Bharata Bharatavanshi
Most popular · Most recent
-
Religion
Islamoskepticism or Islamophobia
The author argues that religions should be compared on criteria such as inequality, freedom to criticise and violence, concluding that Hinduism is worst on inequality while Islam and Christianity score…
-
History
Did Islam gain more from its contact with India or Did India gain from its contact with Islam.
Mostly a compilation of tweets and comments arguing that Mughal India was extractive and that Europe was already ahead, and that Islamic rule contributed little beyond arts, food and architecture.…
-
Society
Freedom leads to freedom, not anything else
A reader-style reply argues that Ambedkar did not see Hinduism as hopeless, that Hindu thinkers such as Ramanuja opposed caste discrimination, and that Islam’s arrival, not Hinduism, explains India’s relative…
-
Society
Humanities and sciences
The author argues that the humanities’ commitment to social justice over truth, as Jonathan Haidt describes, goes back to the church’s role in European history, with Marxism filling the gap…
-
Politics
Transnational political campaigns, hacking the elections,organizing riots
The author argues that cheap social media tools let outsiders and insiders organise protests, campaigns and even riots, that big data can test political slogans daily, and that Russian-meddling claims…
-
Religion
Are all religions/ideologies reformable ?
The author asks whether every religion or ideology can be reformed, comparing it to getting admirers of Hitler to drop racism, and argues that doubting reform should not simply be…
-
Religion
Should Hinduism survive?
The author, who left and returned to Hinduism, argues it must be judged by whether it can end untouchability and violence against women, while holding that its philosophical traditions such…
-
Religion
Hinduism,Hindus,BJP/RSS media, academia,politics; Whose fault is it anyway?
The author asks who is to blame for tensions around Hinduism, media and academia, arguing that Western power has fed a sense among some Hindus that everyone is against them,…
-
Politics
free speech,freedom,truth, democracy and development
An open question asking how free speech, democracy, development, China’s growth and technology connect, and what new ideological forces may emerge over the next 20 to 150 years.
-
Politics
Hindus/buddhists threat perception of christianity and islam.
A short post quoting an analyst’s view that Hindu and Buddhist nationalists see their movements as defensive responses to expansionist, proselytising religions, an aspect the poster says Western coverage misses.
-
Politics
Is Political Philosophy the key difference between west and the rest even now?
The author argues that Western success rests on political philosophy that demands answers not rooted in identity, and that societies without Enlightenment values stay trapped in tribal discourse, so philosophy…
-
Society
India’s Rotherham
The poster shares Indian news links on alleged cases of Muslim men targeting non-Muslim girls, calling them ‘India’s Rotherham’, while acknowledging some sources are questionable and mainstream media rarely cover…
-
Geopolitics
Clash Of Civilisations – Samuel Huntington
Suggests Samuel Huntington’s Clash of Civilizations deserves a revisit given Ukraine, China, Turkey, Myanmar and Modi’s India, and posts a collection of his quotes, beginning with the cultural differences between…
-
Brown Pundits
Climate and Civilizations
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/900-year-drought-wiped-out-indus-civilisation-iit-kharagpur/articleshow/63776710.cms
-
Politics
NDTV, the Left and the Maoists
A commenter argues that Arundhati Roy’s sympathy for Maoists reveals the nature of the Indian left, points to political violence in West Bengal and Kerala, and says Kashmir’s violence differs…
-
Brown Pundits
Islamism: Contested Perspectives on Political Islam
Islamism: Contested Perspectives on Political Islam” Edited by Richard C. Martin and Abbas Barzegar
-
Brown Pundits
Satire and the Bubble of Religion
An argument that satire of religion should stay possible, because without it every community turns tribal and counts its numbers.
-
History
Concert for Bangladesh.
A short post sharing the Concert for Bangladesh video, saying even an indulgent class can do good, and doubting that Ravi Shankar or George Harrison knew it was Hindus being…
-
Religion
India’s Oral Tradition
A commenter argues India’s oral tradition made possible the spectrum of beliefs on what survives death, from atheism and Buddhism to Sankhya and Advaita, and that these schools all grew…
-
History
Why Europe Pulled Ahead: Science, Printing and the Freedom to Criticise
A commenter argues that Islam, like the British, is invoked to explain India’s underdevelopment, that India once allowed freedom to criticise and produced thinkers who opposed caste, and that knowledge…
-
History
Ashoka, the Shungas and Buddhism
A commenter argues that Ashoka’s violence and later rulers’ patronage complicate the story of Buddhism’s decline, and quotes Ambedkar’s view that the Muslim invasions were the main cause of Buddhism’s…
-
Religion
artilce in outlook on Islam & reform
A quoted Outlook extract in which Shajahan Madampat argues that God’s grant of full freedom of action to Satan in the Quran is a model Muslims should follow for freedom…
-
Society
Ambedkar, Ramanuja and Hope in Hinduism
A comment-style post arguing that Ambedkar did not see Hinduism as hopeless, that Hindu thinkers could criticise caste, and that the coming of Islam hindered India’s moral development.
-
Society
Why tribalism wins
The author asks why tribalism wins, arguing that simple, identity-based ideas spread more easily than complex ones, and suggests guardrails such as skin in the game and incremental, tested interventions…
-
Religion
There is no morality
Responding to attacks in Tamil Nadu by followers of Periyar, the author argues that if religion is discarded for lack of evidence, morality should be discarded too, since humans are…
-
Society
Evolution of societies: A Perspective
The author proposes four factors for comparing societies: diversity of thought, scale and conformity, incentives and law, and external threat, and argues social science should study how societies change over…
-
Society
competition of different tribal dogmas/worldview
Links to two articles on tribalism, with a note that belief structures can be classified by openness to ideas, attitude to internal differences and attitude to outsiders.
-
Brown Pundits
Two Articles On Tribalism
http://nautil.us/issue/52/the-hive/is-tribalism-a-natural-malfunction http://nautil.us/blog/when-did-tribalism-get-to-be-so-fashionable
-
Brown Pundits
h
-
Economy
Headwinds Ahead : The Growing Divergence Between Truth and Productivity?
Arguing that productivity has always rested on understanding nature, the author says European societies gained from institutions such as patents and free speech, and asks whether a growing divergence between…
