Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Shoemakers, Merchants and the BJP

FlyDie and X.T.M16 November 2026FlyDie’s 5th and X.T.M’s 1,005th post7 min read0 comments
Painting of the Golden Mosque of Roshan ud-Daula on Chandni Chowk, Delhi, with traders’ stalls along the street below.
Chandni Chowk, Delhi, c. 1852. Painting: Ghulam Ali Khan, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

FlyDie, Volume Three: nine of his best comments on Indian politics, in his own words and spelling. Volume One and Volume Two cover South India, caste, language and religious history.

Voters Vote for Self-Interest, Not Faith

I think you are overestimating people’s change in their religious notions. From what I can see, most people’s realignment in politics seems to be based on their economic incentives and social incentives that are often unrelated to religion, though. … A consistent theme has been welfare and reservation bound together with caste politics, with a religious coating on top. …

From what I see, most people are incentivized for different reasons. Merchants like the BJP because of their neoliberal policies. The agriculturalist lower caste are satiated using welfare, and the Brahmanical/literati are satisfied by being given important positions.

Did Modi Make India Great Again?, 20 July 2026

Why a House, Not a Temple?

… communal tensions in some sense mask caste, class, and other conflicts. … If a Muslim merchant is being attacked by Hindu workers yelling JSR, the underlying issues might be class one, hidden underneath a religious garb to make it palatable to everyone else.

In “The King and the People: Sovereignty and Popular Politics in Mughal Delhi” by Abhisek Kaicker, there is a unique reference to a religious riot. … There were a bunch of Muslim shoemakers who lived in Delhi at the time. Over time, a Hindu Baniya merchant moved into this region and started taking up all the business from the shoemakers. Class tensions simmered over time between the two groups until one day a Muslim shoemaker was accidentally colored during Holi. … The Muslim mob decided to riot either way, and they proceeded to attack the Hindu Baniya merchant’s home, which was defended by his muslim bodyguards. … If this were a religious riot, they would be attacking a temple and not a merchant’s home.

Bin Qasim’s Thousand-Year Wound, 30 May 2026

The Hijab Bargain

Over time, people became less stringent as women were able to leave their households without male restrictions and had more freedom. This applied to every community, including muslims. The only difference between muslims and the other groups was that they were slower to change. …

So, [muslim conservatives] created things like the Hijab or burka, etc to act as a compromise; you can go outside without a male escort, but you have to cover yourself. In this way, the women get a degree of freedom, thereby reducing the desire to rebel, while conservatives get to retain their authority over women. … So, it seems like the number of people wearing it increased, when in reality the women previously bound in homes have started to step out. …

Ironically, the excessive decision to outright ban or control this clothing gave it validation and shifted it from a conservative compromise into a symbol of resistance.

Pakistan Punches Above Its Weight. Blame Aligarh, 20 September 2026

Congress Is a Battle Royale

Congress is basically a battle royale party, a massive tent party, where the winner takes all kinda of model. … Basically, it’s easy to enter or leave, but never easy to rise in rank. … this focus on practical politics over ideology has helped the party ensure its survival long after what should have been its expiration date. …

On the other hand, the BJP/RSS/Communists/Marxists/Naxals and others like them are organized in the near-inverse manner: vertically. Usually, anyone who wants to join can’t simply become a part of their organization without agreeing with their ideological positions, and leaving these entities is often difficult. … Internal dissent is often suppressed and often builds up over time until it eventually blows up in your face at some point. …

In simple terms, the BJP will decline over time, but Congress can’t fill its shoes, and it’s going to create a political vacuum with a lot of uncertainties. Of course, this is my opinion, and reality may go in a different direction.

Did Iran Change the Regime in the USA?, 8 November 2026

The Pendulum Swings Back to Caste

Almost all the political parties in India, irrespective of economic positioning, have been socially conservative in one way or another. …

Communists and other left-leaning groups favored things like land reforms that explicitly benefited the lower caste groups. Furthermore, the Congress has always favored more extensive welfare policies that helped uplift a significant portion of OBCs who were economically depressed. Over time, these groups saw a gradual improvement in their socioeconomic conditions, which naturally shifted their economic interests towards other financial and social interests that the BJP was able to provide. Even then, not all OBCs followed the same pathway. …

Religious nationalism was fundamentally the basic glue that held these groups together as part of a shared Hindu community. However, the Indian political pendulum has always swung between religious consolidation and caste consolidation, which inevitably means that religious consolidation fades with time as caste conflict arises and consolidation under caste identity happens.

Did Iran Change the Regime in the USA?, 8 November 2026

Why Even the BJP Doesn’t Want Riots

In addition to communal violence, insurgencies have gone down over the years as well since the government started changing its traditional strategies. … The government switched up this strategy with financial incentives like roads, infrastructure, or health care services being provided to the tribal population, which indirectly provided a pathway for the military to move into insurgent spaces. …

Mind you, none of this means that communal violence or insurgency is completely gone in Manipur, Phalgam, or every other occasional incident. … the recent rise is bad, but it is still better than the last major incident to happen, so there does seem to be some clear restraint. …

Even the BJP wouldn’t want its citizens to start riots since it’s something that they can’t control; after all, a raging mob doesn’t differentiate between the state enforcers or their main target. … In this new reality, the main issues relating to Indian muslims these days heavily stem from segregation, animal bans, discriminatory hiring practices, poverty, and other more mundane systematic issues that affect daily life.

Hindu-Muslim violence is changing, 4 June 2026

Indians and Pakistanis Are Drifting Apart, and That’s a Good Thing

See, I think there are more issues at hand as to why Indians and Pakistanis don’t interact as extensively. From what I see, both groups are culturally diverging at this point in extreme ways. There aren’t that many people who share experiences or memories of the undivided times under British rule. The old Ganga-Yamuna Tehzeeb and the broader Hindu-Muslim syncretic culture that acted as a common denominator between the two countries is gradually fading away. …

Oddly enough, I think the diaspora seems to preserve the older cultural aspects due to the fact that they are kinda in a time capsule, culturally speaking. …

In essence, this divergence does present a pathway for a better future since it allows people to focus on the internal matters of their own country and develop an identity separate from past ones. People-to-people interactions in some sense have made relations between India and all its neighbouring countries exceptionally bad; a little distance is probably for the better for everyone.

Bin Qasim’s Thousand-Year Wound, 30 May 2026

Kashmir: Who Gets to Leave?

… none of the points that you stated here ever truly addressed the very large question of what becomes of the 23% of non-muslims that live in that region. This 23% owns most of the land that forms Ladakh and Jammu, which I doubt they are willing to give up in favor of joining a country that will probably not treat them well. All of this works under the assumption that the Kashmiri people want to actually join the state of Pakistan rather than make a country for themselves. … What happens if a district decides not to secede, but all the surrounding districts want to secede? How would the land be divided? …

There is an old belief in Kerala that the first person you see at the start of your day represents how the rest of your day goes. A lucky person brings a good day, and an unlucky person brings a bad day. How something begins will determine how it will end; a relationship that starts in death and the displacement of millions would never end in anything but violence. I doubt this relationship would have been better even without Kashmir being added to the mix. The fact that this relationship is stuck in a limbo would be better for everyone else, since the alternative was always going to be violence.

India’s Wealth will not turn Pakistan into East Germany, 6 June 2026

Can Indians and Pakistanis Write on the Other?

… most people here have an opinion about a specific subject that they hold onto quite strongly, without reflecting on their own position. The result would be an endless circular argument, where everyone makes the same arguments over and over again with no nuance or end in sight. I, myself, am guilty of this on certain occasions. …

On top of that, a sizeable portion of the discussion about anything South Asia requires additional cultural knowledge and education (via readings or schooling) on many subjects in order to have certain discussions. I can’t explain the intricacies of caste to someone who neither lives in such a cultural context nor is extensively well-read on the subject matter. It’s kinda why I don’t comment on Pakistani issues since I lack that cultural context. …

I will just leave his quote from the Inquiry into the True Nature of Things by Raghunatha Siromani, the first modern philosopher of South Asia and a major figure in the Navya Nyaya school: … These matters spoken of should not be cast aside without reflection just because they are contrary to accepted opinion; scholars should consider them carefully.

Bin Qasim’s Thousand-Year Wound, 31 May 2026

Start the argument

0 comments
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Brown Pundits
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x