Brown Pundits Archive
Most popular · Most recent
-
Iran’s geostrategic importance
-
Politics
The bounds of decency
A report on the daughter of convicts in the Rajiv Gandhi case pleading for her father’s release, with the poster arguing that regional identity shields gangsters and that Modi’s electoral…
-
Baloch terrorism?
After a train bombing in southern Pakistan, the author argues that if Baloch separatists are responsible it is self-defeating, since children are among the dead, and invites informed comment on…
-
The Islamic System of Government
The author says the farcical Taliban talks have prompted TV debates on replacing Western democracy with an Islamic system, a debate Islamists start with an advantage because Pakistan’s founders promised…
-
Another reason to hate Putin; fewer abortions?
The poster notes that Russian abortions fell from 2.5 per live birth in the 1990s to 0.42 after Putin took power, and wonders whether the West resents Russia’s resurgence or…
-
Society
Can inter-sect marriages save Pakistani society?
An extract on a young Pakistani woman, with a Shia father and Sunni mother, who refuses to choose a sect, asking whether inter-sect marriages could help heal sectarian divides.
-
Politics
You gotta love the Bhutto-Z kids
A link to a video of the Bhutto-Zardari siblings, with the poster’s comment on hereditary princeling antics and the weak state of Sindhi in India.
-
Dirty War in Balochistan
The author notes that mass graves found in Balochistan, which the home minister blames on Indian intelligence while most suspect missing Baloch nationalists, have drawn little attention, and suggests Western…
-
Conversation with Prof. Aseem Shrivastava
Another Browncast is up. You can listen on Libsyn, Apple, Spotify, and Stitcher (and a variety of other platforms). Probably the easiest way to keep up the podcast since we don’t have a regular…
-
Brown Pundits
Mawtana Rabba and the Role of Climate Change and Plague in the Rise of Islam
Part Two: Modern tree-ring dating techniques inform us that during the 6th century CE most of the world was enveloped in a 125-year-long mini Ice Age . It was caused…
-
Brown Pundits
Brown Pundits is now back at Brownpundits.com
Please update your bookmarks to brownpundits.com. Update your RSS to feeds.feedburner.com/Brownpundits.
-
Brown Pundits
Gay leather man & Pakistani American
-
Geopolitics
India-Pakistan people’s peace resolution: Throwing a pebble in the pond
Reports on a peace resolution circulated by Indian and Pakistani activists, seventy years after Partition, urging both governments to improve relations, and quotes its preamble on visas, civilians in conflict…
-
Brown Pundits
16th cavalry: a historic picture, and an anecdote from Kashmir
-
Brown Pundits
Islam doesn’t understand democracy!
-
Brown Pundits
Gary Taubes and Sam Harris discuss the obesity epidemic
-
Politics
Islam is Breaking the Back of the Liberal Democratic Consensus
Dr Abdul Majeed Abid argues that Islam may be the rock on which the Western liberal democratic consensus is breaking, citing Turkey and France, while the editor adds that loyalty…
-
Brown Pundits
Blasphemy and Blasphemy laws. The Big Picture
-
Geopolitics
Pakistan: Managing the Coalition Business
Hamid Hussain examines Pakistan’s decision to let recently retired army chief General Raheel Sharif head the Saudi-led coalition, noting that neither government nor general has clarified the terms, nature, objectives…
-
Review: Age of Anger. Pankaj Mishra
An admitted rant rather than a review, aimed less at Pankaj Mishra personally than at the postliberal Eurocentric elite he writes for and who admire him, taking issue with Age…
-
Review. Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw
Hamid Hussain recommends a review of Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw: The Man and His Times by Behram and Zenobia Panthaki, offering Manekshaw’s conduct as a model for Indian and Pakistani…
-
A Few Questions re Trumpistan..
Posing questions on Trump’s America, the author argues Trump and his advisers truly believe the United States is in a fight to the death with Islam, with Putin as ally,…
-
The INA (Indian National Army)
Hamid Hussain recounts the Indian National Army, formed in the Second World War from Indian prisoners captured by the Japanese, against the rapid wartime expansion of the Indian Army and…
-
Brown Pundits
China’s coming dominance in science
http://www.businessinsider.com/chinas-scientific-dominance-is-a-done-deal-2014-6
-
Politics
Neti, Neti.. Left and Right in Trumpian America
A collection of headlines and quotations on Trump, Bannon and the liberal order, set against Avadhuta Gita verses on ‘neti, neti’, with a brief argument about whether identity politics can…
-
Politics
Harmless Secular Activists “Disappeared” in Pakistan
The author asks why several secular bloggers and rights activists disappeared across Pakistan in one week, noting that the pattern suggests the intelligence agencies, and that English-language, social-media activists in…
-
Major General Anant Singh Pathania MVC, MC
Hamid Hussain circulates Maj Gen Syed Ali Hamid’s profile of Maj Gen Anant Singh Pathania, MVC, MC, from a family of warriors tied to the hill state of Nurpur, adding…
-
History
Review of Crossed Swords; a History of the Pakistan Army
Reposts Major Agha H. Amin’s acerbic 2008 review of Shuja Nawaz’s Crossed Swords, which welcomes the book’s new sources and information but judges most of it anecdotal and notes it…
-
Geopolitics
General Raheel Sharif in Saudi Arabia
Hamid Hussain looks at General Raheel Sharif’s move to Saudi Arabia after retiring as Pakistan’s army chief, set against the Yemen war and a Saudi-led coalition of 39 Sunni states…
-
The Bokhari Brothers and Lionell Fielden
Hamid Hussain pays tribute to Ahmed Shah and Zulfiqar Ali Bokhari, scions of Peshawar tied to the history of broadcasting in India, and to Lionel Fielden, who came from the…
-
PIA’s Black Goat Sacrifice
Describes PIA engineers sacrificing a black goat at Islamabad airport before resuming ATR flights after a crash, and sets out the derision of westernised Pakistanis and objections from orthodox Muslims,…
-
Brown Pundits
Untitled, 12 December 2016
-
Lt Gen SK Sinha
Hamid Hussain remembers Lieutenant General S. K. Sinha (1926-2016), who came from a Bihar police family, joined the army at the end of the Second World War and spent three…
-
President Trump. The unknown unknowns..
After Trump’s election, the author gathers several well-regarded pieces on why and how it happened, adds brief comments on each, and then sets out his own thoughts and open questions…
-
Stephen Bannon Speaks..
The author discusses Stephen Bannon’s 2014 Vatican conference remarks, noting his commitment to a global war with Islam and his elite-bashing, and argues that his ‘Judeo-Christian West’ history and economic…
-
Guide 1965
-
President Trump
A short post of numbered questions after Trump’s win: what a President Trump can deliver for rust-belt voters, which of the predicted disasters might come true, and where his instincts…
-
Pakistan and GHQ’s commitment to fight terrorists..
The author asks how outsiders can judge whether the Pakistan army is committed to defeating all Islamist militant groups, and proposes public metrics, such as whether the main enemy is…
-
More “Collateral Damage” in Quetta General Durrani
After an attack on a police training college in Quetta killed about 50 recruits, the author points to overlapping militant groups with semi-legal sponsors and mocks the military’s media machine,…
-
Musharraf’s Coup. October 1999
Hamid Hussain, in a piece first written in 2012, reviews the background to the October 1999 coup, the differences between Nawaz Sharif and General Musharraf after Kargil, and the decisions…
-
Brown Pundits
Kashmir: India Tries a Reset
-
Brown Pundits
India and Pakistan. Again at the
-
A Tale of Two Professors
Hamid Hussain tells the stories of two assistant professors, one killed protecting students in the January 2016 attack on Bacha Khan University in Pakistan and one in Afghanistan, as human…
-
The Decline (and Attempted Rise) of the Sunnis in the Middle East
The author discusses Martin Kramer’s essay on the decline and attempted revival of Sunni power in the Middle East since the Ottomans, arguing that Islamists will recognise this story, and…
-
Mangal Pandey. Truth and Fiction
Hamid Hussain checks scene by scene how far the film Mangal Pandey: The Rising follows the historical record, noting that its core facts are broadly intact but that the Afghanistan…
-
Mangal Pandey. Truth and Fiction
Hamid Hussain checks the film Mangal Pandey: The Rising against the historical record, scene by scene, finding the core facts of the 1857 episode kept intact but much invented, such…
-
The Civilizational Unity of India
The author posts excerpts from a Hindutva-leaning article on India’s civilisational unity, saying its arguments are largely reasonable, while noting that even such writers struggle with the Indo-European migration.
-
Dhaka Attackers; BD elite and NYT are “shocked” by their origins..
Responding to a New York Times report that some Dhaka attackers came from elite schools and wealthy families, the author argues this should surprise no one, since revolutionary violent movements…
-
History
Origins of the British East India Company Army
Hamid Hussain traces the origins of the East India Company’s army in the anarchy of eighteenth-century India, arguing that the Company won control of large areas through superior military organisation…
-
Brexit
Noting that his social-media circle almost universally condemns Brexit, the author argues that the large leave vote should be explained rather than dismissed as racism, and offers some loosely ordered…
-
Indian History, Brexit, Trump and the Bombay Fornicator
In a set of random thoughts, the author recommends a Hindu-nationalist writer’s summary of what is known about the Aryans, observes that many Pakistanis repeat 1950s textbook views on it,…
-
Orlando. Stochastically predictable?
After the Orlando attack, the author argues that classical shariah-based Islam endorses violence against gays, yet practical tolerance of homosexuality in the Islamicate world was long very high, so a…
-
An Honor-able Society
Reproduces Tribune and Telegraph reports on a Lahore mother who police say burned her daughter alive for marrying by choice, with other recent cases, a government inquiry and the Human…
-
Afghanistan, and some hints from Machiavelli
Hamid Hussain’s candid comments on Khalid Aziz’s article on Afghanistan, which he calls a ‘snake pit’, argue that Machiavelli is the right guide and that real thinking differs from public…
-
Science
Review of Dark Territory (Cyber war)
Hamid Hussain reviews Fred Kaplan’s Dark Territory, a history of cyber war from the 1983 War Games scare to offensive capabilities, finding it a well-drawn account of a largely classified…
-
Akhtat Mansour, Islamic Wife-beating and Muslims for Trump 5-29-2016
The author uses the drone strike that killed Taliban leader Mullah Mansoor to question Pakistan’s double role as a US ally and Taliban backer, then adds further ‘random thoughts’ on…
-
Diaspora
Asian Americans: Model Minority, POC or just a bad idea?
Quoting Razib Khan’s response to a Quartz piece, the post argues the ‘model minority myth’ framing is selectively applied, then asks why some South Asian American intellectuals insist Asian Americans…
-
Politics
Donald Trump Quotes
A list of quoted remarks attributed to Donald Trump, posted without commentary.
-
History
Book Review: Monsoon War (the war of 1965)
Hamid Hussain reviews Tajindar Shergill and Amarinder Singh’s The Monsoon War, calling it an encyclopedic account of every phase of the 1965 India-Pakistan war, built on Indian and Pakistani sources…
-
Brown Pundits
Is it Game Over for the Muslim World?
-
Brown Pundits
Iran’s Lasting Influence on India
-
Brown Pundits
The Machete Killers of Bangladesh
-
Geopolitics
Operation Z to A
Hamid Hussain assesses Pakistan’s Operation Zarb-e-Azb, written at a pessimistic officer’s request, noting that army opinion ranges from declared victory to doubt, and adding tribesmen’s and foreign observers’ views that…
-
The Army is on the job..
The author argues that the Pakistan army uses every crisis, here the latest attack, to elbow civilians aside, with ISPR press releases presenting its action in Punjab as unilateral and…
-
Geopolitics
Scott Atran Proposes.. Boy Scout troops??
The author criticises Scott Atran’s proposal of community-based, youth-led ‘peace-building’ as an alternative to ISIS, arguing it is vague and offers no actionable recommendations.
-
Brussels. Islam, War on Terror, History..
After the Brussels attacks, the author reposts excerpts from earlier pieces on cultural and religious issues in the war with Islamist terror, adding that policing matters more in the short…
-
Trump, the phenomenon
The author recommends Adam Elkus’s essay on the Trump phenomenon and adds that the internet’s bypassing of gatekeepers helps explain ‘why now’, quoting the essay’s closing paragraphs.
-
Geopolitics
Drone Warfare; The Unblinking Eye
Hamid Hussain surveys armed drones as the most open secret of modern warfare, reviewing how target killing grew out of post-9/11 detention problems and weighing opponents’ claim that drones kill…
-
Religion
Adonis: “Islam Cannot be Modernized”
The author thinks Adonis is probably right about classical Islam, whose apostasy and blasphemy rules resist top-down reform, but argues change will still come as practice outruns legal and theological…
-
Religion
The Triumph of Classical Islam and the slow fall of the Islamicate World
Asking whether the solidification of Islamic theology harmed the Islamicate world, the author reproduces a review of Robert Reilly’s book The Closing of the Muslim Mind, which blames the victory…
-
Politics
Bhutto Hereticizes the Ahmedis
The author preserves a Facebook comment by Ammar Ali Qureshi about whether Bhutto intended the 1974 amendment declaring Ahmadis non-Muslim, or was pushed by agitation, recalling a police officer’s account…
-
Pakistan and India 2016. To talk or not to talk?
After the Pathankot air base attack, the author argues India should continue talks with Pakistan despite the doubts, reading the strategic situation through Myra Macdonald’s analysis and judging that some…
-
Brown Pundits
Talking to Pakistan; For now..
-
Brown Pundits
The Empire Strikes Back, at Pathankot
-
Scott Atran: Parochial Anthropologist
A link, posted without comment, to an Aeon essay by Scott Atran arguing that ISIS is a world-altering revolution born of danger and death, brotherhood and joy.
-
Geopolitics
Modeling ISIS chances in your country..
A thought experiment asking whether a two-variable model, Muslim popular support for classical Sunni shariah and the strength of state security, could predict a serious ISIS threat in a given…
-
Roger Scruton on the Postmodern Turn
The author recommends Roger Scruton’s essay on the postmodern turn, quoting extended excerpts on how the literature of critical theory targets an enemy and the language of rational argument.
-
Saudi TV Host and Islamic Militant
A short comment on a video of a Saudi TV host and a jihadi, arguing the host has no logical argument against the militant once Wahhabi ideology is accepted.
-
Peshawar: Massacre of the Innocents.
Reposting last year’s reaction to the Peshawar school massacre, the author invites readers to judge which parts are now irrelevant and which remain unchanged, opening with a survivor’s testimony and…
-
Politics
Trial by Trump: Testing Times for the Republican Party
The author reads Trump’s call to keep Muslims out of the United States as a test of character for the Republican Party, asking whether the party of Lincoln will still…
-
History
East Pakistan to Bangladesh, some comments
Hamid Hussain annotates Brigadier Samson Sharaf’s op-ed on 1906-1971, which the poster calls a Pakistani army officer’s non-Islamist view, adding comments on the Muslim League’s treatment of Bengal and on…
-
History
Book Review: The Last Warlord
Hamid Hussain reviews Brian Glyn Williams’s The Last Warlord, a friendly life of Abdul Rashid Dostum that presents him as a moderate secular leader seeking a fair share for Uzbeks,…
-
San Bernadino Terror Attack
The author recounts the San Bernardino attack by a Pakistani-American couple, setting out what was known of the shooters, their weapons and the reported pledge to ISIS, and considers what…
-
Review: Over the Tightrope
A review of Asif Ismaeel’s debut novel Over the Tightrope, praised as a stunning and unexpected mix of dystopian science fiction, Sufism, politics and humour, set in a Salafist ‘Al-Bakistan’…
-
Geopolitics
Why do Muslims Blow Stuff Up?
Responding to Harbir Singh Nain’s Nation piece blaming Saudi-funded fundamentalism for Muslim terrorism, the author agrees that Saudi oil money and Wahhabism matter, but argues Islamists also harbour world-power ambitions,…
-
Farewell Sykes-Picot. You will be much missed..
The author argues it is overstated that Sykes-Picot created the modern Middle East’s troubles, since Arab states never built convincing narratives for their own existence, and asks which of several…
-
Paris, Islam, ISIS and Sykes-Picot. Random Thoughts
After the Paris attacks, the author describes the Mumbai-style operation and ISIS’s recent bombings in Ankara, Beirut and against a Russian aircraft, then offers random thoughts on Islam, the group’s…
-
Religion
Is the Islamic State Islamic? by Charles Cameron
Posting Charles Cameron’s piece from Zenpundit, the author asks whether ISIS is Islamic, noting that the Khawarij were regarded as heretics by Muslims yet form a recognisable stream of revolt,…
-
Hamid Hussain: Remembering Colonel Shuja Khanzada
Hamid Hussain remembers Colonel Shuja Khanzada (1943-2015), the Punjab home minister killed in a suicide attack in Attock, tracing his military family’s service in the British Indian army and his…
-
History
Hamid Hussain Reviews Cloughley’s Book about the Pakistan Army
Hamid Hussain reviews the fourth edition of Brian Cloughley’s A History of the Pakistan Army, welcoming new chapters on the Musharraf and Kayani eras and the author’s long access to…
-
No Water from Mosque for Christians
A news report, by Wilson Chowdhry, on a Christian family in Wazirabad accused of blasphemy over drawing water from a mosque, with a brief comment that comparing Pakistani Christians to…
-
Politics
Is Jeremy Corbyn a Tory pawn to annihilate the Labour Party forever?
The author argues Jeremy Corbyn will lose badly because elections turn on middle-class and working-class white English voters who dislike immigrants and the rich alike, so Labour should run lightly…
-
Brown Pundits
Mob Murder in Dadri
-
Geopolitics
A Letter from Former ISI DG Javed Qazi (and comments from Dr Hussain)
Hamid Hussain annotates former ISI chief General Javed Ashraf Qazi’s letter on the army’s role in creating the jihadi problem, adding comments, drawn partly from a biography of Auchinleck, that…
-
Joseph Conrad, the Modern World, Yemen; Random Thoughts
Triggered by a Prospect essay on Joseph Conrad, the author posts excerpts, a piece on Yemen and his own Facebook remarks in an impressionistic post, arguing Conrad anticipated far more…
-
Indian Studies; Reversing the Metropolitan Gaze
The author links Samir Chopra’s long essay criticising the Rajiv Malhotra and Balagangadhara school’s project of reversing the Western gaze on India, quoting Satadru Sen’s point that colonial power underwrote…
-
History
Colonel Imam As I Knew Him
An unsigned reminiscence of Colonel Imam (Sultan Amir) by a fellow Pakistan army officer who knew him from 1966, recalling their early years as young officers in Lahore, sent in…
-
Romila Thapar. Something is missing..
Commenting on an interview with Romila Thapar, the author says he accepts her sceptical, neutral historian’s ideal but finds she lacks a vision of what India is and why India…
-
Geopolitics
Decline in Violence Worldwide; For Now?
Quoting Steven Pinker’s Guardian piece on the continuing worldwide decline in violence, the author adds a Facebook exchange questioning how far that decline can be taken as a lasting trend…
-
The 1965 War. A Summary by Major Amin
The author reposts Major Amin’s long article on the 1965 India-Pakistan war, offered as a more objective view because both countries claim victory, arguing Pakistan’s Kashmir operations misjudged India’s response…
