Brown Pundits Archive
Most popular · Most recent
-
The Bangladesh Paradox
The poster relays economist Jyoti Rahman’s study of why Bangladesh cut poverty faster than its growth suggests, offering a speculative story of garment jobs for women, migrant labour, NGOs and…
-
Politics
The truth will always out
Quotes Kerala Congress leader T H Mustafa calling Rahul Gandhi a joker and urging Priyanka Gandhi to lead, with the poster adding that the party should shed its dynasty’s liabilities,…
-
The Christian Brotherhood
The poster argues the rise of a ‘Christian Brotherhood’ draws little comment compared with its Muslim, Hindu and Buddhist counterparts, citing church positions on abortion, anti-gay laws in Uganda, Putin’s…
-
Society
11 bullets? one, two..not enough??
A report on the shooting of an American cardiologist in Pakistan, with the poster’s view that good deeds there are hazardous and that diaspora members should avoid such risks, and…
-
Politics
Inequality caused by “neoliberal, neopatriarchy”
Objecting to the ‘neo’ prefix, the poster takes issue with a Guardian call for a women’s revolution and a commenter’s claim that Chinese women were better off under Mao, calling…
-
Geopolitics
How alike are Pakistan and Israel?
Taking up the question of how alike Pakistan and Israel are, the poster notes both were created after the Second World War as religiously defined states, cites Zia’s remark, P…
-
Society
S Anand
Profiles S Anand, whose publishing house Navayana takes its name from Ambedkar’s Buddhism and publishes books against caste prejudice, using quoted coverage of its awards and links to earlier Brown…
-
Politics
Arundhati Roy explains the Modi-plan
Posts key points from an Arundhati Roy interview describing a democratically elected totalitarian government under Modi, with the poster’s sarcastic aside that tribals, not Muslims, will be sacrificed to corporates.
-
Mossad + (jewish controlled) Twitter = Victory!!!
Noting claims that Twitter won the election for Modi and a Congress leader’s claim that Mossad did, the poster mockingly joins the two into a conspiracy chain, while remarking on…
-
Politics
An american visits Un-India (discovers Modindia)
Responding to Daniel Berman’s account of travelling through India before the vote, the poster finds the analysis largely sound, says Modified Indians see India as a sleeping developed country, and…
-
Kashmiri students expelled from Meerut
After Kashmiri students were charged with sedition for cheering Pakistan’s cricket team, ten were expelled from a Meerut university; the poster says young people must be allowed to speak and…
-
Nawaz Sharif is coming to Delhi
As Nawaz Sharif prepares to visit Delhi, the poster quotes Maryam Nawaz’s tweet urging cordial relations with the new Indian government, with a quoted profile of her as a rising…
-
Politics
India: controlled by (kosher) remote?
Admitting poor political instincts, the poster recalls expecting a BJP win in 2009, argues Congress won partly because voters wanted Pakistan pacified and feared the ISI, and says the Modi…
-
History
The good old days (human heads as cannonballs)
Introduces a long extract on a siege of Malta, in which a sentry finds crosses bearing headless bodies in the harbour, with the poster remarking that historians spin stories but…
-
Brown Pundits
Dear Naveen, BB (Big Bosses): an appeal
A welcome note to a new contributor, Naveen, with advice on introductions and keeping post titles short.
-
Geopolitics
Mrs Menon goes to (two) Pakistan(s)
Reading Meena Menon’s closing report from Pakistan, the poster notes Indian journalists were expelled, asks why she says little on Pakistan’s Hindus, cites a lawmaker that thousands leave yearly, and…
-
Politics
Aatish Taseer has the final word (NaMo vs. RaGa)
Praises Aatish Taseer’s article on why elites like Rahul Gandhi lost and may never rule India, with quoted passages on Modi’s mocking of poverty as a state of mind and…
-
Twitter for your thoughts
The poster argues that the Indian and Israeli far right differ from Europe’s: they want to be Westerners with a thin Hindu or Hebrew overlay, while local cultures fade. It…
-
Society
North Indians (agressive fighters) vs. South
Posted as exam results were declared, this note on student suicides in the southern states reproduces an interview with the helpline SNEHA. It urges readers to support those at risk…
-
Politics
Couple of thoughts.
Three short thoughts: Chetan Bhagat’s argument that separate laws for Kashmir and Muslims underpin Indian secularism, the BJP’s win mirroring the PML-N’s in Pakistan, and a personal aside about sleep…
-
Politics
Voice of the Hindus
The poster defends Three Idiots against Pankaj Mishra’s dislike of Chetan Bhagat, then reproduces Bhagat’s column listing dos and don’ts for Hindus as results approach, including that Hindus should not…
-
Geopolitics
by Jove, I think he’s got it!!
A news report that the White House congratulated Modi and said he is welcome to visit the US, which had denied him a visa since 2005. The poster frames it…
-
Politics
Indira reborn
A short comment calling Priyanka Gandhi ‘Indira incarnate’ after Rahul’s failure, suggesting the BJP offer an opt-in uniform civil code, and predicting Modi’s party could stay ascendant for two more…
-
South Asians more lactose friendly than Middle Easterners?
-
BJP: CVoter 289, ABP 281, CNN 276, Cicero 272
Surveying exit polls that project a BJP-led majority, the poster notes the record 66 per cent turnout and state-by-state predictions, and says India looks set to welcome her first Shudra…
-
Society
“fake OBC” is not the “real” problem
The poster argues the ‘fake OBC’ row over Modi distracts from real caste discrimination, and that elites play the caste card for reservations, marginal votes and debating points. It urges…
-
The 51st state
Reacting to an FBI agent’s presence in Pakistan without a government invitation, the poster jokes that Pakistan is America’s 51st state and argues that Washington should explain, with possible reasons…
-
Gujarat model: a Pakistani perspective
A comment with extracts from a Pakistani traveller’s account of Gujarat: round-the-clock electricity and safe streets for women, but segregated neighbourhoods, anti-alcohol rules and an uneven benefit to the poor.…
-
The (im)moral Maharajah
The poster argues that adultery between a journalist and a politician is a private matter, that paid news already undermines neutrality in Indian media, and that it is nonetheless amusing…
-
Politics
Slum-dog vs. Hans Solo
The poster summarises John Oliver’s segment on the Indian election, which pokes fun at American indifference, Rahul Gandhi’s lineage, Narendra Modi’s record on the 2002 riots and CNN’s inflated electorate…
-
Selfie (833AM), self-less (834AM)
A warning against taking selfies, texting or posting while driving, prompted by a news extract on a woman killed in a US head-on collision seconds after updating her status.
-
An Atheist upgrades to Allah (via Jesus )
A comment on an interview with Reza Aslan on tradition, why al-Qaeda is not anti-modern and his own moves from Christianity to Islam, with the poster asking what led him…
-
Politics
“We love Pakistan army and ISI”
A comment on Geo TV’s unprecedented public defiance of the ISI after the attack on Hamid Mir; the poster expects little to change except Geo’s demise, but thinks breaking the…
-
Deep State Fatwa: shut down Geo TV (or else)
A comment, with a news extract, on the Pakistan Army’s demand that Geo TV be shut after it accused the ISI of ordering an attack on Hamid Mir; the poster…
-
Politics
Affirmative action is dead
A comment, with a news extract, on the US Supreme Court’s 6-2 ruling that Michigan may ban affirmative action in public education; the poster attributes it to the Southern white…
-
Science
500 mil Speedsters on the (Whats App) Freeway
A short comment on WhatsApp passing 500 million users, with growth led by India and Brazil, noting that nobody yet knows how to monetise the app; an extract from WhatsApp’s…
-
TCS (soft)powers India to Premier League
A comment on Tata Consultancy Services entering the world’s top ten IT services firms by revenue, with the poster suggesting that what is good for TCS is now good for…
-
Society
Dr Mattu (hero) vs. NHS (bully)
A comment, with a news extract, on a doctor who won a case against the NHS; the poster calls it a relief that British courts rescued a whistle-blower and says…
-
“Dad, don’t worry. I’ve got a life vest on…”
A reflection, with a news extract, on the text messages of a teenage girl on the Sewol ferry telling her father she had a life vest on, and the comfort…
-
Vijay-anna ki Pulitzer vijay
The poster congratulates the poet Vijay Seshadri on his Pulitzer Prize, links earlier Sepia Mutiny coverage, and raises the case of a publisher blacklisting a star author for politically incorrect…
-
Coastal Leader for a prosperous India
The author argues that India’s leaders have mostly come from the north, far from the coast, and welcomes the writer Joe D’Cruz’s endorsement of Narendra Modi as a coastal leader…
-
Politics
“Some can resist these pressures. Others succumb”
A post on PC Parakh’s book about the coal allocation scandal, which says Manmohan Singh overruled calls for auctions. The poster sees the book’s timing as a BJP-driven election ploy…
-
(Tata) Car Of The Year (COTY)
A light note on a Jaguar sports car winning a car award, praised as a Tata product, with background on Bombay House, the Tata Group’s Mumbai headquarters.
-
The “hospital of death”
An article on infant deaths at Kolkata’s B.C. Roy children’s hospital, which the poster reads as a sign of deep rot in Bengal’s health system, set against the memory of…
-
Society
An orphan for life
A profile of Jashodaben, Narendra Modi’s estranged wife, from the Indian Express. The poster calls her the last of a generation of women who stand by their men and sees…
-
1 Bil fighters for Mother India
A post on Facebook’s push to reach a billion Indian users during the elections, noting Modi’s large online following, with a swipe at the claim that American firms feed Hindutva.
-
21st century amrit (elixir of life)
A post on a Swiss study suggesting glucosamine extended the lives of mice by 10 per cent, with the poster’s remarks on animal testing and the trade in rhino and…
-
Economy
Indelible (not quite) ink: Maharajah brand
A report on the Mysore factory that makes the indelible ink used on voters’ fingers around the world, which the poster sees as an Indian technology success.
-
Politics
Taliban Justice. Then and Now
The poster points to Kahar Zalmay’s report on taking a Karachi property dispute to a Taliban commander’s court in North Waziristan, and reposts his own six-year-old account, suggesting the heroic…
-
Geopolitics
Reihan Salam- neocon unlimited
The poster is puzzled by Reihan Salam’s defence of American policy on the 1971 Bangladesh war, noting that Nixon never told the Pakistan Army to stop, though Salam admits a…
-
Kargil War
Reposting an older piece, the author argues Kargil was no great victory thrown away by Nawaz Sharif. He once accepted the ‘tactical success, strategic blunder’ line, but later details showed…
-
India- Hindu or Secular?
The poster argues India is neither simply Hindu nor secular, as Hindus are not a single bloc and ‘secular’ is used to play communities against each other, with a report…
-
Politics
Why Dilip Babu will not vote for BJP
The poster reproduces Dilip D’Souza’s explanation of why he will not vote BJP, however good the local candidate, and says the party’s challenge is to win over people like him.
-
Politics
Tulsi Gabbard: defender of the faith
The poster salutes Tulsi Gabbard for defending Hindus, alongside a report that US commission witnesses warned a BJP government would harm India’s religious minorities.
-
Religious diversity in the world
The poster thinks a Pew religious diversity map undercounts India and Iran, where Bahá’ís may fear exclusion, alongside a report that Pakistan is more religiously diverse than 48 other countries.
-
Geopolitics
The guns of Sevastopol
A report on McDonald’s closing its Crimean outlets and on Russia’s gas price rise for Ukraine, with the poster joking that a new cold war opens with a burger strike.
-
Diaspora
The race for top US jobs (India > China)
A Wall Street Journal report on why more Indians than Chinese reach top US jobs, citing language, familiarity with Western culture and willingness to move.
-
Economy
India: food, food everywhere, not a bite to eat
An article on India producing more food than it needs while children go hungry and grain rots from poor storage, with the poster joking that Amartya Sen deserves a second…
-
Politics
Heavenly abode prefers a secular icon
The poster looks at where the Congress may win seats in the South, noting Kerala and Karnataka favour it while Tamil Nadu favours the AIADMK, with polling projections.
-
Fish rots from the head
A Reuters report that Chinese authorities seized at least 90bn yuan from Zhou Yongkang’s associates, with the poster calling it a textbook case of crony capitalism.
-
Politics
Dogs barking mightily at the caravan
A report that Congress candidate Imran Masood was arrested for threatening to chop Narendra Modi into pieces, with the poster querying his claim that Uttar Pradesh is 42 per cent…
-
Monsters Inc
A report on the Taliban attack on Kabul’s Serena Hotel that killed a family including a five-year-old, with the poster asking why the Taliban are not designated terrorists.
-
Raza Rumi survives terror attack
A post on the attack on the journalist Raza Rumi, in which his driver was killed, saying the Taliban want to silence the messengers and criticising those who flatter armed…
-
Religion
Missing God…in God’s own country
On the reinstatement of Professor T. J. Joseph, whose hand was cut off by fundamentalists, the poster blames his own community’s leaders for betraying him and calls religion a poison…
-
Politics
The new un-touchables are rising
A short argument that Indian political dynasties, which held 29 per cent of seats in 2009, form a new untouchable caste of power, and that Brahmanism will outlast Brahmins because…
-
Politics
Dravidas of the world unite (no brotherly love)
A comment on the expulsion of M. K. Alagiri from the DMK and the anointing of M. K. Stalin, setting the family feud against dynastic quarrels from Aurangzeb and Dara…
-
Science
Confirmed: MH-370 lost @ sea
A note on Inmarsat’s conclusion that Malaysia Airlines MH370 ended in the southern Indian Ocean, with the poster’s view that the pilots are most likely culprits and that we may…
-
Politics
The Guardian verdict: no lotus blossoms ever
A sardonic reading of a Guardian preview of the 2014 Indian election, which the poster says dismisses AAP and regional parties and backs Congress, followed by his own seat projections…
-
Society
(un) Indian mother
A note praising an ordinary middle-class mother who encouraged her son, injured in a bike accident, to keep pursuing his dream of crossing India by motorbike, which the poster treats…
-
Varanasi- Waterloo of the East
A comment framing the Varanasi contest as the Waterloo of the East, a Congress Brahmin against a BJP Shudra favoured to win, and as the end of a slow 67-year…
-
Society
Asian Americans defeat affirmative action
A note on Asian American opposition defeating a California affirmative action push, with the poster warning that the victory may be temporary and that quotas are a powerful weapon for…
-
Politics
The United States of India
A comment on Tamil leader Vaiko’s manifesto, which would rename the country the United States of India and lift the ban on the LTTE, as a sign of regional parties’…
-
Politics
The GM invasion is underway
A note on Jayanthi Natarajan’s removal as environment minister, said to reflect industry complaints and a new leader’s wish to show friendliness to business.
-
Politics
Palaniappan Chidambaram
A comment on P. Chidambaram opting out of the Lok Sabha election and nominating his son Karti, which the poster sees as a quick fall that effectively ends his career.
-
Geopolitics
Who betrayed whom?
A note on Carlotta Gall’s book The Wrong Enemy, which claims Pakistani generals knew of Osama bin Laden’s presence, with the official Pakistani rebuttals.
-
Save rhinos, be safe from leopards
A note on rhino poaching in Assam’s Kaziranga and leopard attacks in Mumbai, with the poster rejecting deportation and de-horning and half-seriously proposing to loan baby rhinos to China.
-
The poverty picture (Africa)
A note on a WIDER study arguing sub-Saharan Africa has the world’s least responsive labour markets because too few workers have moved from farms to factories, with a nod to…
-
The Posiedon flies high (in the Andaman sky)
Satellite and radar data suggest MH370 flew on for hours towards the Andaman Islands. Notes on the 2014 search for the missing Malaysia Airlines jet.
-
Politics
Worse than Hitler !!!
A satirical note on Indian politicians’ escalating insults, from ‘worse than Hitler’ on, ranging over Stalin, Aurangzeb, Mao and the Hitler collaborator Subhas Chandra Bose.
-
Society
Thanks Whats App
A note worrying that children glued to screens are growing more aggressive and less civil, weighing bullying against the need for assertiveness, with a quoted extract.
-
Sweet as Sunny
A sardonic note on a US student’s turn to pornography and Bollywood interest in her, taking the story as a sign of the times and asking readers to sign a…
-
Politics
Comrade Prashad battles the (Gir) Lion
A note on Vijay Prashad’s appeal to secularism ahead of the 2014 vote, which the poster finds well argued but wrong to frame the choice as growth versus harmony, faulting…
-
Culture
Pakistan and India: divided by a common culture
A piece on how India and Pakistan are divided by a common culture, with the poster agreeing that ordinary people share much, though he doubts that Indian culture is rightly…
-
Economy
Sensex @ 22k
News extracts on the Sensex reaching a record 22,000 after sustained foreign buying, with the poster’s remark that the market may be signalling confidence in a stable government after the…
-
Geopolitics
Pit Bulls of the world unite (with middle class backing)
A long extract collecting the insults Western leaders have thrown at Vladimir Putin over Ukraine, introduced with the poster’s quip that Putin is a pain to liberals everywhere.
-
Made in Bangladesh
An extract on the controversy over an American Apparel ad featuring a former-Muslim Bangladeshi model, with the poster arguing that showcasing women’s liberation answers conservatives better than anything, and that…
-
She is the perfect Queen
Best wishes to Kangana Ranaut and her film Queen, with extracts of reviews praising a middle-class Himachal girl’s breakout role.
-
The (Lady) Enforcer
A profile of 27-year-old Manju Bhatia, joint MD of the all-female loan recovery agency Vasuli Recovery, with the poster’s comment that India needs more women leaders in fields seen as…
-
Culture
The bridge stretches from Pune to Potsdam
An extract on Raghunath Purushottam Paranjpye as a bridge between India and Germany, with the poster noting Germany’s long admiration of Indian culture and asking whether it had anti-Semitic undertones.
-
Society
High HDI peeps fight (fear of) extinction
A report that a Kalpetta church is paying Catholic families for a fifth child to reverse population decline amid fears of Muslim growth in Kerala, with the poster stressing that…
-
Chinese folly in Eithiopia/Kenya
A report that Ethiopia’s Gibe III dam could shrink Kenya’s Lake Turkana by up to 20 metres, with the poster warning that China, as the next imperial power, should expect…
-
Kachins against ka-ching
A report on the Kachins’ resistance to Chinese-backed Irrawaddy dams, which Burma suspended, with the poster noting fears that the projects could restart once President Thein Sein steps down.
-
Geopolitics
SAsia (mostly India) and the USA
A report on cut US aid to Pakistan, with the poster arguing that Washington needs Pakistan for a smooth exit from Afghanistan and that the curious wording of the announcement…
-
Science
Thorium reactor #1 (only by 2025)
A report that India’s Advanced Heavy Water Reactor, a thorium-fuelled design from BARC, is ready, with the poster hoping the plans are meant and worrying that Kerala’s thorium reserves are…
-
Geopolitics
Islamabad
A report on a gun and suicide bomb attack at an Islamabad court complex that killed 11, with the poster saying the ceasefire is a joke.
-
Religion
Shia/Sunni = Catholic/Protestant
A report that the Aga Khan compares the Sunni-Shia conflict to Ireland’s and urges the West to mediate, followed by the poster’s questions on Ismaili numbers, theology and notable members.
-
Society
Flat out prejudice
A story of Captain Zainul Abidin Juvale, who steered 722 Indians from Kuwait during the 1990 Iraqi invasion, with the poster urging communities to see poverty and illiteracy, not each…
-
Politics
The americans are keeping (a careful) watch
A report on a Pew survey of Indian voters, with the poster asking why Americans poll India on election eve and what it says about US readiness to align with…
-
Society
Don’t cry for me, Parsi
An older article on how the shrinking Parsi community, now under 70,000 and concentrated in Mumbai, has started a vulture programme to restore the birds on which its funerary Towers…
-
Iran’s geostrategic importance
