On “Press Freedom” and Prejudice.

This is what Norway’s leading newspaper chose for its coverage of the Indian Prime Minister’s visit to Norway.

https://x.com/_Tracer_Bullet_/status/2056737017460089173

While the usual suspects on BP chose to focus on an aspiring influencer’s stunts and dramatic heckling, I am not surprised that such blatant bigotry in the ‘mainstream’ newspaper of the supposedly Number one ranked Press has not been discussed on BP. Hilariously, a non-trivial subset of the Indian media and political opposition actually supported a rookie aspiring journalist’s publicity stunt.

Its a time-tested pattern. Rage-baiting and attacking Hindus and India earns notoriety, while the pushback and negative consequences if you push the envelope too far into nakedly racist territory, is minimal if there at all.

For all the cacophony and chaos that the Indian media landscape consistently generates, it has yet to demonstrate ability to even capitalize on such low-hanging fruit. A more capable media ecosystem wouldn’t allow such nonsense unpunished.

This is the overton window that needs to be shifted – the coverage ‘rules’ on India allow for a lot more mainstream ‘phobia’ and assault. And we see that on BP as well, the Pakistani tribal ‘patriot’ squad repeatedly find themselves facing pushback which to them is unexpected. After all, why shouldn’t they be allowed free rein in rage-baiting and plying bigoted stereotypes.

4.2 5 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

15 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Calvin
Calvin
1 day ago

This racist caricatures aside, it is not a religious group or a country being attacked.

And yes our media is bad and horrible and this is a direct result of the domestication through access and ads that has been happening for the last decade. A minstrel can only write hagiogrpahies, not make good rhetoric. Had our media done even the most basic jobs this whole situation would not be happening

Last edited 1 day ago by Calvin
AS Lakhnawi
AS Lakhnawi
1 day ago
Reply to  Calvin

Completely agree with Calvin here

Calvin
Calvin
22 hours ago

It is not all Indians, I dont agree that a picture that clearly shows one person represents all Indians.

I dont agree with argument that sound eerily similar to India= Indira and Indira=India.

They should not have represented him as a snake charme but that is about it.

Deep saran Bhatnagar
Deep saran Bhatnagar
1 day ago
Reply to  Calvin

// And yes our media is bad and horrible //

I agree but it has been like that since long time, as Naipaul noted –

Indian journalism developed no reporting tradition; it often reported on India as on a foreign country.

but i disagree with period & reason you suggest.

Calvin
Calvin
22 hours ago

I don’t think that before the last 10 years our media was taking narratives directly from social media and openly running false narratives against citizens of the country

Plus Manmohan Singh himself did close to 114 press conferences, this whole situation is because of the state of our media.

Gajamardanam
Gajamardanam
8 hours ago
Reply to  Calvin

Again, this is false. The Nirbhaya case and the India against Corruption movement were essentially “social media narratives” (albeit later hijacked by Arvind Kejriwal and the like). The party that MMS represented lost the elections three consecutive times meaning that people don’t care about press conferences as much as the self-important cohort of journalists does.

Bombay Badshah
1 day ago

Let them throw stones. We should just keep developing.

There were similar cartoons regarding the space program and ISRO has now achieved some things which no country has been able to (moon pole soft landing).

Only two things matter – GDP (for overall power) and GDP per capita (for quality of life). Everything is downstream of it.

The welcome India gets in European capitals was not there 10-15 years ago. 10-15 years later even the cartoons will disappear.

Calvin
Calvin
22 hours ago
Reply to  Bombay Badshah

Yes exactly, rather than getting triggered over this and doing usual IT cell shenanigans or thst press conference, one should have just ignored this in the first place.

S Qureishi
S Qureishi
1 day ago

Why is it so offensive being shown as a snake charmer? Isn’t that part of Indian culture, something that does not exist outside South Asia? If someone showed Pakistanis as snake charmers for charming all the westerners, we would not be offended at all. It’s not bigotry if its true.

The second point about Satan worshipping Hindus is what I alluded to in earlier posts. Westerners, especially Northern Euros and Americans are innately repelled by idol worship and Hinduism to them is seen as Satanic. Even the most liberal ones think this unconsiously.

S Qureishi
S Qureishi
1 day ago

Guess what: the two are independent of each other.

Own your peculiarities rather than lash out about it.

Calvin
Calvin
22 hours ago
Reply to  S Qureishi

Westerners of today seem more repulsed by christianity or Islam tbh

Hinduism when it does get talked about is talked about positively, and whatever repulsion that there maybe is because of the lack of proof not the belief and practise itself

Many Indians dont like the representation of snake charmers because it represents something archaic, not modern. Many Westerners outside of those interested in India still are using 18th-19th century framing on Hinduism like on other religions as well.

X.T.M
Admin
21 hours ago

this is disgraceful and racist..

Brown Pundits
15
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x