Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

caste

  • Genetical clarifications on caste

    Following an earlier post, a geneticist uses jati and varna to avoid the European word caste, and argues South Asia’s population-genetic structure is unusual because groups remain genetically distinct, unlike…

  • Genetical observations on caste

    Citing David Reich’s book, Razib Khan says most Indian jatis have been genetically endogamous for about 2,000 years and varna groups differ in steppe ancestry, which he thinks undermines the…

  • American Caste

    The author contrasts scholar Daria Roithmayr’s view of America as having four castes, where inherited social capital drives outcomes, with Glenn Loury’s emphasis on class over caste, and suggests discussing…

    AnAn7 June 201817 comments
  • Caste in Pakistan

    A reader comment, signed Abdul Majeed, argues that caste matters greatly in Pakistan despite appearing invisible in big cities, shaping elections, marriages and dealings with bureaucrats, and accuses Sir Syed…

    X.T.M6 June 20187 comments
  • Caste in US medicine?

    A first-person account by a US cardiologist of his name revealing his Kuruba shudra roots and three incidents of caste questions from Indian-origin colleagues, with a call for US law…

  • The Crime of Being a Dalit

    A reproduced Times of India report on the killing of a young Dalit man near Bhuj, said by police to be over a love affair with a woman from the…

    X.T.M30 May 201810 comments
  • BJPization of Dalits

    X.T.M, with a deliberately provocative title, reads the Karnataka result as Dalit voters moving behind the BJP, and speculates that Hindutva, if it ended caste hierarchy, might be welcome, while…

    X.T.M17 May 201832 comments
  • Colonial Dravidian

    X.T.M, picking up Vijay’s post, argues that the Aryan-Dravidian divide, caste and the Hindu-Muslim split were largely colonial constructions, quoting Lord Curzon that India’s natural boundaries are mountains and seas,…

    X.T.M27 April 201812 comments
  • South Asians and “communalism”

    Razib Khan, citing David Reich, argues that South Asia, unlike China, is a collection of many genetic groups with strong structure persisting within regions, so that Brahmins in Tamil Nadu…

  • Why Europe Pulled Ahead: Science, Printing and the Freedom to Criticise

    A commenter argues that Islam, like the British, is invoked to explain India’s underdevelopment, that India once allowed freedom to criticise and produced thinkers who opposed caste, and that knowledge…

Brown Pundits