Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

India

  • Dharms are Natural Democrats

    The indigenous record was procedurally rich and narrow. The colonial record was procedurally borrowed and narrow. In 1950 Delhi adopted universal adult suffrage at a stroke, literacy under a fifth,…

    X.T.M29 July 2026253 comments
  • The Writ of the Pakistani State into P.A.K

    Two states reached for the same instrument five weeks apart. The AJK police called the protesters a challenge to the writ of the state. Pradhan put tukde-tukde forces at Jantar…

    X.T.M28 July 2026165 comments
  • The Price of India’s Soul?

    X.T.M examines the Great Nicobar port and township project, arguing from reported Finance Ministry records that its strategic rationale was added after the fact, and asks whether the port is…

    X.T.M27 July 202625 comments
  • The Cockroach Takes a Bow

    Flag-occupation is not sufficient. Shaheen Bagh flew the tricolour and read the Preamble nightly, and was sorted out of the nation anyway. The CJP was not, and the difference is…

    X.T.M26 July 2026186 comments
  • The Hindufication of the Indian Bahá’í Community

    X.T.M notes that a Bahá’í prayer performed in Mumbai for the 2017 bicentenary was in Shuddh Hindi, and wonders whether that translation came from Urdu, Perso-Arabic sources or English, since…

    X.T.M25 July 20260 comments
  • Open Thread – Iran & CJP

    Open thread from X.T.M on the war in Iran and the continuing CJP protests in India, asking about Sonam Wangchuk and why the Education Minister has not resigned, with praise…

    X.T.M24 July 202646 comments
  • Thoughts on the 5 Point Plan?

    X.T.M quotes the Cockroach Janta Party’s five-point plan, from barring Chief Justices from Rajya Sabha seats to a 20-year ban on defectors, and strongly disagrees with the defection ban but…

    X.T.M23 July 202666 comments
  • Eliminator, Not Meritocracy

    X.T.M argues NEET is an eliminator, not a meritocracy, a rationing device for 1.3 lakh MBBS seats that measures stamina and family resources, yet should be kept because fragmented state…

    X.T.M22 July 2026139 comments
  • Open Thread: Raga the Martyr?

    Open thread on 21 July in Delhi: a photograph credited to PB of Sapan News of Rahul Gandhi being carried out of a large student and youth demonstration against the…

    X.T.M21 July 20268 comments
  • Best of Bharat

    X.T.M ends a Delhi trip at a Para athletes event and the Lotus Temple, and reads the visit as showing what a soft but strong Indian superpower looks like.

    X.T.M20 July 20260 comments
Brown Pundits