Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Urdu

  • RIP Fahmida Riaz

    A note marking the death of the poet and scholar Fahmida Riaz, remembered for her fearlessness and an Indian exile under Zia, with Hasan Mujtaba’s tribute poem and a translation…

    Omar Ali21 November 201816 comments
  • Biryani Night

    Reporting on a Cambridge South Asian Forum screening of the Kashmiri film Harud, the author describes a round table where he argued that India cannot understand its Muslim minority and…

    X.T.M18 November 201874 comments
  • The Urdu-Speaking Inheritance

    Shares a speech by Senator Faruqi, praising the Urdu-speaking inheritance as defiant, liberal, just and aristocratic.

    X.T.M1 September 201876 comments
  • Urdu as an intra-provincial link language

    Picking up a reader’s point that Urdu binds ethnically diverse provinces, the author notes three Pakistani provinces have large linguistic minorities, discusses Pashtun expansion, the origin of the word vatan…

    X.T.M30 August 201827 comments
  • Suno Punjab

    Watching the Pakistani drama Suno Chanda, the author hears Punjabi at length for the first time and asks why it is treated as a rustic Urdu, then explores the Lahnda-Eastern…

    X.T.M28 August 201836 comments
  • Persian Vs. Punjabi Vs. Urdu

    Shares clips in which a speaker follows Persian words better in Urdu than in Punjabi mode, taking them as a sign of the divide between Punjabi popular culture and Urdu…

    X.T.M30 July 201812 comments
  • On ethnicity

    The author, from a Bangladeshi Muslim family in the US, describes his parents’ 1980s social circle as mostly South Asian, mixing Bangladeshis, Indian Bengalis and other clusters across ethnolinguistic lines,…

  • Muslims and Urdu in India

    Razib Khan plots Census 2011 data on Urdu speakers against Muslim share by state, finding the core Urdu-identified region in the Deccan and Bihar, about 30 per cent of Tamil…

  • Why not Persian for the pre-1971 Pakistan ?

    Razib Khan asks why Pakistan took Urdu rather than Persian as its national language, arguing Persian would have reduced language conflict, tied Pakistan to the Iranic world, and offered a…

    Vikram28 June 2018170 comments
  • The Rise of the RSS

    X.T.M, in a provocative aside, says India needs the BJP to manage minorities, lists changes he thinks Indian Muslims should make, and wonders whether liberal democracy fails with large minority…

    X.T.M8 March 20188 comments
Brown Pundits