Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Open ThreadWhat’s new?81 comments · last comment agoAdd your thoughts →

India

  • The Self-Confident Hindu

    X.T.M asks whether a self-confident Hindu majority is a bad thing, arguing that India is a source rather than an appropriator of culture and that a confident majority held to…

    X.T.M20 July 202653 comments
  • Did Modi Make India Great Again?

    X.T.M, writing from Delhi, weighs what one Modi tenure has compounded against Britain’s seven prime ministers in a decade, citing India’s rise to fourth-largest economy, and asks what continuity buys…

    X.T.M19 July 2026204 comments
  • When in Bharat

    A one-line note from Delhi: the writer did not know what jamun was and has now eaten it twice in a single morning.

    X.T.M17 July 20265 comments
  • From Indus to Exile: Notes from Delhi

    The heat has gone out of the tribes, and what remains is argument. From a Delhi breakfast to Amardeep Singh’s talk on the Sindhi Nanak Panthis and the halls of…

    X.T.M14 July 20267 comments
  • Poison Trees: Mythological Fiction & Hindu Values – 1: Fixing the Bow

    Arkacandra Jayasimha, cross-posting a May 2026 series, answers a Centre for Studies in Hindu Conservatism essay on mythological fiction, arguing in part one that its reading of Marx’s ‘opium of…

  • desi open thread

    k jayas’s open thread of seven short items: the death of singer S. Janaki, Australian uranium sales to India, Modi, Rahul Gandhi’s travels, Hindu push-back over the Sutlej, urban flooding…

  • The Crescent and the Trident clash over their women

    X.T.M argues that the Crescent’s seclusion and the Trident’s ‘protection’ of women are unequal in statute, citing Pakistan’s Hudood Ordinances, but equivalent in structure, as the bahu-beti bachao slogan and…

  • Reading Dawn in Delhi.

    X.T.M reports Beena Sarwar’s talk at Mela Nordic’s Stockholm Partition event, tracing the end of Aman ki Asha to Sapan, a volunteer network with a minimum common agenda that bans…

    X.T.M7 July 20263 comments
  • The Meltwater Carries No Passport

    X.T.M reports Anuradha Bhasin’s talk at Mela Nordic’s Stockholm Partition event, which proposed cross-border newsrooms, a shared archive and arts as empathy, and weighs it against earlier attempts such as…

    X.T.M5 July 202621 comments
  • Geography is Power

    A reply to X.T.M’s post, this essay argues from realism that geography has shaped South Asian states’ trajectories, citing Mackinder and Spykman, Pakistan’s Cold War and GWOT frontier role, and…

    0M-31 July 20268 comments
Brown Pundits