahawalpur state” at once. The question underneath was the same one: which parts of that outline are actually Punjab?</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">My teacher has a stake in the answer. He is from Rajanpur, at the bottom of the province, and I wrote in September about <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/18/pakistan-has-a-dosa-and-nobody-told-you/">the rice-flour dosa his family eats with saag</a>. In 1947 Rajanpur was a tehsil of Dera Ghazi Khan district, one of the two circled on the map. His family moved to the city from Cholistan, and they are the Muslims of the opening. In a class on 6 November he told me that they call themselves Seraiki, that his grandfather spoke Marwari, and that they still speak a mixed Marwari with their own community. The Hindus, he said, call themselves Marwari and speak Seraiki. When I sent him <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/14/how-pakistan-punjabified-lahnda-and-urdufied-punjab/">my September post on Lahnda</a>, he translated it into Urdu for his family group, and wrote back that the regional languages are part of the culture and should be kept.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-road.jpg"><img decoding="async" width="1024" height="768" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-road-1024x768.jpg" alt="A dirt road on a canal bank, with low green bushes on one side and fields on the other, under a blue sky" class="wp-image-28346" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-road-1024x768.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-road-300x225.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-road-768x576.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-road-1536x1152.jpg 1536w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/cholistan-canal-road.jpg 2048w" sizes="(max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" /></a><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">The canal road in the same village. Photo: my Urdu teacher</figcaption></figure>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">That Lahnda post was about what happened inside the box: the canal colonies, Partition and the census. In 2019 I asked whether the British, entering from Bengal, <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2019/04/29/did-the-brits-indianise-the-northwest/">re-Indianised the north-west</a>, and Major Amin’s <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2019/04/30/review-the-garrison-state-military-government-and-society-in-colonial-punjab-1849-1947/">review of The Garrison State</a> took up what the colonial Punjab was for: the army’s recruiting ground.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">How the Punjab was Colonised</h2>



<figure class="wp-block-table"><table><thead><tr><th>Year</th><th>Move</th><th>Effect on the map</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>1849</td><td>Annexation of the Sikh kingdom after the Second Anglo-Sikh War</td><td>The rest of the Lahore kingdom, from the Sutlej to the Indus and its lands beyond it, joins the cis-Sutlej tracts the Company already held as the Punjab</td></tr><tr><td>1858</td><td>The Delhi territory transferred from the North-Western Provinces after the rebellion</td><td>Delhi, Gurgaon, Rohtak, Hisar, Karnal and Sirsa join the Punjab</td></tr><tr><td>1901</td><td>North-West Frontier Province created</td><td>Peshawar, Hazara, Kohat, Bannu and Dera Ismail Khan leave; Dera Ghazi Khan, also across the Indus, stays</td></tr><tr><td>1912</td><td>Delhi made a separate province for the new capital</td><td>The Delhi enclave leaves</td></tr></tbody></table></figure>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-divisions-1947.png"><img decoding="async" width="1024" height="785" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-divisions-1947-1024x785.png" alt="Map of the Punjab province with its divisions labelled, 1947" class="wp-image-26472" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-divisions-1947-1024x785.png 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-divisions-1947-300x230.png 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-divisions-1947-768x589.png 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-divisions-1947-1536x1178.png 1536w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-divisions-1947.png 1953w" sizes="(max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" /></a><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">The British divisions of the Punjab in 1947. Map: M1a1n dee $, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0</figcaption></figure>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">So the outline the reader posted is the Punjab after 1912. By 1947 it had twenty-nine British districts in five divisions, with the princely states of Bahawalpur, Patiala, Nabha, Jind, Kapurthala, Malerkotla, Faridkot, Chamba, Mandi, Suket and the Simla hill states inside the line but under their own rulers. The province was run by a Lieutenant-Governor from 1859 to 1921 and a Governor after that.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Sir Robert Montgomery was Lieutenant-Governor of the Punjab from 1859 to 1865. In 1864 the headquarters of Gogaira district moved to a station on the railway line, which was named Montgomery after him in 1865, and the district took the name; the town and district became Sahiwal in 1966. Lyallpur, named for Sir James Lyall, Lieutenant-Governor from 1887 to 1892, became Faisalabad in 1977. Two of the names on the map are British officials, and both have since been removed.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Three Punjabs</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The word carries three meanings that the map runs together.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The first is the land of the five rivers: Jhelum, Chenab, Ravi, Beas and Sutlej, which is to say the doabs between them, the Sindh Sagar Doab west of the Jhelum, and the Bist Doab between the Beas and the Sutlej. On that reading Punjab ends at the Indus to the west, at the Sutlej to the south-east, and at the Siwaliks to the north-east. Malwa, south of the Sutlej, is outside the rivers but Punjabi in speech, which is where the first two meanings part.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-doabs-1880.jpg"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="785" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-doabs-1880.jpg" alt="Map of the Punjab region showing the doabs between its rivers, about 1880" class="wp-image-26471" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-doabs-1880.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-doabs-1880-300x230.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-doabs-1880-768x589.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" /></a><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">The five rivers and the doabs between them, about 1880. Map: W. H. Allen and Co., public domain, via Wikimedia Commons</figcaption></figure>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The second is the Punjabi language, in its central dialects, Majhi, Doabi, Malwai and Powadhi, and its western ones, Shahpuri, Dhani and Jhangvi. The edges are disputed. Potohari, spoken on the plateau around Rawalpindi, has no column of its own in the Pakistani census and is listed as a separate language, Pahari-Potwari, by Ethnologue. Seraiki, spoken from Jhang southwards, has been a separate census language in Pakistan since 1981. My teacher put the gap in practical terms: by his own estimate a Seraiki speaker and a Pothohari speaker understand about thirty per cent of each other’s speech, and the food, the dress and the accent differ as well.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The third is political: whatever a government calls Punjab today. On the Indian side that was cut back to the Punjabi-speaking districts in 1966. On the Pakistani side the 1947 box, minus the Indian share and Islamabad and plus Bahawalpur, has never been divided on language.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Sorting the twenty-nine districts</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">This is my grouping of the districts against the first two meanings. The margins are mixed: Hoshiarpur, Gurdaspur and Ambala were split in 1966, and Patiala and Jind held land on both sides of the language line.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-table"><table><thead><tr><th>Group</th><th>Districts and states on the 1947 map</th><th>Test</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>Core Punjab</td><td>Lahore, Amritsar, Gurdaspur, Sialkot, Gujranwala, Sheikhupura, Gujrat, Shahpur, Jhelum, Lyallpur, Montgomery, Jalandhar, Hoshiarpur, Ludhiana, Firozpur; Kapurthala, Patiala, Nabha, Jind, Malerkotla, Faridkot</td><td>Inside the five rivers, or in Malwa south of the Sutlej, and Punjabi-speaking (Lyallpur and Montgomery by settlement from the central districts; the older speech of the bar was Jhangvi)</td></tr><tr><td>Transitional</td><td>Rawalpindi, Attock, Jhang, Mianwali</td><td>Potohari and Hindko in the north; Jhangvi shading into Seraiki; Mianwali mostly Seraiki and Thalochi, with Pashto in Isa Khel</td></tr><tr><td>Seraiki south-west</td><td>Multan, Muzaffargarh, Dera Ghazi Khan; Bahawalpur State</td><td>Multan was its own province under the Mughals, separate from Lahore. Dera Ghazi Khan is across the Indus and Baloch in its tribes. Bahawalpur’s rulers, the Daudpotra Abbasis, came from Shikarpur in Sindh in the eighteenth century</td></tr><tr><td>Haryana</td><td>Hisar, Rohtak, Gurgaon, Karnal, and the plains of Ambala</td><td>Haryanvi and Bagri speech, Jat and Ahir country of the Delhi region; except for Ambala, in the Punjab only because of 1858</td></tr><tr><td>Hills</td><td>Kangra, Simla; Chamba, Mandi, Suket and the Simla hill states</td><td>Western Pahari languages, Kangri and its neighbours; the Siwaliks and beyond</td></tr></tbody></table></figure>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/punjab-29-districts-five-groups.jpg"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="799" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/punjab-29-districts-five-groups-1024x799.jpg" alt="Map of the Punjab with its districts and states coloured in five groups: Core Punjab, Transitional, Seraiki south-west, Haryana and Hills" class="wp-image-28424" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/punjab-29-districts-five-groups-1024x799.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/punjab-29-districts-five-groups-300x234.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/punjab-29-districts-five-groups-768x599.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/punjab-29-districts-five-groups-1536x1199.jpg 1536w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/punjab-29-districts-five-groups.jpg 1800w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" /></a><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">The twenty-nine districts in the five groups, coloured on the district map in Sir James Douie’s The Panjab, North-West Frontier Province and Kashmir (1916), public domain. Sheikhupura was made in 1919. The southern state patches are shown with Haryana.</figcaption></figure>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">By my count fifteen of the twenty-nine districts are Punjab in both the river and the language sense, and four more are transitional. Three in the south-west are Seraiki, with Bahawalpur State beside them; five in the south-east are Haryanvi; and two in the north-east are Pahari. The two circled districts, and the state below them, are exactly the parts of the map with the weakest claim to the name.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">What 1947 and 1966 did to Greater Punjab</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Partition cut the box along a line that Radcliffe drew in five weeks, through the core: Lahore west, Amritsar east, <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/04/28/gurdaspur-and-siliguri-the-two-necks-that-held/">Gurdaspur split at the tehsil</a>. It did not touch the question of where Punjab ends.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">India then answered that question. The princely states east of the line had become PEPSU in 1948, and PEPSU was merged into Punjab in 1956. The Punjab Reorganisation Act of 1966 took Hisar, Rohtak, Gurgaon, Karnal and Mahendragarh out as Haryana, with parts of Ambala district and the Jind and Narwana tehsils; gave Simla, Kangra, Kullu, Lahaul and Spiti, the Nalagarh tehsil and parts of Hoshiarpur and Gurdaspur to Himachal Pradesh; made Chandigarh a union territory; and left an Indian Punjab close to the Punjabi-speaking districts. The States Reorganisation Commission had refused a linguistic Punjab in 1955; the Punjabi Suba movement got it eleven years later, and the state that resulted is a Punjab whose boundary was argued on the ground of speech. Pakistan’s never has been. In the notes to <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2019/06/24/bp-episode-50-south-asian-subnationalism-with-prof-majeed/">a 2019 podcast with Professor Majeed</a> I called this the great victory of the Sikhs: Punjabi is a vigorous language of state in India in a way that it is not in Pakistan.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-1951-66.png"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="415" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-1951-66-1024x415.png" alt="Maps of Indian Punjab&#x27;s territorial changes between 1951 and 1966" class="wp-image-26473" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-1951-66-1024x415.png 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-1951-66-300x122.png 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-1951-66-768x311.png 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-1951-66-1536x622.png 1536w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/punjab-1951-66.png 1920w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" /></a><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Indian Punjab, 1951 to 1966: Haryana and Himachal cut out, Chandigarh a union territory. Map: Furfur, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0</figcaption></figure>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Pakistan kept the Punjab but swapped out Punjabi. Bahawalpur State, which acceded to Pakistan in October 1947, lost its separate existence in One Unit on 14 October 1955 and came out of One Unit in July 1970 as districts of Punjab, not as itself; I have asked whether Pakistan should <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/08/01/restore-the-princes/">restore its princes</a>. The Seraiki districts, the Potohar plateau and the central doabs sit in one province of 127.7 million people at the 2023 census, and the argument about new provinces that <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/14/how-pakistan-punjabified-lahnda-and-urdufied-punjab/">opened my Lahnda post</a> is an argument about whether to do what India did in 1966. In 2018 I wrote, in <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2018/07/28/the-siraiki-question/">The Siraiki question</a>, that Pakistani Punjab had not had its Haryana moment yet. It still has not. Urdu has done some of the binding instead; <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2018/08/30/urdu-as-an-intra-provincial-link-language/">an earlier post</a> argued that it works as a link language inside a province with large linguistic minorities.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">The Punjab is both Fact &amp; Fiction</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Punjab, in river and in speech, runs from the Indus to the hills, and south of the Sutlej across Malwa as far as Punjabi is spoken. The 1947 outline runs past it because the British added the Delhi districts in 1858 and kept Dera Ghazi Khan in 1901. India corrected the eastern and northern overshoots in 1966. The western and southern overshoots are still on the map, and they are what the people of Multan, Dera Ghazi Khan and Bahawalpur mean when they say they are not Punjabi.</p>

<div style="margin-top: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px;" class="sharethis-inline-share-buttons" ></div>]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/11/09/where-punjab-ends-1947-map/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>5</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Arikamedu: Port That Traded with Rome (X.T.M’s 1,000th Official Post)</title>
		<link>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/29/arikamedu-port-that-traded-with-rome/</link>
					<comments>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/29/arikamedu-port-that-traded-with-rome/#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2026 05:30:52 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Agni]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Ancient and classical]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Archaeological Survey of India]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Archaeology]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Arikamedu]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Indian Ocean]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[maritime trade]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Puducherry]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Roman Empire]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Tamil Nadu]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.brownpundits.com/?p=26452</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Arikamedu, 4 km south of Pondicherry, traded with Rome 2,000 years ago. Today it is littered, its mangroves full of plastic. What should the site be for?]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<ol>
 	<li class="wp-block-paragraph">Arikamedu, about four kilometres south of Pondicherry on the Ariyankuppam river, is one of India’s best-known excavated ports with evidence of trade with the Roman world. Agni visited on 17 October; the photographs are hers.</li>
</ol>
<h2 class="wp-block-heading">What is there</h2>
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The site is a low mound on the right bank of the river, where it opens into a lagoon before the Bay of Bengal. It is widely identified with Poduke, a market town named in the Periplus of the Erythraean Sea, a Greek sailing manual of the first century CE, and in Ptolemy’s Geography of the second century.</p>
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The brick pillars and arches that visitors photograph are not Roman. They are what is left of an eighteenth-century French missionary seminary and residence, usually dated 1771 to 1773 and abandoned in 1783, with some of the ancient bricks reused in its walls. The ancient remains, which the excavators read as warehouses, tanks and drains, lie in the trenches and under the ground.</p>

<figure class="wp-block-image size-large bp-fig-portrait" style="max-width: 640px; margin-left: auto; margin-right: auto;"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-26461" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-gate-pillars-agni-2026.jpg" alt="The brick gate pillars at the entrance to the Arikamedu site" width="960" height="1280" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-gate-pillars-agni-2026.jpg 960w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-gate-pillars-agni-2026-225x300.jpg 225w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-gate-pillars-agni-2026-768x1024.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 960px) 100vw, 960px" /><figcaption>The gate pillars at the entrance to the site. Photo: Agni, 17 October 2026</figcaption></figure>
<h2 class="wp-block-heading">How it was found</h2>
<figure class="wp-block-table">
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<th>Date</th>
<th>What happened</th>
</tr>
</thead>
<tbody>
<tr>
<td>1734</td>
<td>French records describe villagers carrying off old bricks from the mound near Virampattinam</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>1945</td>
<td>Mortimer Wheeler and his team dig the site and find imported Italian red-gloss pottery, Arretine ware; report published 1946</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>1982</td>
<td>The Archaeological Survey of India takes control of the site, 34.57 acres</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>1989 to 1992</td>
<td>Vimala Begley, K. V. Raman and their collaborators dig for three seasons and find occupation before and long after the main Roman trading period</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
</figure>
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The finds include amphorae, Arretine ware, Roman lamps, glass, beads of glass and stone, gems, and the waste of a bead-making industry. Wheeler read them as a trading post opened under Augustus and closed within two centuries. The later digs showed a much longer settlement history, with Rome as one trading partner among several. Finds from Arikamedu are displayed in the Puducherry Museum.</p>

<h2 class="wp-block-heading">What it looks like now</h2>
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">She found the site neglected: used for selfies, littered, loud. The mangroves along the lagoon were full of plastic, and the estuary too. I have been there myself; I went kayaking on that river.</p>

<figure class="wp-block-image size-large bp-fig-portrait" style="max-width: 640px; margin-left: auto; margin-right: auto;"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-26462" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-mangroves-egret-agni-2026.jpg" alt="Mangroves on the Ariyankuppam river at Arikamedu, with an egret" width="1200" height="1600" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-mangroves-egret-agni-2026.jpg 1200w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-mangroves-egret-agni-2026-225x300.jpg 225w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-mangroves-egret-agni-2026-768x1024.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-mangroves-egret-agni-2026-1152x1536.jpg 1152w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1200px) 100vw, 1200px" /><figcaption>Mangroves on the Ariyankuppam river below the site, with an egret. Photo: Agni, 17 October 2026</figcaption></figure>
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The site is protected by the Archaeological Survey of India. The visible walls are eighteenth-century, the finds are in a museum, and the river that made the port is choked with rubbish. What should a site like this be for, and who should look after it?</p>

<figure class="wp-block-image size-large bp-fig-portrait" style="max-width: 640px; margin-left: auto; margin-right: auto;"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" class="wp-image-26463" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-river-mouth-bay-of-bengal-agni-2026.jpg" alt="A boat on the Ariyankuppam river where it meets the Bay of Bengal, near Arikamedu" width="1200" height="1600" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-river-mouth-bay-of-bengal-agni-2026.jpg 1200w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-river-mouth-bay-of-bengal-agni-2026-225x300.jpg 225w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-river-mouth-bay-of-bengal-agni-2026-768x1024.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/arikamedu-river-mouth-bay-of-bengal-agni-2026-1152x1536.jpg 1152w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1200px) 100vw, 1200px" /><figcaption>The Ariyankuppam river meeting the Bay of Bengal. Photo: Agni, 17 October 2026</figcaption></figure>


<p class="wp-block-paragraph"><em>This is X.T.M’s 1,000th official post on Brown Pundits. The first, <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20120103152522/http://www.brownpundits.com/2010/12/30/hello-world-2/">Hello world</a>, went up on 30 December 2010. That is the official count. Errors in the back archives confuse attribution: if about a third of the uncredited posts are X.T.M’s, the number may be closer to 1,300. Of the 1,000 counted here, 514 came before <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2023/10/19/two-zacks-meet-in-new-cambridge/">X.T.M came back in October 2023</a>, and 486 since. The 999th was <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/27/brown-pundits-autopilot-readers-commenters/">Brown Pundits on Autopilot</a>.</em></p>

<div style="margin-top: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px;" class="sharethis-inline-share-buttons" ></div>]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/29/arikamedu-port-that-traded-with-rome/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>10</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Who Made the Brahmins and the Goddess Vegetarian?</title>
		<link>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/19/who-made-brahmins-vegetarian-pattanaik/</link>
					<comments>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/19/who-made-brahmins-vegetarian-pattanaik/#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 19 Oct 2026 18:19:15 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Ancient and classical]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[History]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Medieval and Mughal]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Religion and philosophy]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society, caste and identity]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Ashoka]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Brahmin]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[caste]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Devdutt Pattanaik]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[food history]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Hemachandra]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Jainism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Sanskritisation]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Vegetarianism]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.brownpundits.com/?p=26417</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Devdutt Pattanaik places the first fully vegetarian texts in medieval Gujarat, under Jain and Muslim influence. Earlier Indian sources complicate that.]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[
<p class="wp-block-paragraph"><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2017/10/05/review-jaya-by-devdutt-pattanaik/">Devdutt Pattanaik</a> <a href="https://www.facebook.com/devduttmyth/posts/pfbid08xiupUAyJyx1fJ5STrwvUbNjCzQsnC4i3CfCHwZFGbHZUcY3eLzuquBRB7VAxpoUl" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">asked on Facebook</a> who funded the Brahmins to give up meat. His claims about <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/tag/vegetarianism/">Brahmin vegetarianism</a>: the earliest texts promoting a fully vegetarian lifestyle are Jain texts from Gujarat around 1000 AD; Muslim merchants and halal practice may have shaped Hindu purity rules; and trade went both ways, with Gujarat supplying the peacocks seen in Islamic art and Muslim traders supplying the lions that became the symbol of the Jain kings of Girnar. He conceded that some monks and priests were vegetarian earlier, and asked whether the influence could have run the other way. He framed each point as &#8220;this needs investigation.&#8221; His Baniya and Brahmin thesis was discussed in <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/08/08/the-brahmin-civil-war/">The Brahmin Civil War</a>.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Satire or history</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">&#8220;Who funded&#8221; and &#8220;this needs investigation&#8221; are phrases used online to question activists and protests. Pattanaik applied them to Brahmin diet and ended: &#8220;So it cannot be Baniya funded.&#8221; The post can be read as satire of that method. Whether or not it was meant as satire, its historical claims can be checked.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Two claims that hold</h2>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Brahmin diet varies by region</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Members of several Brahmin communities eat fish, and some eat meat: Bengali, Odia, Maithil, Kashmiri, Saraswat and Konkani traditions all include fish-eating groups. Vedic ritual included animal sacrifice. Vegetarian norms are prominent among Brahmin communities in Gujarat, Rajasthan, the Tamil and Kannada regions and parts of the Hindi belt. Current practice shows variation; it does not by itself show how old any of these diets are.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="768" class="wp-image-26415" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/bhapa-ilish-steamed-hilsa-howrah-1024x768.jpg" alt="Bhapa ilish, steamed hilsa with mustard, prepared in a home kitchen in Howrah" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/bhapa-ilish-steamed-hilsa-howrah-1024x768.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/bhapa-ilish-steamed-hilsa-howrah-300x225.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/bhapa-ilish-steamed-hilsa-howrah-768x576.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/bhapa-ilish-steamed-hilsa-howrah-1536x1152.jpg 1536w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/bhapa-ilish-steamed-hilsa-howrah.jpg 1920w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" />
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Bhapa ilish, steamed hilsa, in a Howrah kitchen. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Steamed_Ilish_-_Howrah_20170531131511.jpg">Photo</a>: Biswarup Ganguly, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption>
</figure>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Jain accounts describe a royal ban on killing in Gujarat</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Jain accounts record that in the twelfth century the Chaulukya king <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kumarapala_(Chaulukya_dynasty)">Kumarapala</a>, advised by the Jain scholar <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hemachandra">Hemachandra</a>, proclaimed amari, a ban on killing animals, across his kingdom. The accounts come from the Jain side. How far the ban was enforced is not known.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="226" class="wp-image-26413" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/hemachandra-yoga-shastra-jain-manuscript-leaves-1024x226.jpg" alt="Two leaves from a Jain manuscript of Hemachandra’s Yoga-shastra" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/hemachandra-yoga-shastra-jain-manuscript-leaves-1024x226.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/hemachandra-yoga-shastra-jain-manuscript-leaves-300x66.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/hemachandra-yoga-shastra-jain-manuscript-leaves-768x170.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/hemachandra-yoga-shastra-jain-manuscript-leaves-1536x339.jpg 1536w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/hemachandra-yoga-shastra-jain-manuscript-leaves.jpg 1920w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" />
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Leaves from a Jain manuscript of Hemachandra’s Yoga-shastra, Gujarat, 1279. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Hemachandra_-_Pair_of_Two-Sided_Leaves_from_a_Jain_Manuscript_-_1971.128_-_Cleveland_Museum_of_Art.jpg">Image</a>: Cleveland Museum of Art, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption>
</figure>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Arguments against eating meat long before 1000 AD</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Pattanaik&#8217;s dating concerns texts that promote a fully vegetarian life. The sources below are of different kinds. None shows all Brahmins changing diet at one moment. Together they show that the argument for abstaining from meat is far older than medieval Gujarat.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-table">
<table class="has-fixed-layout">
<thead>
<tr>
<th>Date</th>
<th>Source</th>
<th>Type</th>
<th>Content</th>
</tr>
</thead>
<tbody>
<tr>
<td>c. 250 BCE</td>
<td><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edicts_of_Ashoka">Ashoka&#8217;s edicts</a></td>
<td>Royal policy</td>
<td>Rock Edict I reduces killing in the royal kitchen to two peacocks and a deer, the deer not regularly, and says these too will stop. Pillar Edict V lists protected animals. A restriction on killing, not a vegetarian rule for all subjects.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>Early centuries CE</td>
<td><a href="https://www.wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/manusmriti-with-the-commentary-of-medhatithi/d/doc200424.html">Manusmriti 5.48 to 5.49</a></td>
<td>Normative teaching</td>
<td>Meat cannot be had without injury to living beings, so a man should avoid it. The same chapter permits meat in ritual and other contexts.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>c. 400 CE</td>
<td><a href="https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/A_Record_of_Buddhistic_Kingdoms">Faxian</a>, Chinese pilgrim</td>
<td>Traveller&#8217;s account</td>
<td>Reports that in the Middle Country people did not kill living creatures, drink alcohol, or eat onion or garlic, except the Chandalas. An observation, not a census.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>c. 300 to 600 CE (dating disputed)</td>
<td><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tirukku%E1%B9%9Ba%E1%B8%B7">Tirukkural</a>, chapter 26</td>
<td>Normative teaching</td>
<td>Ten verses on abstaining from meat.</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
</figure>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/faxian-zhuan-woodblock-print.jpg"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="634" height="1024" class="wp-image-26411" style="max-height:560px;width:auto;display:block;margin:0 auto" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/faxian-zhuan-woodblock-print-634x1024.jpg" alt="First page of a 12th-century woodblock print of the Travels of Faxian" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/faxian-zhuan-woodblock-print-634x1024.jpg 634w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/faxian-zhuan-woodblock-print-186x300.jpg 186w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/faxian-zhuan-woodblock-print-768x1241.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/faxian-zhuan-woodblock-print-951x1536.jpg 951w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/faxian-zhuan-woodblock-print.jpg 963w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 634px) 100vw, 634px" /></a>
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">First page of a twelfth-century woodblock print of Faxian’s Record of the Buddhist Countries. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Faxian_zhuan.JPG">Image</a>: public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption>
</figure>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">The disputed Jain passage</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Pattanaik&#8217;s reading that early Jain texts allowed meat rests in part on the Bhagavati Sutra (Viyahapannatti 15), in the account of Mahavira&#8217;s illness. Revati prepares food described with words that can mean pigeon and rooster. The Indologist <a href="https://jainqq.org/booktext/History_of_Vegitarianism_and_Cow_Veneration_in_India_Romanized/006921">Ludwig Alsdorf</a> defended the literal meat reading. Jain commentators since the medieval period have read the words as plant names, a gourd and a citron. The passage is disputed and has been for more than a century. It does not settle Mahavira&#8217;s diet, and it does not date the origin of Brahmin vegetarianism either way.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="735" class="wp-image-26416" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/kalpasutra-folio-infant-mahavira-1024x735.jpg" alt="Lustration of the infant Jina Mahavira, folio from a Kalpasutra manuscript" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/kalpasutra-folio-infant-mahavira-1024x735.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/kalpasutra-folio-infant-mahavira-300x215.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/kalpasutra-folio-infant-mahavira-768x551.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/kalpasutra-folio-infant-mahavira-1536x1102.jpg 1536w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/kalpasutra-folio-infant-mahavira.jpg 1920w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" />
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Lustration of the infant Jina Mahavira, folio from a Kalpasutra manuscript. A contextual illustration; it does not show the Bhagavati passage. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Anonymous_-_Lustration_of_the_Infant_Jina_Mahavira,_Folio_from_a_Kalpasutra_Manuscript_-_2005.35_-_Metropolitan_Museum_of_Art.jpg">Image</a>: Metropolitan Museum of Art, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption>
</figure>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Purity rules and the lion before Islam</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Dharmashastra texts classified substances, animals and people as pure or impure centuries before Islam reached Gujarat. Lions are native to Gujarat, where the Gir forest and the surrounding Saurashtra landscape hold the surviving wild Asiatic lions, and the lion is Mahavira’s emblem in Jain iconography. None of this rules out later borrowing in particular cases. It does mean that a Muslim import is not needed to explain the purity rules or the lion.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="659" class="wp-image-26414" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/asiatic-lion-gir-forest-1024x659.jpg" alt="An Asiatic lion in Gir Forest National Park, Gujarat" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/asiatic-lion-gir-forest-1024x659.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/asiatic-lion-gir-forest-300x193.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/asiatic-lion-gir-forest-768x494.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/asiatic-lion-gir-forest-1536x989.jpg 1536w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/asiatic-lion-gir-forest.jpg 1920w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" />
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Asiatic lion in Gir Forest National Park, Gujarat. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Asiatic_lion_03.jpg">Photo</a>: Bernard Gagnon, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption>
</figure>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">What the evidence explains, and what it does not</h2>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Sanskritisation explains spread, not origin</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">M. N. Srinivas described <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanskritisation">Sanskritisation</a> in the 1950s: castes seeking higher status adopt the practices of higher castes, often including vegetarianism. This explains how a prestigious diet spreads, and why diet still marks <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2024/03/17/reinforcing-caste-boundaries-in-everyday-social-interactions/">caste boundaries in everyday life</a>. It does not explain why Brahmins in some regions adopted it first.</p>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Competition with Buddhism and Jainism</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Brahmanical traditions competed with Buddhism and Jainism for royal and merchant patronage over many centuries, and both of those religions made non-violence central. That is a plausible pressure on Brahmin practice. The sources used here do not establish whether it explains the regional pattern, and the ancient texts above do not measure it.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">What the sources establish</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Diet is now argued over as a marker of national identity: meat called foreign by one side, vegetarianism called an import by the other. Indian arguments for abstaining from meat predate Islam and Hemachandra. The sources do not identify one moment when all Brahmins changed diet, or one sponsor. Regional practice, religious teaching, patronage and status imitation are separate mechanisms, and each needs its own evidence.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Since then: the goddess and the flies</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Pattanaik has stayed on the subject. Three posts since the one I answered above:</p>



<figure class="wp-block-table"><table><thead><tr><th>Date</th><th>Post</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>13 October</td><td><a href="https://www.facebook.com/devduttmyth/posts/pfbid02LX44ZzCNNZLnC5Kh369JMUGh1D9S1DCWY1Sys5RoFh5tdF9WBpDvMfApaLrGg8Lbl" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Flies in the Rig Veda</a>: an answer to the vegetarians who call meat-eating Hindus “makkhi”</td></tr><tr><td>18 October</td><td><a href="https://www.facebook.com/devduttmyth/posts/pfbid033rm83ZQJj9tsxavaN45pZsFSGKvMre6dcxS7iuNNVn2xccrPQXYJgV9BEBv5jiv9l" target="_blank" rel="noopener">China had no food taboos</a>, “no halal, no satvik, no kosher”, until Buddhist monks brought ideas of purity</td></tr><tr><td>19 October</td><td><a href="https://www.facebook.com/devduttmyth/posts/pfbid02wMrE8mwTXRLbem93dfmsxEiLgmSh7zdYKmjG8pqbsHELDA8p4ayfKVwy3FHPjbtl" target="_blank" rel="noopener">“How to make a vegetarian goddess?”</a>, his New Indian Express column of 18 October, posted in Hindi</td></tr></tbody></table></figure>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The goddess column makes the same argument as the Brahmin post, with the goddess in place of the priest. In Konkan, Gauri comes home after Ganesh and is fed fish or mutton by Koli, Agari and Maratha households. In Bengal, Uma comes home for four days, goats were once killed before her in the old houses, and on Dashami she is sent off with fish and rice. A daughter eats what the house eats. Against this he sets Vaishno Devi of the Trikuta hills, a maiden who hates meat and liquor; both belong to her enemy Bhairon Nath, the disciple of Gorakhnath. He then gives two Jain stories: in Jinasena’s Harivamsa Purana of 783 CE, Durga’s blood cult begins when hunters find a tiger has eaten a Jain nun and conclude that the goddess wants blood; at Osian in Rajasthan, the monk Ratnaprabhasuri gives Chamunda a heap of sweets, she gives up the buffalo and becomes Sachiya Mata, the vegetarian clan goddess of the Oswal Jains. His explanation is the purse. Marwari and Gujarati families, Jain and Vaishnava, paid for the marble, the feeding halls and the trusts; “once the purse comes into their hands, the goat is taken away.” His text is the Devi Bhagavata Purana, 3.26, where verses 30 and 31 prescribe fruit for Navaratri and verses 32 to 34 open a second path: animals offered to the goddess go to heaven, and the killing counts as non-violence. A popular modern Hindi translation, he says, folds those verses into one line about fruit.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">I checked what I could. Swami Vijnanananda’s translation of 3.26 reads as he says: “Those who eat meat, they can sacrifice animals in this worship of the Devi; and, for this purpose, goat and wild boars are the best”, the animals “attain to unending heavens”, and “in all the Sastras … this killing of animals in a sacrifice is considered as non-killing.” Chapter 27 adds that “payasa and fresh fish are to be specially offered”. Two menus, both lawful, as he says. One correction: the chapter names goat and wild boar; the buffalo is his addition. The Harivamsa story, the Osian story and the 956 CE inscription at Osian are as he gives them, though I read the Harivamsa in summary, not in the original. The Shrine Board’s own account of the Vaishno Devi legend names Bhairon as “a disciple of Guru Gorakhnath”, so that outline is the shrine’s own. The fish sent off with Durga on Dashami is well attested in Bengal; for Konkan his source is his own 2015 column on the Kolis of Mumbai.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The flies post holds too. All six verses he cites read as he says in Griffith’s translation: the fly that eats the raw flesh of the sacrificed horse, whose share goes to the gods (1.162.9); the men who wait for their portion of the cooked horse (1.162.12); the honey-bee that sang to the Ashvins (1.119.9); worshippers “like flies on honey” around Indra (7.32.2); the fifteen or twenty bullocks cooked for Indra (10.86.14); the horses, bulls, oxen and rams offered to Agni (10.91.14).</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">What is not shown is the same as before: a date and a sponsor. He dates the spread of the Vaishno Devi story to the twentieth century, through the Arya Samaj, BAPS, calendar art and cassettes, and gives no source; he concedes that the age of the written legend is unknown. The Hindi translation that drops the three verses is not named, so I could not check it. The purse mechanism is documented at Osian and plausible elsewhere, but he gives no second case with dates and accounts. The texts show two traditions side by side for a very long time, and the richer one setting the menu wherever it paid for the temple. That is the finding of the Brahmin post as well.</p>
<div style="margin-top: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px;" class="sharethis-inline-share-buttons" ></div>]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/19/who-made-brahmins-vegetarian-pattanaik/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>11</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Ambedkar&#8217;s Grammar of Anarchy and the Diaspora Letter</title>
		<link>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/19/ambedkar-grammar-of-anarchy-diaspora-letter/</link>
					<comments>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/19/ambedkar-grammar-of-anarchy-diaspora-letter/#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 19 Oct 2026 01:55:50 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[History]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics and public life]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Since independence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society, caste and identity]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[2020–21 Indian farmers' protest]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[B.R. Ambedkar]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cockroach Janta Party]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Constituent Assembly]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Democracy]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Election Commission of India]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Indian diaspora]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Protest movement]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Special Intensive Revision]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.brownpundits.com/?p=26439</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[A diaspora letter quotes Ambedkar's 'grammar of anarchy' against street protest. His 1949 speech and five decades of protests that became law complicate it.]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">A statement titled <a href="#statement-in-full">“Spare India from Anarchy”</a> began circulating in Indian diaspora WhatsApp groups on 14 October, four days after the Delhi lockdown described in <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/14/gandhi-inherited-colonial-state-south-asia/">The Raj With a New Flag</a>. It is signed by “Indian-origin academics, students and alumni of universities outside India”, collected names through a <a href="https://forms.gle/2FiymsTpJccac4To6">Google Form</a>, now closed (the full text is at the end of this post), and rests its argument on a line from <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/tag/b-r-ambedkar/">B. R. Ambedkar</a>. The line deserves a closer look, and so does the record of what the Indian street has done to Indian law.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">What the letter says</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The statement makes five points. Indian democracy has held for seven decades with working institutions and peaceful transfers of power. Election denial, attacks on constitutional bodies and a preference for “street over Sansad” now threaten it. The armed forces have been pulled into partisan debate. Doubt about democracy has been sown by “weaponizing sub-judice matters” and amplified on the streets by “anarchist forces”. Dissent is essential, but differences should be resolved “through debate, discussion, dialogue and dissent under the roof of constitutional institutions.”</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">It names no authors and no organisation. It lists no demands.</p>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Who is asked to sign</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The form asks for a name, a university email, the university attended and the year of graduation. The intended signatory is a graduate living outside India. Most of them do not vote in Indian elections; overseas Indians can register but must be physically present in their constituency to cast a ballot.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">What Ambedkar said in 1949</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The letter’s authority is Ambedkar’s <a href="https://www.constitutionofindia.net/debates/25-nov-1949/">closing speech to the Constituent Assembly on 25 November 1949</a>, the source of the phrase “grammar of anarchy”. The passage is worth reading whole, because it is aimed at a specific target.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="800" height="518" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/constituent-assembly-india-meeting-1950.jpg" alt="A meeting of the Constituent Assembly of India in 1950, with B. R. Ambedkar seated top right" class="wp-image-26435" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/constituent-assembly-india-meeting-1950.jpg 800w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/constituent-assembly-india-meeting-1950-300x194.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/constituent-assembly-india-meeting-1950-768x497.jpg 768w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 800px) 100vw, 800px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">A meeting of the Constituent Assembly in 1950. Ambedkar is seated top right. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:A_Constituent_Assembly_of_India_meeting_in_1950.jpg">Image</a>: public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption></figure>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">The grammar of anarchy</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Ambedkar said that once constitutional methods for achieving social and economic ends exist, “there can be no justification for these unconstitutional methods.” He then named them: “the bloody methods of revolution”, and “the method of civil disobedience, non-cooperation and satyagraha.” Those, he said, “are nothing but the Grammar of Anarchy and the sooner they are abandoned, the better for us.”</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Civil disobedience, non-cooperation and satyagraha were Gandhi’s methods. Ambedkar was asking the new republic to retire the Congress movement’s own toolkit. A letter that quotes the phrase against protesters is quoting a man who meant it against the founding party as much as against anyone else.</p>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">The second warning: hero-worship</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The same speech carries a second warning, less often quoted. Ambedkar said that in politics “bhakti or hero-worship is a sure road to degradation and to eventual dictatorship”, and that Indians were more prone to it than any other people. He warned a third time that political democracy would not last without social democracy: liberty, equality and fraternity as “a way of life”. The letter quotes the first warning and not the other two.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">The street has written Indian law before</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The letter treats “street” and “Sansad” as rivals. The record shows them working in sequence: a movement outside, a law or a verdict inside.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-table"><table class="has-fixed-layout"><thead><tr><th>Years</th><th>Movement</th><th>What the institutions then did</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>1974 to 1975</td><td><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Navnirman_Andolan">Navnirman</a> in Gujarat; JP’s “Total Revolution” in Bihar</td><td>Gujarat assembly dissolved; Emergency declared June 1975; Congress lost the 1977 election</td></tr><tr><td>1990</td><td>Anti-Mandal protests</td><td>Supreme Court upheld OBC reservation in 1992 with a 50% ceiling</td></tr><tr><td>2011</td><td><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Indian_anti-corruption_movement">Anna Hazare’s fasts</a> at Jantar Mantar and Ramlila Maidan</td><td><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lokpal_and_Lokayuktas_Act,_2013">Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013</a></td></tr><tr><td>2012 to 2013</td><td>Protests after the Delhi gang rape</td><td><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_Law_(Amendment)_Act,_2013">Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013</a></td></tr><tr><td>2019 to 2020</td><td><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaheen_Bagh_protest">Shaheen Bagh sit-in</a> against the CAA</td><td>Supreme Court ruled in October 2020 that protest in public places cannot be indefinite</td></tr><tr><td>2020 to 2021</td><td><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020%E2%80%932021_Indian_farmers%27_protest">Farmers’ protest</a> on Delhi’s borders</td><td>Parliament repealed the three farm laws in November 2021</td></tr></tbody></table></figure>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="768" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ramlila-maidan-anna-hazare-fast-2011-1024x768.jpg" alt="A crowd gathered at Ramlila Maidan in Delhi during Anna Hazare’s fast in 2011" class="wp-image-26437" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ramlila-maidan-anna-hazare-fast-2011-1024x768.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ramlila-maidan-anna-hazare-fast-2011-300x225.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ramlila-maidan-anna-hazare-fast-2011-768x576.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ramlila-maidan-anna-hazare-fast-2011.jpg 1280w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Ramlila Maidan, Delhi, during Anna Hazare’s fast in 2011. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:People_Gathered_at_Ramlila_maidan_on_Anna_Hazare%27s_Fast.jpg">Image</a>: Hemant Banswal, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption></figure>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Each of these began outside Parliament. Each ended inside an institution. The Emergency is the exception that proves the sequence: it was the institutions, not the street, that suspended the Constitution.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">What the letter gets right</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Three things. Peaceful transfers of power have held since 1977, including in 2004 and 2014 when the losing side had reason to contest. Institutions do erode when every result is called stolen; that is the lesson of other democracies this decade. And a movement that lives on social media has to show it can also live inside a legislature, a point the July posts on the <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/tag/cockroach-janta-party/">Cockroach movement</a> made before the Delhi lockdown.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">What it does not settle</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph"><strong>“Sub-judice matters.”</strong> The protests concern the <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/tag/special-intensive-revision/">Special Intensive Revision</a> of the electoral rolls. The scale of deletions is contested, and the letter does not give a number. It calls raising the dispute “weaponizing” it. Whether the deletions were lawful is the question in dispute, not a premise the letter can assume.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph"><strong>Who speaks.</strong> A graduate abroad asking voters at home to stay off the street is making a request that costs the signatory nothing. The letter does not address that asymmetry.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph"><strong>The armed forces.</strong> The letter says the forces have been drawn into partisan debate but does not say by whom. Without that, the sentence can be read either way.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph"><strong>Sansad itself.</strong> The letter asks for debate in Parliament. It does not say what happens when Parliament does not sit on the question, or passes a law in minutes, as it did when it repealed the farm laws in 2021 without discussion.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="683" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/farmers-protest-singhu-border-february-2021-1024x683.jpg" alt="Farmers from Haryana at the protest camp on the Singhu border near Delhi, 15 February 2021" class="wp-image-26438" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/farmers-protest-singhu-border-february-2021-1024x683.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/farmers-protest-singhu-border-february-2021-300x200.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/farmers-protest-singhu-border-february-2021-768x512.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/farmers-protest-singhu-border-february-2021.jpg 1280w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" /><figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Farmers from Haryana at the Singhu border camp, 15 February 2021. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Farmers%27_protest_at_Singhu_Border_(15_February_2021).jpg">Image</a>: Satdeep Gill, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption></figure>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Where this leaves the argument</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Ambedkar’s speech supports the letter on one point and undercuts it on two. It does condemn unconstitutional methods once constitutional ones exist. It also condemns hero-worship and warns that a constitution without social democracy will not hold. Indian practice since 1949 has not followed his advice on the first point, and the laws listed above are the result. The question the letter raises is real: where does a constitutional method end and an unconstitutional one begin? The answer in Indian history has been settled case by case, usually by a court, after the street had already moved.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading" id="statement-in-full">The statement in full</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The text below is “Spare India from Anarchy” as it appeared on the signature form, which has since closed. The form opened with: “We, Indian-origin academics, students, and alumni of universities outside India offer this statement out of deep concern for the troubling developments in India. If you wish to express your support for this statement, please complete this form to add your name as a signatory.”</p>



<blockquote class="wp-block-quote is-layout-flow wp-block-quote-is-layout-flow">
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">In the seven decades since independence, Indian democracy has proved its resilience repeatedly. Institutions have flourished, checks and balances have functioned admirably, and peaceful transition of power has remained an enduring hallmark. Unfortunately, a frenzy of election denial, relentless questioning of constitutional institutions, and a preference for ‘street over Sansad’ has gripped certain quarters. Unfavourable election outcomes have led to questions of procedural integrity. Adverse judgements have provoked unfortunate commentary on judicial independence. Even the most apolitical institution in the country – the Armed Forces – has been gratuitously and unjustly entangled in partisan discourse.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">An unconscionable and devious plan of sowing seeds of doubt in Indian democracy has been hatched by weaponizing sub-judice matters, which is then amplified on the streets by leaning on anarchist forces, which have historically and philosophically never believed in constitutional form of governance. All in the name of saving democracy. We remain amazed at the irony of all. But more importantly, as informed people who have stakes in the future of this country and travel the world identifying as ‘Indians,’ we are deeply anguished at this state of affairs.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Dr. BR Ambedkar, the architect of the Indian constitution, warned posterity of this scenario. He exhorted that for India to survive as a constitutional republic, we must ‘hold fast to constitutional methods… abandon the bloody methods of revolution [which are] the grammar of anarchy.’ Increasingly, anarchy is becoming an expression of choice – ready to supplant the spirit and wisdom of fraternité.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">As concerned global citizens, we express our solidarity with democratic forces globally and reject perverse, regressive means to achieve narrow, self-serving ends. We understand dissent is an essential ingredient of democracy, but we refuse to be silent spectators to the subversion of democratic apparatus in its guise.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">We urge all social and political forces to take cognizance of our distress and desires and resolve differences through debate, discussion, dialogue and dissent under the roof of constitutional institutions that our venerable founding fathers created for us. India needs to set an example for the democratic world, for all the right reasons. We hope wisdom will prevail.</p>
</blockquote>
<div style="margin-top: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px;" class="sharethis-inline-share-buttons" ></div>]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/19/ambedkar-grammar-of-anarchy-diaspora-letter/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>3</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>The Raj With a New Flag: Gandhi and the Inherited State</title>
		<link>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/14/gandhi-inherited-colonial-state-south-asia/</link>
					<comments>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/14/gandhi-inherited-colonial-state-south-asia/#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 14 Oct 2026 02:31:30 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Geopolitics, security and conflict]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Partition and independence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics and public life]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Afghanistan]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[B.R. Ambedkar]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Durand Line]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[flydubai]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Indian Economy]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Jawaharlal Nehru]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Mahatma Gandhi]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Poona Pact]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Reserve Bank of India]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Taliban]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.brownpundits.com/?p=26406</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Gandhi built India's nation; the Raj built its state. Pakistan's Afghan strikes, Delhi's protest ban and the RBI rate rise show that inherited state at work.]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/02/open-thread-gandhi-jayanti/">Gandhi Jayanti thread</a> asked whether Gandhi is politically homeless. What if Gandhi built the nation, the Raj built the state, and the state is still running on that infrastructure?</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Gandhi built the nation, not the state</h2>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">From lawyers&#8217; club to mass movement</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Before 1915 the Indian National Congress was a debating society for lawyers. By 1920 it was a mass movement of peasants who had learned to resist together. That is Gandhi&#8217;s work more than anyone else&#8217;s.</p>



<blockquote class="wp-block-quote is-layout-flow wp-block-quote-is-layout-flow">
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">It is the Hindu belief that a mind with supreme self control attains the capability of changing reality. Gandhiji is the physical embodiment of that. The metaphor made real.</p>
<cite><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/02/open-thread-gandhi-jayanti/#comment-147085">Indosaurus, on the Gandhi Jayanti thread</a></cite></blockquote>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Nehru&#8217;s design, Patel&#8217;s map, Ambedkar&#8217;s constitution</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The state is somebody else&#8217;s. Modern India is a centralised parliamentary republic, run in English, with a standing army, a civil service and a district collector. It is Nehru&#8217;s design, Patel&#8217;s map and Ambedkar&#8217;s constitution.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="582" class="wp-image-26400" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/constituent-assembly-india-1946-1024x582.jpg" alt="The Constituent Assembly of India in session" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/constituent-assembly-india-1946-1024x582.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/constituent-assembly-india-1946-300x170.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/constituent-assembly-india-1946-768x436.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/constituent-assembly-india-1946.jpg 1280w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" />
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">The Constituent Assembly of India, which built a state on a different plan from Gandhi&#8217;s. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Indian_Constituent_Assembly.JPG">Photo</a>: public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption>
</figure>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Village republics, reduced to Article 40</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Gandhi wanted village republics and a minimal state. The Constituent Assembly gave the panchayat one line among the directive principles, Article 40, and built everything else on the opposite plan. Then it put his face on the money.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Why no party can hold Gandhi</h2>



<ul class="wp-block-list">
<li><strong>The BJP</strong> cannot claim the man whose last fast, in January 1948, was for the safety of Delhi&#8217;s Muslims.</li>



<li><strong>Congress</strong> cannot claim him, because it built Nehru&#8217;s state, not his.</li>



<li><strong>The left</strong> cannot, because he defended varna.</li>



<li><strong>The Ambedkarites</strong> cannot, because of the 1932 Poona Pact, where his fast against separate electorates forced Ambedkar&#8217;s hand.</li>
</ul>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">That last objection is the serious one. It says moral coercion is still coercion, and the Depressed Classes paid for it. The opposite view holds that no party has dropped Gandhi, his portraits stay up whoever governs, he is simply no longer the only god in the state&#8217;s pantheon.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">The colonial state was inherited, not overthrown</h2>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">What was never settled</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">France and America settled their internal balance of power through real conflict. India put moral pressure in its place, so the colonial state&#8217;s machinery passed intact to native elites. Partition was a different kind of rupture. The question is whose interests nationalism never touched.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">That is right about the inheritance. The republic of 1950 kept the Police Act of 1861, sedition, preventive detention and the collector. None of it was discarded. It was debated, kept and transferred. The redistribution never happened.</p>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Would a revolution have done better?</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Revolutions usually hand the machinery to whoever wins them, sharpened. What Gandhi did redistribute was the habit of refusal: peasants, women and the poor learned they could say no to a government and be counted.</p>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">A hard state in Gandhian cover</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">That habit did not settle the balance of power. It made the state feel it had to pretend to be good. Shekhar Gupta calls India a hard state in Gandhian cover.</p>



<blockquote class="wp-block-quote is-layout-flow wp-block-quote-is-layout-flow">
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The masses follow the earnest reading of gandhism and the state runs it’s own playbook with the earned legitimacy from that narrative.</p>
<cite><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/02/open-thread-gandhi-jayanti/#comment-147108">girmit, on the Gandhi Jayanti thread</a></cite></blockquote>





<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Pakistan bombs Afghanistan: the Raj&#8217;s frontier policy</h2>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Kunar and Helmand, 30 September</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Pakistani jets hit Kunar and Helmand on the night of 30 September, another round in a conflict both sides have called open war since February. The Taliban say nine civilians died; the UN mission says at least ten, most of them children. Islamabad says it hit 22 militants; the UN mission counts over 1,100 civilian deaths and injuries in Afghanistan from cross-border violence this year. Pakistan&#8217;s foreign minister warned Kabul on 3 October not to let its territory be used for attacks, and took the dispute to the Moscow-format meeting on 5 October. No talks between the two governments are scheduled. <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/02/open-thread-gandhi-jayanti/#comment-147058">Naam de Guerre</a> asked what the strategy is; <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/02/open-thread-gandhi-jayanti/#comment-147067">0M-3</a> answered that it is the British one.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="834" height="1024" class="wp-image-26401" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/durand-line-afghanistan-pakistan-border-834x1024.jpg" alt="Map of the Durand Line border between Afghanistan and Pakistan" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/durand-line-afghanistan-pakistan-border-834x1024.jpg 834w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/durand-line-afghanistan-pakistan-border-244x300.jpg 244w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/durand-line-afghanistan-pakistan-border-768x943.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/durand-line-afghanistan-pakistan-border.jpg 1036w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 834px) 100vw, 834px" />
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">The Durand Line, drawn in 1893 and rejected by Kabul since 1947. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Durand_Line_Border_Between_Afghanistan_And_Pakistan.jpg">Map</a>: public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption>
</figure>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">The same playbook since 1919</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">When the ground war failed in 1919, the British bombed the tribes, and few Pashtuns have accepted the Durand Line since. Pakistan inherited the line, the method and the problem. It is now fighting, in slow motion, a government it spent decades helping into power. What is the exit?</p>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Governor&#8217;s rule in the Frontier, 11 October</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">On 11 October President Zardari, on the prime minister&#8217;s advice, declared a state of emergency in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and imposed governor&#8217;s rule, citing the provincial government&#8217;s failure to ensure security. Chief Minister Sohail Afridi, the assembly speaker and several ministers were taken into what the interior ministry calls preventive custody, a week into PTI&#8217;s long march. Governor Faisal Karim Kundi now runs the province with an eleven-member advisory council. Direct rule over the Frontier from the centre is older than Pakistan.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Delhi bans protest in the capital</h2>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">The Cockroach rally and the lockdown, 10 to 13 October</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The Cockroach Janta Party called a rally in Delhi for 10 October to demand that the chief election commissioner, Gyanesh Kumar, resign over the Special Intensive Revision of the voter rolls, which has removed more than 130 million names. The government sealed the capital with thousands of police, suspended travel and telecom links, detained the party&#8217;s founder at the airport and, by the party&#8217;s count, thousands of supporters. Some 600 were arrested in Mumbai. Former chief ministers Mamata Banerjee, Arvind Kejriwal and Pinarayi Vijayan were detained for a time. The leaders were released on 11 October and on 12 October the opposition marched to the Supreme Court with a petition against the Election Commission. On 13 October the prime minister called India the mother of democracy; the UN human rights office raised the mass detentions, and Germany&#8217;s finance minister cancelled the India leg of his Asia trip, citing current developments. The rule now is the one Islamabad has long kept: protest all you like in the provinces, but not in the capital.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="768" class="wp-image-26402" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/jantar-mantar-new-delhi-protest-1024x768.jpg" alt="Protest banner near Jantar Mantar, New Delhi" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/jantar-mantar-new-delhi-protest-1024x768.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/jantar-mantar-new-delhi-protest-300x225.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/jantar-mantar-new-delhi-protest-768x576.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/jantar-mantar-new-delhi-protest.jpg 1280w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" />
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Jantar Mantar, New Delhi, during the 2020–21 farmers&#8217; protest. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Near_Jantar_mantar_New_Delhi_banner_supporting_2020-2021_Indian_farmers%27_protest_IMG_20210210_092042.jpg">Photo</a>: Sumita Roy Dutta, <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0">CC BY-SA 4.0</a>.</figcaption>
</figure>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">The Raj&#8217;s machinery against the Mahatma&#8217;s method</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Here the two halves meet. Dharna is Gandhi&#8217;s own method. Its critics say it has become a way to hold the country to ransom.</p>



<blockquote class="wp-block-quote is-layout-flow wp-block-quote-is-layout-flow">
<p class="wp-block-paragraph">…dharnabaazi has become a playbook for those wanting to cause mischief.</p>
<cite><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/02/open-thread-gandhi-jayanti/#comment-147116">Agni, on the Gandhi Jayanti thread</a></cite></blockquote>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">A country whose characteristic political excess is sitting down and refusing to eat has been lucky in its founder. A government that bans the sitting down in its capital is afraid of something. However, a party built on mocking the prime minister is not yet a party.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">The flydubai FZ1073 attack: vetting, not suspicion</h2>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">What happened on the flight</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">On 30 September the Omani co-pilot of flydubai FZ1073, Dubai to Tel Aviv, attacked the Indian captain, Smit Machchhar, with the crash axe. Investigators say he tried to bring the aircraft down. The captain, with crew and passengers, stopped him, and the flight landed at Tabuk. The UAE attorney general now says it was a premeditated plot to fly the aircraft into the passenger terminal at Ben Gurion. Oman had reportedly barred the co-pilot, Hamam Al-Hammami, from flying over extremist views; flydubai&#8217;s own checks showed nothing. The captain is recovering in hospital in Abu Dhabi. Trump has suggested an Iranian link without giving details, Iran calls the incident staged, and the UAE has not linked Iran to it.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="575" class="wp-image-26429" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/flydubai-a6-fga-dhaka-1024x575.jpg" alt="flydubai Boeing 737-800 landing at Dhaka airport" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/flydubai-a6-fga-dhaka-1024x575.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/flydubai-a6-fga-dhaka-300x169.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/flydubai-a6-fga-dhaka-768x432.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/flydubai-a6-fga-dhaka-1536x863.jpg 1536w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/flydubai-a6-fga-dhaka.jpg 1920w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" />
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">A flydubai Boeing 737-800 landing at Dhaka, not the aircraft involved. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:A6-FGA_-_FlyDubai_-_Boeing_737-8KN(WL)_-_60954_-_VGHS.jpg">Photo</a>: Md Shaifuzzaman Ayon, <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/">CC BY-SA 4.0</a>.</figcaption>
</figure>



<h3 class="wp-block-heading">Should passengers know a pilot&#8217;s religion?</h3>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph"><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/02/open-thread-gandhi-jayanti/#comment-147032">Archer</a> raised the question on the thread after friends began ringing airlines to ask. Disclosure would put every Muslim pilot on trial to catch one man the system should have caught.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">The RBI raises rates: paying for other people&#8217;s wars</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">On 7 October the Reserve Bank of India raised the repo rate by 25 basis points, to 5.50%, its first rise since 2023, and changed its stance to calibrated tightening. It points to tighter money in the US and to food and fuel prices pushed up by the war in West Asia. On 12 October the September figures came in: inflation 5.54%, the highest since October 2024, with food at 7.74%. Core inflation was 4.2% in August. ICRA expects another rise in December.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="506" height="683" class="wp-image-26404" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/reserve-bank-of-india-tower-mumbai.jpg" alt="Reserve Bank of India tower, Mumbai" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/reserve-bank-of-india-tower-mumbai.jpg 506w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/reserve-bank-of-india-tower-mumbai-222x300.jpg 222w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 506px) 100vw, 506px" />
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">The Reserve Bank of India, Mumbai. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:RBI-Tower.jpg">Photo</a>: Nichalp, via Wikimedia Commons, <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/">CC BY-SA 3.0</a>.</figcaption>
</figure>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Most of this is imported inflation, not overheating, though the core number says some of it is home-grown. India is paying for other people&#8217;s wars at the petrol pump, and the RBI has chosen to pay early.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Will India&#8217;s engineers come home?</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">US visa limits, led by the $100,000 fee on new H-1B petitions, have revived the old question; <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/02/open-thread-gandhi-jayanti/#comment-147174">formerly brown</a> asked it on the thread. India needs deep tech; what it will get first is what pays, and what pays in India is still logistics and payments. Deep tech follows capital, and capital follows the first exits.</p>



<figure class="wp-block-image size-large"><img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="1024" height="664" class="wp-image-26405" src="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/electronic-city-bangalore-tcs-1024x664.jpg" alt="Tata Consultancy Services campus, Electronic City, Bangalore" srcset="https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/electronic-city-bangalore-tcs-1024x664.jpg 1024w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/electronic-city-bangalore-tcs-300x195.jpg 300w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/electronic-city-bangalore-tcs-768x498.jpg 768w, https://www.brownpundits.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/electronic-city-bangalore-tcs.jpg 1280w" sizes="auto, (max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px" />
<figcaption class="wp-element-caption">Electronic City, Bangalore. <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Tata_Consultancy_Services,_Electronic_City_Bangalore_campus.jpg">Photo</a>: HokuroN, <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0">CC BY-SA 4.0</a>.</figcaption>
</figure>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">The state can build the roads, the ports and the digital rails. It cannot decree a Bell Labs.</p>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Smaller items</h2>



<figure class="wp-block-table">
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<th>Date</th>
<th>What</th>
</tr>
</thead>
<tbody>
<tr>
<td>1 October</td>
<td>Nepal: 16 trekkers stranded in Manang rescued. Separately, the avalanche search found more bodies.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>1 October</td>
<td>Nepal, already suspended by FIFA, will miss the SAFF Championship in Dhaka in November.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>3 October</td>
<td>Sri Lanka beat Bangladesh by 63 runs for Asian Games cricket bronze.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>8 October</td>
<td>Nana Patekar, Om Shanti: Rs 50 a show early on, and army service in Kargil.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>9 October</td>
<td>An ancient structure found at Jandial, near Sirkap, in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>11 October</td>
<td>Bangladesh: Rooppur unit 1 reached its first controlled nuclear chain reaction. Dhaka also signed a $336 million Chinese loan for two Mongla port terminals.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>12 October</td>
<td>Nepal: flash floods in Gorkha cut the Manaslu trail and stranded more than 100 foreign trekkers; a rescue is under way.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>12 October</td>
<td>Sri Lanka: President Dissanayake said the country is open to a new IMF agreement.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>6 October</td>
<td>World Bank: South Asia to grow 6.9% this year on domestic demand.</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
</figure>



<h2 class="wp-block-heading">Why Gandhi is still worth having</h2>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph"><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/02/open-thread-gandhi-jayanti/#comment-147146">Kabir</a> made the case on the thread: whatever his faults, Gandhi led the non-cooperation movement, went to jail for it, and much of the goodwill India had abroad came from him; Martin Luther King and Nelson Mandela claimed him as an inspiration. Nobody governs by the Sermon on the Mount either. The point of Gandhi is not that South Asia follows him. It is that its states still feel they have to pretend to, and the pretence is the only check some of them have.</p>



<p class="wp-block-paragraph">Judge him as a man of Dharma, not a <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/04/22/men-of-state-and-the-great-mahatma/">man of state</a>.</p>

<p>&nbsp;</p><div style="margin-top: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px;" class="sharethis-inline-share-buttons" ></div>]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/10/14/gandhi-inherited-colonial-state-south-asia/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>6</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Izzat Maxing</title>
		<link>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/30/izzat-maxing/</link>
					<comments>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/30/izzat-maxing/#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 30 Sep 2026 07:10:42 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Geopolitics, security and conflict]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Since independence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[1971 War]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Great Powers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Kargil War]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Mecca Joint Defence Agreement]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[nuclear deterrence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Operation Sindoor]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.brownpundits.com/?p=26132</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[X.T.M answers Q’s claim that India–Pakistan wars will stay short, arguing that allies matter only for the fifth day. He tests this against 1971, Kargil, Operation Sindoor and the Gulf and Chinese roles, with nuclear weapons as the real ceiling.]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p dir="ltr">Q contends that no India–Pakistan war will ever last more than a few days, because neither side wants the destruction a long one brings. The region, he says, will get &#8220;bouts of clashes every few years&#8221;, and he called it izzat maxing.</p>
<p dir="ltr"><strong>Four days</strong></p>
<p dir="ltr">Kargil, 1999, ran two months, and India kept its aircraft on its own side of the Line of Control the whole time. Balakot, 2019, was a day and a dogfight. Sindoor, May 2025, was four days, and on the fourth Washington and Riyadh were on the phone to both capitals. Each side claims it stopped when it chose to, and each side stopped.</p>
<p dir="ltr">The stopgaps are nuclear, then American, then Gulf: Washington does not want a nuclear crisis, and the Gulf pays Pakistan&#8217;s bills and buys Desi labour. Q&#8217;s model of the next war, days of strikes and then a ceasefire, is also how India&#8217;s deputy army chief described Sindoor afterwards: staying ahead on the escalation ladder while preventing a full-scale war.</p>
<p dir="ltr">Q claims the alliances shone through in Sindoor, that Turkey and China stood up and accordingly there was pressure to deescalate? Nobody needs an ally for four days however one seems to need them for the fifth.</p>
<p dir="ltr"><strong>1971: the ally that turned up and the one that didn&#8217;t</strong></p>
<p dir="ltr"><span id="more-26132"></span></p>
<p dir="ltr">Did Pakistan have no real allies in 1971? What about the US carrier group (the Seventh Fleet), Jordan&#8217;s Starfighters, Iran&#8217;s help, SEATO, CENTO and well the most <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pakistan–United_States_military_relations">allied ally?</a></p>
<p dir="ltr">A US carrier group built around the Enterprise entered the Bay of Bengal in the war&#8217;s second week. Nine Jordanian F-104s reached Karachi&#8217;s Masroor base, and an Indian MiG-21 shot one down. Iran&#8217;s help was conditional. On 8 December the Shah told the Americans he would not send Iranian aircraft or pilots, because of the treaty India had signed with Moscow; he would not risk the Soviets.</p>
<p dir="ltr">He offered instead to cover Jordan with two Iranian squadrons so that Jordan could lend Pakistan its Starfighters, and Nixon and Kissinger agreed, one step away. China did nothing.</p>
<p dir="ltr">Did any of this save Pakistan from dismemberment? The war lasted thirteen days, and Dacca fell before any of it could matter. The Enterprise arrived and did not fire. The 1965 embargo had hit both sides, and it hurt the side flying American aircraft more.</p>
<p dir="ltr">India had one treaty, signed with Moscow in August 1971, four months before the war. It bought three Soviet vetoes in the Security Council, on 4, 5 and 13 December, a shadow on the Enterprise, and the Shah&#8217;s aircraft staying at home. That is the whole case for allies in a short war: they buy time at the UN and keep the other side&#8217;s friends at sea.</p>
<p dir="ltr">Pakistan&#8217;s partners sent aircraft and a fleet that changed nothing; India&#8217;s one treaty changed the Security Council and kept Iran out. Only one kind mattered, and it mattered for thirteen days.</p>
<p dir="ltr"><strong>The proof is in the (Pakistani) pudding</strong></p>
<p dir="ltr">Q&#8217;s strongest case is the year Pakistan has had. In February the United States and Israel went to war with Iran. Pakistan stayed neutral, condemned the strikes and the Iranian answer alike, and by April Iran&#8217;s ambassador was saying Tehran would talk in Pakistan and nowhere else. The ceasefire of 8 April was Islamabad&#8217;s. The talks of 11 and 12 April were in Islamabad&#8217;s Serena Hotel, ran twenty-one hours and failed; the memorandum that came out of them is, this week, back on the table. Trump called Munir and Sharif extraordinary men.</p>
<p dir="ltr">The Saudi agreement of September 2025 said aggression against one is aggression against both. In August, in Mecca, Turkey signed on: attack on one, attack on all. The text has not been published, no mechanism for a military response has been announced, and neither the Turkish nor the Pakistani parliament has ratified it.</p>
<p dir="ltr">Then the Houthis, who now hold Mokha and islands in the Red Sea, began hitting Saudi Arabia. On 10 September Islamabad said no immediate response was under consideration. On 26 September the three countries&#8217; military chiefs met in Riyadh. On 29 September, in Rome, Asif said Pakistan would defend Saudi Arabia by whatever means were available, that any enemy of Saudi Arabia is an enemy of Pakistan, that a secretariat is being set up, and he would not say whether Pakistani jets had already flown. Behind the words there are already several thousand Pakistani troops, a fighter squadron, drones and an air-defence system on Saudi soil, sent by mid-year, and Riyadh put three billion dollars into Pakistan&#8217;s reserves in April. Pakistan reinforced Saudi Arabia and did not cross into the war against Iran. That is the line the pact is now being asked to move.</p>
<p dir="ltr">And Pakistan is already fighting a war, with a neighbour barely mentioned in the earlier BP thread. Kabul was bombed on 27 February and the defence minister said open war; Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Qatar brokered an Eid truce; Khost was struck again on 24 September. There are two exceptions to Pakistan&#8217;s good neighbourhood, the two states that essentially border it. One of them is a live front with a 2,640-kilometre border.</p>
<p dir="ltr"><strong>India&#8217;s shelves</strong></p>
<p dir="ltr">Is it true that in a long war nobody would sell India anything, not even Russia? SIPRI&#8217;s March report says India bought 40 per cent of its arms from Russia over 2021 to 2025, down from 72 per cent a decade earlier, with France at 29 per cent and Israel at 15. Imports fell 4 per cent; domestic output reached ₹1.78 lakh crore in the year to March, and the defence minister said most of what flew in Sindoor was Indian-made. Pakistan, by the same report, is the fifth-largest importer in the world, and 80 per cent of what it imports is Chinese. &#8220;Nobody sells&#8221; cuts both ways. One side has three suppliers who answer to nobody in common. The other has one.</p>
<p dir="ltr">The Indian army is short about 1.8 lakh soldiers, the first <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agnipath_Scheme">Agnipath</a> batch walks out this winter, and the services are asking to keep half of them instead of a quarter. The air force flies about thirty fighter squadrons against a sanctioned forty-two. SIPRI itself lists India&#8217;s pending orders, up to 140 combat aircraft from France and six submarines from Germany, and calls that a probably increasing reliance on foreign suppliers.</p>
<p dir="ltr">And on the northern border India has, in its own deputy chief&#8217;s phrase, two adversaries on one border: during the DGMO calls in May, he said, Pakistan was getting live inputs on Indian deployments from China. Beijing&#8217;s foreign ministry said it did not know how that allegation came about. Beijing also reopened three trade passes with India in August after six years, and Indian politicians said the same month that the PLA had walked into Arunachal. Both are true. China would rather use Pakistan to cause pain, the general said, than fight on its own frontier. Which is Q&#8217;s point in an Indian uniform. China has no need to mobilise while it can inform.</p>
<p dir="ltr"><strong>The broader Global Contours</strong></p>
<p dir="ltr">Can the Gulf roll Pakistan&#8217;s loans forever? Has China gone quiet on CPEC, and might it hand Gwadar back? India&#8217;s equivalent, possibly, is a trade deal with Washington that has been a framework since February and is still unsigned, with Goyal in Milwaukee this week calling it almost done; an EU agreement concluded in January and now before the Council for signature; a BRICS presidency; and a border trade with Beijing that reopened while Beijing&#8217;s soldiers moved.</p>
<p dir="ltr">In a sense Pakistan remains the region&#8217;s Israel: an ideological nation, an outlier among neighbours whose borders imperial powers drew. However, Israel and Pakistan drew, and demanded, their own borders.</p>
<div style="margin-top: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px;" class="sharethis-inline-share-buttons" ></div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/30/izzat-maxing/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>16</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>FlyDie, Volume Two</title>
		<link>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/21/flydie-volume-two/</link>
					<comments>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/21/flydie-volume-two/#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 21 Sep 2026 00:38:35 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[FlyDie]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Medieval and Mughal]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society, caste and identity]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Aurangzeb]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Bollywood]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[caste]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[hijab]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Mughal Empire]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Shahab Ahmed]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[varna]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.brownpundits.com/?p=26085</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[Nineteen more FlyDie comments across six threads: the three pillars of caste, what the Mughals took from the land, how the Rig Veda got written, Kerala’s three-cornered trade, and Bollywood as Sanskrit theatre. Each name links to the original comment.]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A sequel to <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/08/30/flydie-on-south-india/">FlyDie on South India</a>. 19 comments, across 6 threads, in this second batch.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/08/30/flydie-on-south-india/">FlyDie on South India</a></strong></p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/08/30/flydie-on-south-india/#comment-144884">The three pillars of caste</a>.</strong> Privilege never converged on one varna. Brahmins hold the social pillar, Vaishyas the economic, Shudras the political, and a jati&#8217;s rank follows its proximity to each: close to all three makes a Kshatriya, far from all three a Dalit. The Kshatriya is the mediator everyone wants and nobody needs; the Mughals played that part best, and the empire came apart when they stopped.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/08/30/flydie-on-south-india/#comment-144908">Varna was always negotiable</a>.</strong> The lawbooks rejected one direction of mixed marriage and tolerated the other. Bengal&#8217;s Kulin Brahmins wrote jati origin myths to secure their own land grants, and &#8220;pure&#8221; Kshatriya lineages were invented as needed. The grey areas, he argues, are why caste survived 3,000 years.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/08/30/flydie-on-south-india/#comment-144912">Manchus are to China what Mughals are to India</a>.</strong> A follow-up to his India-and-China comment. &#8220;Han&#8221; was a set of practices before it became an ethnicity; Sun Yat-sen, arch Han nationalist, was Hakka. The Yuan never assimilated and lasted barely a century, while the Qing sinicized and endured.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/08/30/flydie-on-south-india/#comment-144948">The Deccan blunder</a>.</strong> Urban Muslim nobles could be killed and replaced; rural Maratha sardars could not. Aurangzeb&#8217;s destruction of the sultanates left the vacuum the Marathas filled. In his verdict, a great general and a bad politician.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/08/30/flydie-on-south-india/#comment-144884">What the Mughals took from the land</a>.</strong> North India is Vaishnav, he argues, largely through Mughal patronage; even Adityanath&#8217;s Nath sect spread on Mughal-era networks. Mughal architecture began at Bayana in Rajasthan, where the chhatri was born from the Nagara mandapa and the Persian canopy.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/08/30/flydie-on-south-india/#comment-144959">The environment, not the man</a>.</strong> Akbar&#8217;s tolerance was no outlier; Ibrahim II of Bijapur ran the same experiment. The conservative turn began in mid-Shah Jahan, and Aurangzeb rode the wave rather than made it. Dara was always going to lose.</p>
<p><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/02/quick-review-shahab-ahmed-what-is-islam/"><strong>Quick Review: Shahab Ahmed, What is Islam</strong></a></p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/02/quick-review-shahab-ahmed-what-is-islam/#comment-145172">Against apologetics</a>.</strong> Defending a faith from the outsider&#8217;s picture accepts the outsider&#8217;s frame; the prior question is whether culture reflects religion or religion reflects culture. Sarmad Kashani, an Armenian-descent Jewish convert who became a fakir, then a yogi, then nothing at all, fits no category the book allows. A Balkans-to-Bengal &#8220;Islamic world&#8221; cuts non-Muslims off from their own past while making Muslims the foreign other at home.</p>
<p><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/03/parsis-dna-and-steppe-incursions/"><strong>Parsis, DNA and steppe incursions</strong></a></p>
<p><span id="more-26085"></span></p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/03/parsis-dna-and-steppe-incursions/#comment-145252">How the Rig Veda got written</a>.</strong> A king named Sudas, a head priest swapped mid-composition (Vishwamitra out, Vasistha in), and a Battle of Ten Kings won by breaking a dyke; the victory, in his telling, forged the Kuru super-tribe. The fire Agni absorbs from a lake may preserve the memory of a burning Central Asian gas leak.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/03/parsis-dna-and-steppe-incursions/#comment-145290">The Sarasvati was still flowing</a>.</strong> The Haryana stretch of the Ghaggar-Hakra kept its Sutlej connection until about 1500 BCE (his source: River and Goddess Worship in India), so the Vedic poets watched a living river decay rather than recalling a dead one. The Indus-side channel had failed a thousand years earlier.</p>
<p><strong><a href="http://Failing to reject the null">Failing to reject the null</a>.</strong> On an Indus-Vedic connection, the evidence keeps failing to reject the null hypothesis. He wanted the link and, as he puts it, learned the hard way that there is little to work with.</p>
<p><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/06/why-india-will-not-lose-her-soul-to-missionaries/"><strong>Why India will not lose her soul to missionaries</strong></a></p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/06/why-india-will-not-lose-her-soul-to-missionaries/#comment-145468">Christianity&#8217;s expired advantages</a>.</strong> The school-and-hospital edge died when the post-90s economy built better ones, the tribal frontier has closed, and the cult market now belongs to the biggest cult of all, ethnoreligious nationalism. His verdict: a marginal community, useful as a boogeyman.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/06/why-india-will-not-lose-her-soul-to-missionaries/#comment-145492">Mappila means son-in-law</a>.</strong> The name once covered Muslim, Jewish and Christian trading communities alike, born of merchants marrying in. The Jewish grandee Joseph Rabban received palaces and a Nair wife from the Chera king.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/06/why-india-will-not-lose-her-soul-to-missionaries/#comment-145482">Kerala&#8217;s three-cornered trade</a>.</strong> Muslim, Jewish and Christian Mappilas ran the ports of Malabar, Kochi and Travancore while Hindu castes held the politics. Today&#8217;s Muslim-Christian friction is Malabar money moving south into Christian territory, class and caste rather than communalism, and he expects migration to break the stalemate as Kerala&#8217;s fertility falls.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/06/why-india-will-not-lose-her-soul-to-missionaries/#comment-145525">Religions built for feudalism</a>.</strong> The major faiths were designed for a feudal agrarian world, and modern states no longer need to compromise with them. Disillusionment now sorts believers into atheists, the vaguely spiritual, and traditionalists who care more about how religion is practiced than what it believes.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/06/why-india-will-not-lose-her-soul-to-missionaries/#comment-145574">Hinduism was never mostly Brahmanical</a>.</strong> Naga cults grew out of monsoon ecology, and Skanda began as a child-devouring Graha. Tantra spread as far as Japan. Bhakti, when it came, was a mercantile movement: merchants financed the sects, and warrior ascetics cleared the highways for them.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/15/how-pakistan-became-south-asias-reference-muslims/">How Pakistan Became South Asia&#8217;s Reference Muslims</a></strong></p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/15/how-pakistan-became-south-asias-reference-muslims/#comment-146206">Sanskrit as Medieval Latin</a>.</strong> Proto-Indo-Aryan is archaic Latin, Vedic Sanskrit is Classical Latin, Classical Sanskrit is Medieval Latin, and Prakrit is the Vulgar Latin people actually spoke. Classical Sanskrit owed its rise to the Indo-Saka Western Satraps; the Satavahanas preferred Prakrit. His family&#8217;s own Ayurvedic lineage ended when a grandaunt fell into a well and his great-grandfather read it as a curse.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/19/pakistan-punches-above-its-weight-blame-aligarh/">Pakistan Punches Above Its Weight. Blame Aligarh</a>.</strong></p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/19/pakistan-punches-above-its-weight-blame-aligarh/#comment-146360">Appearance is not piety</a>.</strong> A third of Indian Muslims told Pew they keep no meat restrictions at all, and Urdu is mother tongue to 4 percent of the country against a 14 percent Muslim share. What reads as rising religiosity is urbanization dissolving caste communities, with religious institutions filling the gap.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/19/pakistan-punches-above-its-weight-blame-aligarh/">Bollywood is Sanskrit theatre</a>.</strong> Hindi cinema keeps the Natya Shastra plot shape, tragic middle and dance numbers included: Sanskrit drama in vernacular speech, European camera technique, Indo-Persian costume. Its troubles are inherited forms without the theory behind them, and a Hindi belt too plural to give it a core region.</p>
<p><strong><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/19/pakistan-punches-above-its-weight-blame-aligarh/#comment-146396">The hijab as a compromise</a>.</strong> Purdah once meant a woman could not sit on the veranda or ride a bicycle; the veil was the conservatives&#8217; bargain that let women out of the house without surrendering authority over them. Banning it turned a fading practice into a symbol of resistance.</p>
<div style="margin-top: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px;" class="sharethis-inline-share-buttons" ></div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/21/flydie-volume-two/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>2</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Pakistan Punches Above Its Weight. Blame Aligarh.</title>
		<link>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/19/pakistan-punches-above-its-weight-blame-aligarh/</link>
					<comments>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/19/pakistan-punches-above-its-weight-blame-aligarh/#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sat, 19 Sep 2026 03:19:39 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Language, literature and culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Partition and independence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Aligarh]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Hamza Alavi]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Lucknow]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Pasoori]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[salariat]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Salman Toor]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Urdu]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.brownpundits.com/?p=26075</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[X.T.M asks how Pakistan produces so much culture for its income, crediting Lucknow and Aligarh rather than Bollywood. In his account the Urdu-speaking salariat carried that culture west in 1947, and Pakistan kept it after the carriers thinned out.]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Many thanks to Kabir for <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/16/open-thread-geopolitics-and-any-other-interesting-news/#comment-146261">inspiring</a> this piece.</em></p>
<p><strong>Toor at the Courtauld</strong></p>
<p>Salman Toor was born in Lahore in 1983 and paints in New York. On Thursday TIME put him on its first TIME100 Art list, and he told the magazine &#8220;<em>I straddle two cultures</em>&#8220;. On 2 October the Courtauld opens his first solo show in Europe, nineteen paintings made since 2019. He describes the work as queer and immigrant lives, caught between intimacy and exposure, belonging and estrangement. One of the principal pictures, a bar on East 13th Street, revisits Manet&#8217;s bar at the Folies-Bergère, which hangs downstairs in the same building.</p>
<p>Two weeks ago his partner&#8217;s Pasoori became the first Pakistan-made music video to pass a billion views, and nine-tenths of those views came from outside Pakistan. I <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/15/how-pakistan-became-south-asias-reference-muslims/">wrote</a> about it. Add Toor. Add that Britain&#8217;s Muslim public face is Pakistani. How does Pakistan gets so much of so little that in the end it is the hegemon of &#8220;Monsoon&#8221; (Sub-altern) Islam, when technically it doesn&#8217;t even belong in that category. My candidate is the language, and I am not sure it is enough.</p>
<p><iframe loading="lazy" title="You’ve NEVER Heard PASOORI Like This Before!" width="500" height="281" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/bucjbvuxpVk?feature=oembed&#038;enablejsapi=1" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; web-share" referrerpolicy="strict-origin-when-cross-origin" allowfullscreen></iframe></p>
<p><strong>The Indus was the corridor, not the capital</strong></p>
<p>Start with the map. Pakistan is the Indus, and the Indus was where everyone arrived. Alexander crossed it. Mahmud of Ghazni crossed it seventeen times. Babur crossed it and kept going, because the prize lay east. Lahore mattered: fourteen years as Akbar&#8217;s capital, Jahangir&#8217;s tomb, Shah Jahan&#8217;s gardens, Aurangzeb&#8217;s mosque. But the high culture that made modern Urdu crystallised farther east and later. Mir and Ghalib wrote in Delhi. Lucknow kept the court after Delhi lost it. Sir Syed built the college at Aligarh that manufactured the class in the next section. Lahore joined the Urdu world in earnest when the colonial state put Urdu above Punjabi in the province&#8217;s offices and schools, which is the story of the Lahnda <a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/14/how-pakistan-punjabified-lahnda-and-urdufied-punjab/">post</a>.</p>
<p>In 1947 Pakistan got the corridor and Lahore. Delhi, Lucknow and Aligarh stayed on the other side. On paper that is a house with a doorway with just about one good room.</p>
<p><strong>Alavi&#8217;s salariat</strong><span id="more-26075"></span></p>
<p>The house may have been tiny but the people came in droves. Hamza Alavi, the Karachi sociologist who died in 2003, broke with the idea that religion made Pakistan. The movement was led, he argued, by the &#8220;<em>salary-dependent class of Muslim government servants</em>&#8220;, whom he called the salariat: Aligarh-educated, Urdu-speaking, raised for the colonial service, and watching its share of posts shrink against an English-educated Hindu middle class. A new state meant new posts, and the salariat stood to gain most from one. Alavi knew the type because he was one: an economics MA from Aligarh, a research officer at the Bank of India in 1945, back in Karachi in 1947 to help set up the new central bank. He also named what the class built once it arrived: the overdeveloped state, a bureaucracy and an army too large for the society beneath them. His own paradox follows. The salariat was the engine of the Pakistan movement, and the provinces that became Pakistan barely had one. The corridor had to import the court.</p>
<p>Count what crossed. Intizar Husain from Dibai went to Lahore. Jaun Elia and Sadequain, both from Amroha (<em>the Amroha Sayyid, my late grandmama&#8217;s lineage, has been around for 800years</em>), went to Karachi: one small town gave Pakistan its most quoted poet and its most famous painter.</p>
<p>Josh Malihabadi followed from Malihabad in 1955. Shaukat Siddiqui came from Lucknow and wrote Karachi&#8217;s great novel about its own poor. Behind the famous names came the clerks, who staffed the new state&#8217;s civil service out of all proportion to their numbers. Karachi tripled between the 1941 and 1951 censuses, and the newcomers were the majority. They were an accomplished lot, and they had just lost everything but the accomplishment. They were also ashraf, the well-born; the pasmanda majority of Indian Muslims stayed where it was, which is a large part of why Indian Islam transformed as well post-Partition.</p>
<p><strong>Israelistan</strong></p>
<p>Israel in 1948 and Pakistan in 1947 are the two states of that decade built by ingathering. Most of the people who came were not an elite; they were peasants, artisans, shopkeepers and the urban poor. But each migration carried a professional class at its head, pulled out of the cities where it had been a minority and dropped on a strip of land it had to turn into a country. Both had a catastrophe at the founding, and both then bloomed. Hebrew went from liturgy to a living literature in a generation.</p>
<p>Urdu, a court language with no country, got one, and with it a state broadcaster, a film industry, a national curriculum and an army of clerks who wrote their memos in it. Catastrophe does not produce culture. Concentration does. It made neither culture from nothing; it gave two old cultures new institutions and something to prove. Put a displaced elite in one city with nothing to do but rebuild its standing and you get Tel Aviv, and you get Karachi.</p>
<p><strong>Bombay kept Urdu alive</strong></p>
<p>The twist came from my Urdu teacher on Saturday morning. &#8220;<em>Urdu got its progress from Bollywood,</em>&#8221; he said. &#8220;<em>A great deal of progress. I will give you proof.</em>&#8221; The proof is due next lesson. Here is mine in advance.</p>
<p>The dialogue of Hindi cinema was written in Urdu, and much of it in the Urdu script. Rajinder Singh Bedi wrote his scripts in Urdu, as did a number of the leading screenwriters of his day. Inder Raj Anand, who wrote Raj Kapoor&#8217;s films from Aag to Sangam, was an Urdu writer working in Urdu. Akhtar ul Iman, the poet, wrote the script of Daag. A linguist at Qatar University notes that early filmmakers policed Urdu phonetics, the sounds for which Devanagari has no letters. India took Urdu out of its schools and kept it on its screens.</p>
<p>My teacher&#8217;s peak is the 1990s, and he loves the 1990s. Purists will say the 1960s. He is right for his generation, because the 1990s were when Pakistan watched Bollywood in bulk, on pirated tape and dish antennas, while Indian films stayed banned from its cinemas. Sunny Deol&#8217;s courtroom speech in Damini, &#8220;tarikh par tarikh&#8221;, is an Urdu set piece that crossed the border on cassette.</p>
<p>For fifty years the transmitter of Urdu stood in Bombay, not Karachi. The language Pakistan took as its own was mass-produced by the country it left. Bombay has not switched the transmitter off. Hindi cinema still speaks Hindustani, because its audience does. What it stopped doing, from about 2000, was treating Urdu as the prestige register behind the sound. The qaaf went, then the poets, and one Indian writer blames the language&#8217;s association with Pakistan. Pakistan took the frequency. Coke Studio Pakistan is now where the Urdu-and-Punjabi hit gets made, and a billion views of Pasoori, nine-tenths of them abroad, is proof in the pudding.</p>
<p><strong>Straddling</strong></p>
<p>So: Urdu, the salariat, or the trauma? The language is a prestige tongue with a film archive attached, and a Pakistani can walk into any room from Dubai to Delhi with it. The salariat gave the country a founding elite whose whole identity was accomplishment. The trauma concentrated that elite in two cities and gave it something to prove. I cannot rank them, and Toor is the reason I no longer need to.</p>
<p>He is not Muhajir. He was born in Lahore, which was never the salariat&#8217;s city, and he paints in New York, which is nobody&#8217;s. The Muhajir share of Karachi has been falling for forty years, and the culture has not fallen with it. The court that came west in 1947 became Pakistani property: Lahore learned it, then the rest of the country, and now a Lahori paints men who belong nowhere for a museum in London. Pakistan&#8217;s advantage is that a minority&#8217;s high culture became a majority&#8217;s, and the majority kept it after the minority thinned out. The corridor learned the court well enough to do without the courtiers. Toor told TIME he straddles two cultures. So does his country, and it has learned to do it without the people who taught it.</p>
<div style="margin-top: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px;" class="sharethis-inline-share-buttons" ></div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/19/pakistan-punches-above-its-weight-blame-aligarh/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>40</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>In Remembrance of Shaheed Lt. Ashfaqus Samad, Bir Uttam (My Cousin Nishat Bhai):</title>
		<link>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/17/in-remembrance-of-shaheed-lt-ashfaqus-samad-bir-uttam-my-cousin-nishat-bhai/</link>
					<comments>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/17/in-remembrance-of-shaheed-lt-ashfaqus-samad-bir-uttam-my-cousin-nishat-bhai/#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 17 Sep 2026 15:33:29 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Since independence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[1971 War]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Ashfaqus Samad]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Bir Uttam]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Indira Gandhi]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Sheikh Kamal]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.brownpundits.com/?p=26056</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[A tribute, headed “by Shawkat”, to Lt. Ashfaqus Samad, a Dhaka University student who became one of the first guerrillas in Dhaka and was killed in action in the 1971 war. It traces his training in India and his service in Sector 6.]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/15/how-pakistan-became-south-asias-reference-muslims/#comment-146199">by Shawkat</a></p>
<p><em>A Tribute to A Family of Freedom Fighters</em></p>
<p>In 1971, my cousin <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abu_Mayeen_Ashfakus_Samad">Ashfaqus Samad</a> (Nishat Bhai) was a student in the Statistics dept. of Dhaka University, having graduated from St. Gregory’s School and Notre Dame College. A talented student, he was considering options of graduate study at MIT and elsewhere. Pakistan Army’s genocidal crackdown started on the night of March 25th; on the 27th, he and his friends Badal, Bodi (Shaheed) and Masud left for Kishoreganj and met with EBR forces there. On April 4th, they returned with a few .303 rifles, some ammunition and 25 grenades, thus becoming the first guerrillas to organize armed resistance in Dhaka. The cache was initially stored at his home, and subsequently moved cross-town at great peril to his friend Towhid Samad’s Dhanmondi residence. Realizing that it was inadequate, he then went to Agartala, India, for further military training.</p>
<p>After seeing sporadic action in the Saldanadi sector, in June he was selected for the First War Course of Bangladesh Army, to be trained by the Indian Army at Camp Murti, near the Indo-Bhutan border. Bearing ID No. S.S. 33, he was one of 61 Commissioned Officers, including Sheikh Kamal (eldest son of Sheikh Mujib), who graduated on October 9th, and one of only two of his batch to be killed in action (KIA) during the war. He was assigned to Sector 6 in Dinajpur and Rangpur, where he helped liberate several areas, notably Bhurungamari, the first upazila (sub-district) to be freed.</p>
<p><span id="more-26056"></span></p>
<p>So thorough was the rout of the Pakistanis by allied forces that their new battalion commander in nearby Nageshwari, Lt. Col.(later Brig.) M.M. Sarfaraz Khan, reported: “<em>Earlier, on 14th November, the enemy successfully attacked a company of 25 Punjab in Bhurangamari…..All the troops including the Company Commander were in poor state. Many of them were in a state of anguish…..I turned to look at the bleak situation and the demoralized soldiers who had recently faced bitter defeat.</em>”</p>
<p>It is not widely appreciated that mid-November marked Indira Gandhi’s “<em>Eid</em>” gift to Bangladesh – prior to that Indian forces did not routinely cross the international boundary (IB), but thereafter joint Indo-Bangladesh forces launched relentless attacks along the entire border. The strategy was to soften up the Pakistanis and drive them into garrisons, which would later be besieged and bypassed on the road to Dhaka.</p>
<p>Nishat Bhai led a small force against the Pakistani stronghold in Raiganj, but in the course of battle they were unable to find cover against elevated enemy positions on the Fulkumar River bridge and adjacent buildings. He told his men to retreat and regroup, while he stayed back alone with a light machine gun to provide covering fire. He bought precious time for his troops, but he paid for it with his life. The Pakistanis targeted their fire on his gun position until he fell silent.</p>
<p>Moved by the ultimate sacrifice of their young leader, his men were determined to fulfill his mission and to recover his remains. A joint Indo-Bangladesh force launched a fearsome counter-attack, and after several hours of bitter fighting, 25 Punjab was driven all the way back to Nageshwari. Nishat Bhai and some other martyrs were buried near the Joymonirhat bazaar mosque after funeral prayers on free Bangladesh soil. It was Eid Day. The army of the state which had awarded his Fulbright Scholar mother the Tamgha-e-Quaid-e-Azam in 1970, would kill him in 1971. He was only 22.</p>
<p>U.S. Civil War historian Michael Musick wryly observed that “<em>…..while all battles are fearsome things, not all battles are equal, particularly in their historiography.</em>” Nishat Bhai’s younger brother Ishtiaq Aziz wrote that perhaps he died in “just another battle.” But was it? From my perch in faraway Florida, I have access to precious little primary sources which might be available locally. But this much is clear: perhaps because of their disastrous defeat a week earlier in Bhurungamari, the Pakistanis were spoiling for a rematch. Lt. (later Lt. Col.) K.J.S. Bakshi of 1 Field Company Engineers wrote in his book Untold Incidences of Operations 1971 Bangla Front: “<em>Soon the enemy too reorganized itself and put up a very tough battle at Raiganj. They used intensive artillery to bombard our troops with plenty of air burst shells inflicting heavy casualties on our side.</em>”</p>
<p>The Government of India posthumously awarded ‘Vir Chakra’ (VrC) to BSF Deputy Commandant (DC) Inderjit Singh Uppal and Lance Naik Mohini Ranjan Chakravarty for their heroic actions during the Battle of Raiganj. The BSF battle report is as follows: “<em>Two Coys of 78 Bn alongwith Mukti Fauz were asked to capture north bank of Phulkumari river near Raiganj. Both Companies i.e. A/C Coy lead by Sh Indrajeet Singh Uppal, Dy Comdt left their location Andharijhar Khamar at 0001 hrs on night 19/20 November 1971 and took opposition on the bank of Phulkumari river. The Companies fought their way upto the North bank against considerable small arms, 82 mm Mortar and 105 mm artillery fire. A fierce battle ensued between the Pakistan and the Indian forces. The enemy bunkers were very heavily fortified. The BSF, Rajput and the Mukti Fauj had a tough time to dislodge the enemy. It was in this battle that Deputy Commandant Indrajeet Singh Uppal came under enemy fire and breathed his last.</em>” DC Uppal was the only BSF officer KIA in the Eastern Theater in 1971.</p>
<p>In the meantime, my Boro Mama (<em>eldest maternal uncle</em>), whose younger son Ishtiaq Aziz was fighting with Dhaka’s famous “Crack Platoon,” a daring guerrilla unit composed of college students, was picked up by the Pakistanis from his home on the fateful night in August, when many freedom fighters and their family members were arrested. Unable to capture any of his freedom fighter sons, the Pakistanis unleashed their fury on the father. Then a man in his 50’s, he was savagely beaten in the torture chamber at the old MP Hostel. The great Crack Platoon guerrilla, late Masud Sadique (Chullu), who was also arrested, has written that he was shocked one day to find my wounded uncle there, still urging the young fighters not to give up or divulge information about arms caches to the Pakistanis (“অস্ত্র কোথায় আছে তোরা বলিসনা, ওটা আমাদের মুক্তির জন্য লাগবে”).</p>
<p>Dr. Kamal Siddiqui CSP ‘68, then PS to Foreign Minister Khondokar Mushtaq, who later became my brother-in-law, was present in the room at the Bangladesh High Commission when the brief of Nishat Bhai’s martyrdom was presented to my Boro Mama, who had just arrived in Kolkata. Kamal Bhai said that he was frozen with shock, and he just sat there stoically as the tragic news sunk in. After the war, he would recover from his physical wounds – but he never recovered from the premature loss of his beloved first-born son, Nishat (<em>which in Persian denotes the ‘Bringer of Happiness’</em>). The bringer of happiness would bring happiness no more. May they both rest in peace.</p>
<div style="margin-top: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px;" class="sharethis-inline-share-buttons" ></div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/17/in-remembrance-of-shaheed-lt-ashfaqus-samad-bir-uttam-my-cousin-nishat-bhai/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>7</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>How Pakistan Became South Asia&#8217;s Reference Muslims</title>
		<link>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/15/how-pakistan-became-south-asias-reference-muslims/</link>
					<comments>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/15/how-pakistan-became-south-asias-reference-muslims/#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 15 Sep 2026 03:22:13 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Partition and independence]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Popular]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society, caste and identity]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[X.T.M]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[British Pakistanis]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Coke Studio]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Faisal Devji]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Indian Muslims]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Muhammad Ali Jinnah]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Urdu]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.brownpundits.com/?p=26041</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[X.T.M argues that Partition cut one Muslim political world into three, and that Pakistan, having taken Urdu, now supplies the default picture of a South Asian Muslim. He calls this cultural sovereignty, seen from Coke Studio to the Home Office.]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The comments have turned into a meditation over whether Urdu ends up as one more dialect of Hindi. I think the fight is about something bigger. Partition took one Muslim political world and cut it into three. Seventy-nine years on, one of the three sets the culture for all of them, and it is the one that took the language.</p>
<p>By reference Muslims I do not mean the most devout or the richest. I mean the group whose speech, dramas, music and religious manner supply the default picture of a South Asian Muslim outside its own borders.</p>
<p><strong>Three blocs, one language</strong></p>
<p>Pakistan has ~230 million Muslims, India ~200 million, Bangladesh ~150 million. In 1971, when the second partition finished the job, the three stood almost level at about 60 million each. Pakistan has pulled ahead since by having more children. Nobody planned any of it. The Muslim League asked for a homeland for the Muslims of India, got two-thirds of them inside one country, and lost half of those within a generation.</p>
<p>The three blocs were never one culture. A Bengali cultivator, a Punjabi Jat, a Sindhi tenant and a Lucknow ashraf household shared a mosque and not much else. What they shared at the top was one political world and one elite language. That language was Urdu, and Urdu was not Pakistani. It grew up in Delhi and matured in Lucknow. Ghalib is buried in Delhi and Mir in Lucknow. Aligarh taught it. The Punjab, which became Pakistan&#8217;s heart, spoke something else entirely, as I argued in my last post.</p>
<p>Pakistan made it the state language anyway. In March 1948 Jinnah stood in Dhaka and told the Bengalis they could keep Bengali for their province, but that the state would speak Urdu and only Urdu. Few in either wing spoke it at home then. The 2023 census puts it at 9.25% of Pakistanis now. The Punjabis, Sindhis, Pashtuns and Baloch learnt it at school. On 21 February 1952 police shot Bengali students in Dhaka for objecting, and the road to 1971 opened from there. The Bengalis kept their language. They still lost the argument about whose culture the Muslims of the subcontinent would run on.</p>
<p>So the language of the Indian Muslim elite now carries a Pakistani label. When a Hindu in Delhi hears Urdu, he hears Pakistan. When a Pakistani hears Urdu, he hears himself.</p>
<p><strong>Why Urdu does not dissolve</strong><span id="more-26041"></span></p>
<p>The case for Urdu fading is simple. It is intelligible with Hindi. Bhojpuri is also close enough to Hindi that the boundary between language and dialect has long been politically contested. Yet Bhojpuri never acquired Urdu’s combination of script, literary prestige, religion and state power. On that logic Urdu shrinks into a Hindi dialect with some Persian vocabulary and a script nobody uses.</p>
<p>I don&#8217;t buy it, and the reason is religion rather than grammar. A Bhojpuri speaker has no reason to keep a separate script. An Indian Muslim does. Quranic literacy is not Urdu literacy, but it puts the alphabet in every practising child&#8217;s hands, and Devanagari cannot do that job. Some Indian Muslims now write Urdu in Devanagari, and it reads as Hindi with a Muslim accent. The Perso-Arabic letters carry a memory that the words alone do not.</p>
<p>Even the Indian Muslim who reads and writes Hindi for work keeps Urdu as the marker. He keeps it because Hindi is the language of the majority and Urdu is the language of being a minority with a past. Bhojpuri has no such job to do.</p>
<p><strong>The mirror moved</strong></p>
<p>Pakistan also lost its comparison group in 1947.</p>
<p>Before Partition the Muslims of the west measured themselves against Hindus and Sikhs, because Hindus and Sikhs ran the towns. Karachi had a Hindu majority in 1941. In Lahore the Hindu and Sikh minority owned most of the commerce. Across Sindh, trade sat with Hindu families. A Muslim in Lahore knew exactly who he was measuring himself against, and the measurement stung.</p>
<p>Within two years the mirror was gone through genocide and ethnic cleansing. A society that had defined itself against the Hindu trader had no Hindu trader to look at, so it found a new comparator, and the new comparator was the Muslim who stayed in India.</p>
<p>This explains a great deal of how Pakistanis talk. Every riot in Gujarat and every mosque turned into a court case is read in Lahore as proof that Partition was right. The Hindu has dropped out of the frame. The Indian Muslim has taken his place as the person the Pakistani needs to be doing better than.</p>
<p><strong>The missing middle</strong></p>
<p>Indian Islam has two poles that the rest of the country can see, and a middle it cannot. One pole is Deoband and the Tablighi Jamaat, both born within a hundred miles of Delhi and between them the two largest conservative movements in Sunni Islam. The other pole is the Bollywood Khans, three men born in 1965 who are among the most famous Muslims alive and whose Islam is mostly a surname.</p>
<p>The middle exists. By most counts Barelvis outnumber Deobandis and the shrines are full. Kerala, Hyderabad, Lucknow and Kashmir each have a Muslim middle class with its own manners. But each of those is regional. None of them is the Indian Muslim way of being modern and observant at once. Between the seminary and the film studio there is no national default, and an Indian Muslim who wants one has no template at home.</p>
<p>Pakistan built the template, almost by accident. Its middle class needed a way to be Muslim that worked with a job and a daughter at university. It settled on an Islam that fasts in Ramadan and watches television the rest of the year. Nobody wrote it down. It is simply how the Pakistani middle class lives, in Karachi and in Bradford. And because the state spoke Urdu and the state was Muslim, the template was national from the start, which is the one thing that eluded Indian Muslims.</p>
<p><strong>The public face</strong></p>
<p>Britain is where this shows. British Islam has several blocs. The Sylhetis of east London and the Gujaratis of Leicester keep their own mosques and their own marriages, and nobody in Tower Hamlets is turning Pakistani. But look at who speaks for British Islam. London elected Sadiq Khan three times. Scotland had Humza Yousaf as First Minister. Sajid Javid ran the Treasury. Shabana Mahmood was the first Muslim Lord Chancellor and now runs the Home Office. All four are Pakistani by descent. Khan&#8217;s grandparents left Lucknow for Pakistan at Partition, which makes him a Lucknow Muslim who became a Pakistani who became the face of British Islam. When a British newspaper wants a Muslim voice, it rings a Pakistani.</p>
<p>Culture runs the same way, and the flow is outward. Coke Studio Pakistan started in 2008 and its Indian copy never caught on. This month Pasoori became the first Pakistani music video to pass a billion views on YouTube. Nine in ten of those views came from outside Pakistan, and in 2022 Google ranked it the second most searched song in the world. Bollywood remade it the next year with Arijit Singh, and the copy was panned. In 2014 Zee launched Zindagi to show Pakistani dramas to Indian viewers, and Fawad Khan was a Bollywood lead by the end of the year, until Uri shut the door in 2016. Riz Ahmed became the first Muslim nominated for the Best Actor Oscar. Kumail Nanjiani wrote himself an Oscar nomination with The Big Sick. When the English-speaking world pictures a South Asian Muslim, it pictures a Pakistani.</p>
<p><strong>Spiritual logic</strong></p>
<p>Partition wrecked the economics. India&#8217;s income per head is now well above Pakistan&#8217;s. Bangladesh has passed Pakistan too, which was not the plan when Dhaka was the junior partner. The Pakistani state has failed at much of what a state is for, and nothing below excuses that.</p>
<p>But Pakistan was never built on an economic logic. Faisal Devji called it Muslim Zion, and the comparison holds. Israel and Pakistan were argued into existence within nine months of each other, both as homelands for a faith, both against the advice of people who had done the sums. A country like that asks to be judged on a second measure as well, and the measure is cultural sovereignty: does the culture of the state belong to the people it was built for, and does it travel?</p>
<p>On that measure Pakistan succeeded early and has never stopped. The Muslims of India spent two centuries perfecting a high culture in Delhi and Lucknow. Pakistan put a flag on it and sold it back to them.</p>
<div style="margin-top: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px;" class="sharethis-inline-share-buttons" ></div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.brownpundits.com/2026/09/15/how-pakistan-became-south-asias-reference-muslims/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>66</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
	</channel>
</rss>
