Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Open ThreadGandhi Jayanti1 comment · last comment agoAdd your thoughts →

Politics and public life

Elections, parties, leaders, courts, law, ideologies and free speech.

  • Thoughts on the 5 Point Plan?

    X.T.M quotes the Cockroach Janta Party’s five-point plan, from barring Chief Justices from Rajya Sabha seats to a 20-year ban on defectors, and strongly disagrees with the defection ban but…

    X.T.M23 July 202666 comments
  • Open Thread: Raga the Martyr?

    Open thread on 21 July in Delhi: a photograph credited to PB of Sapan News of Rahul Gandhi being carried out of a large student and youth demonstration against the…

    X.T.M21 July 20268 comments
  • The Self-Confident Hindu

    X.T.M asks whether a self-confident Hindu majority is a bad thing, arguing that India is a source rather than an appropriator of culture and that a confident majority held to…

    X.T.M20 July 202653 comments
  • Did Modi Make India Great Again?

    X.T.M, writing from Delhi, weighs what one Modi tenure has compounded against Britain’s seven prime ministers in a decade, citing India’s rise to fourth-largest economy, and asks what continuity buys…

    X.T.M19 July 2026204 comments
  • The Crescent and the Trident clash over their women

    X.T.M argues that the Crescent’s seclusion and the Trident’s ‘protection’ of women are unequal in statute, citing Pakistan’s Hudood Ordinances, but equivalent in structure, as the bahu-beti bachao slogan and…

  • Pakistan & India as Imperial Nation States

    X.T.M reports a conference claim that India and Pakistan are post-imperial states smothering small nations, does not adopt that frame, and argues that ethnicity resurges in Pakistan because Islam has…

    X.T.M9 July 20263 comments
  • Reading Dawn in Delhi.

    X.T.M reports Beena Sarwar’s talk at Mela Nordic’s Stockholm Partition event, tracing the end of Aman ki Asha to Sapan, a volunteer network with a minimum common agenda that bans…

    X.T.M7 July 20263 comments
  • The Meltwater Carries No Passport

    X.T.M reports Anuradha Bhasin’s talk at Mela Nordic’s Stockholm Partition event, which proposed cross-border newsrooms, a shared archive and arts as empathy, and weighs it against earlier attempts such as…

    X.T.M5 July 202621 comments
  • Pakistan, the Successor State to Islamistan

    Pakistan is usually read as drifting ever deeper into theocracy. We argue the reverse: its elite has quietly secularised, keeping Islam as the national language while shedding it as the…

    X.T.M23 June 2026230 comments
  • Is Kabir Right?

    X.T.M tests Kabir’s claim that many Hindu-nationalist readers come to BP to litigate Pakistan and Muslims. The essay argues that blaming outsiders gives India a permanent excuse, since caste, corruption…

    X.T.M14 June 202644 comments
Brown Pundits