A revolution is announced (Aug 14)

Charu Majumdar and Kanu Sanyal dreamed of the perfect world where there is no exploitation. However there were a few barriers on the road- the rich (Marwaris in Kolkata), the landed class (feudals in rural Bengal), the petit-burgeouis (aka bhodrolok middle and lower-middle class conservative Hindus), the powerful (politicians) and the people who protected the powerful (police, army). Charu, the ideologue-in-chief wanted to get rid of most (and re-educate the rest in gulags). His inspiration was Mao Tse-Tung, and his slogan was “Chin-er Chairman amader Chairman” (Mao is our Chairman too).

We are not here to argue the rights and wrongs of the Naxalite movement. India for the moment is calm (even though Maoists are active in Central-East India and manage to blow up a train track now and then), under the watchful eye of the Hindu Brotherhood. The agitation against corruption and the rest was led by the Aam Admi Party which then frittered away the love that the voters had bestowed on them. Regardless of win and loss the consensus amongst all communities is firmly on incremental progress (even in Kashmir). The best example is seen in the blood-less partition of Hindu-majority Andhra and Telengana, even though the stakes were just as high as in Hindu-Muslim partitions. If one wants to establish forced analogies, then Telengana is the new Pakistan.

How about the original Pakistan then? We are puzzled by the silence of experts on BP on the upcoming azadi march – perhaps their attentions are engaged elsewhere (Gaza??) or they are not taking this seriously enough. 

Noted below is a comprehensive background report. If one wants to establish forced analogies, then Khan-Qadri are the Charu-Kanu of  this generation (Qadri has specifically called for a revolution). They too dream of a heaven on earth to be brought to Pakistan (corruption to be erased in 90 days) and yes, they may not be averse to adopting violence to achieve their goals.
…..
As an outsider our observation is that Imran Khan is the leader today with the strongest “brand value.” People (middle-class) truly believe in his promises of creating a welfare state. About Tahirul Qadri we are not sure, even though wise men tell us that he is a “moderate.”

Somehow we see the hidden hand of the Army behind these events. Or perhaps we are just being cynical and this is really something big and new. Lal Salaam, comrades!!!
…………
 
The battle lines are more or less defined now with the approach of
Aug 14. Unsurprisingly, Tahirul Qadri has joined hands with Imran Khan
for the ‘azadi march’. His fanatically motivated supporters, drawn
mainly from the lower middle classes across the Punjab heartland, may
add spine to Imran Khan’s middle-class youth brigade with no experience
of street agitation.

….
Besides, Qadri has set a more strident tenor
for D-Day. Now there is no going back on the ‘revolution’, he has
warned his allies. It is certainly the politics of expediency that has
brought together Qadri and Khan on the same platform. But the radical
rhetoric of the Canada-based cleric and his incitement to violence could
turn him into a liability for the PTI and prove to be the undoing of
the ‘azadi march’ even before it has taken off. Nevertheless the new
coalition will shape the emerging political polarisation in the country.

….
Most other political parties are sitting on the fringes weighing
their options as the confrontation comes to a head. What happens on Aug
14 is most likely to determine their future course of action. But more
importantly, what are the choices for the beleaguered prime minister in
this hour of reckoning?


Will he sail through the storm or be swept away by the tide? Having
already lost the initiative in the battle of narratives, Nawaz Sharif
faces a tough fight ahead to survive in power against strong odds. It is
more than just a political battle; the government’s unresolved tension
with the generals over Musharraf’s treason trial and a host of other
issues will also matter in the endgame.

….
Having been thrown out of
power halfway through his tenure twice, one expected Sharif to exercise
discretion while tackling the mounting political tension. However, the
dynamics of the present crisis are quite different from the past. Unlike
his previous terms, when the power struggle at the top echelon cost him
his government, Sharif is confronting a street show of force
challenging the very legitimacy of his rule for the first time.

….
Surely,
the threat is compounded by the conflict within the power structure.
Sharif’s uninspiring and absent leadership does not help his cause for
mobilising mass support for the impending battle. The concentration of
power within a small family circle has exposed the weak ability of the
government to motivate party cadres to stand up to the challenge

….
Yet
there is no sign the prime minister realises the gravity of the
situation. He still wonders where he has gone wrong. His speech on
Monday at the launching of Vision 2025 had a defensive tone with no
clarity on how he is going to fight the battle. He still seems to be in a
state of denial about the gathering storm. His implicit inference to
the military being the author of the script will surely further sour
already tense civil-military relations at this crucial stage.

….
The
Punjab government’s perilous handling of the Qadri issue — first the
killing of 14 Minhajul Quran activists in June and then the recent
blocking of the roads by containers — has cost the administration
dearly. The spectacle of men and women crawling under the containers to
reach their destinations in Lahore could not be more politically
damaging for the Sharif brothers. The container strategy has failed to
work and any move to detain Imran Khan and other leaders ahead of the
Aug 14 sit-in will surely boomerang on the administration, fuelling
uncontrollable violence across Punjab and perhaps giving more dead
bodies for Qadri to exploit.

….
It would have been more sensible had
the government permitted the PTI’s march in the first place. In that
case, the onus of maintaining peace would squarely be on the opposition.
Now Qadri’s joining the march has changed the matrix and any show of
flexibility by the government would be taken as a sign of weakness. The
space for Sharif regaining the initiative is fast shrinking.

…..
Yet
it is not the end of the road for the Sharif government. There are still
a few options left for the troubled prime minister to regain the lost
political space. His biggest political capital is the party’s absolute
majority in the National Assembly that he has yet to put into action. A
major problem for Sharif is his utter disregard for parliament. His rare
appearances in the House and inability to initiate debate on major
policy issues has rendered parliament ineffective and increased his
isolation.

….
It took a long time for Sharif to embrace the other
major parties represented in parliament and that too came when the chips
were down. Inviting political leaders to the national security meeting
to discuss the North Waziristan military operation may be a positive
move.

….
But mixing the discussion on security issues with politics
in the presence of the military brass raises some relevant questions
about the actual purpose of bringing together the civilian and military
leadership. The image of a line of army generals in their battle
fatigues sitting across the table from the political leaders was
presumably meant to send a signal to the public of the military’s
backing for the government.

…..
What was the idea behind the decision
to telecast live the prime minister’s opening remarks concerning the
political crisis in what was supposed to be an in-camera security
briefing? This kind of game is counterproductive. The government is
expected to take a saner approach in such a situation.

….
Sharif may
be down, but he is not out of the game yet. It is neither a 1993 nor a
1999 situation when he lost the power struggle. But the wrong moves
could land him into the same situation. It is not just the issue of
facing up to the challenge thrown by the Qadri-Imran combine, Sharif
also needs to address other problems concerning governance and the
economy to ensure his survival in power and avert the derailing of a
fledgling democratic process.

……

Link: http://www.dawn.com/running-out-of-options
…..

regards

The Cadillac Man

…..A woman would never make a nuclear bomb…..They
would never make a weapon that kills, no, no….They’d make a weapon that
makes you feel bad for a while…..

…..
Robin Williams just committed suicide (August 11). He was brilliant in many movies (Good Will Hunting) and funny in others (Good Morning Vietnam), in Dead Poets’ Society he was funny and brilliant at the same time. A funny man with a not-so-funny personal life and a sad way to end it all at a ripe young age of 63.

In our opinion, comedy is a harsh look at life, softened by the humor. Williams was unsparing on everything holy, he would say that (his denomination) the Episcopal Church as “Catholic Lite—same rituals, half the guilt.” The holy cows will now be missing the dissing.
…..

…..
Here is Williams on Gandhi and Mother Teresa. Not perhaps appropriate for people who worship the (wo)man, not the actions (or ideas). Incidentally, the one thing that does irritate us is how many westerners mis-spell the name as Ghandi.

The movie that is closest to our heart (and one we suspect very few people will know or recall) is the Cadillac Man. Williams is at his persuasive best (indeed the plot looks a bit like his personal life) with the women AND the men. Unintellectual, shallow perhaps….but deeply entertaining. The best part in the movie is when he (Williams) realizes that the gun carried by the maniac (Tim Robbins) is not loaded, he has been wasting his time and energy all this time. That is when a switch clicks ON in his brain and he grows up from a man-boy to a man.
…..
[ref. Wiki] Dead Poets Society won the Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay (Tom Schulman). Peter Weir received a nomination for Best Director and the film itself was nominated for Best Picture of 1989. Robin Williams
received his second Best Actor in a Leading Role nomination and it has
since been widely recognized as one of the actor/comedian’s best roles.

It also won the BAFTA Award for Best Film.
The film’s line “Carpe diem. Seize the day, boys. Make your lives extraordinary.” was voted as the 95th greatest movie quote by the American Film Institute. Also, the film was voted one of the 100 Most Inspiring Films of All Time by the AFI.
……. 

[ref. Wiki] Queens car salesman Joey O’Brien (Robin Williams) must deal with the ever-increasing pressures in his life: he has an ex-wife demanding alimony, a daughter who’s missing, a married mistress (Fran Drescher) and a single mistress (Lori Petty)
who are both desperately in love with him, and a two-day deadline to
either sell twelve cars or lose his job. In addition, he has an
outstanding loan to a Mafia don which he must either quickly repay, or lose his life.



….
On the day of the big dealership car sale (and the final day of O’Brien’s deadline), the car dealership is taken hostage by an AK-47-toting motorcyclist (Tim Robbins) (on a Kawasaki H2) who believes his wife (Annabella Sciorra) is cheating on him. Joey manages to talk the man out of doing any harm to the other hostages,
as police surround the dealership. 


Without realizing that the
assailant’s gun is not loaded, the police wound him after most of the
hostages have already been released which prompts Joey to promise to
stick with him while he recovers. The crisis solves all of Joey’s
problems: his mistresses learn of each other and dump him, his daughter
returns, his job is secure, the Mafia don (whose son was among the
hostages) forgives his debt, and he begins to reconcile with his
ex-wife.


regards 

Mount Sinjar overlooks the Valley of Death

……Yazidi refugees survived by hiding in cave dwellings,
drinking from springs, hunting animals…..families
scattered across Mount Sinjar, a barren range stretching 35 miles
near the border with Syria….there are fears aid will not reach them all
……One pershmerga fighter said: “There’s
not enough for everyone….It’s five people to one bottle
”…..

There seems to be no hope left for the Yazidis dying in droves from thirst (and pain). Just like that, a community will vanish from the face of the Earth, while the world watches (mostly) in silence.

 

………….


Mount Sinjar stinks of death. The few Yazidis who have managed to escape its
clutches can tell you why. “Dogs were eating the bodies of the dead,” said
Haji Khedev Haydev, 65, who ran through the lines of Islamic State jihadists
surrounding it.
………
On Sunday night, I became the first western journalist to reach the mountains
where tens of thousands of Yazidis,
a previously obscure Middle Eastern sect, have been taking refuge from the
Islamic State forces that seized their largest town, Sinjar.

I was on board an Iraqi Army helicopter, and watched as hundreds of refugees
ran towards it to receive one of the few deliveries of aid to make it to the
mountain. The helicopter dropped water and food from its open gun bays to
them as they waited below. General Ahmed Ithwany, who led the mission, told
me: “It is death valley. Up to 70 per cent of them are dead.”

Two American aid flights have also made it to the mountain, where they have
dropped off more than 36,000 meals and 7,000 gallons of drinking water to
help the refugees, and last night two RAF C-130 transport planes were also
on the way.

However, Iraqi officials said that much of the US aid had been “useless”
because it was dropped from 15,000ft without parachutes and exploded on
impact.

Handfuls of refugees have managed to escape on the helicopters but many are
being left behind because the craft are unable to land on the rocky
mountainside. There, they face thirst and starvation, as well as the
crippling heat of midsummer.



Hundreds, if not more, have already died, including scores of children. A
Yazidi Iraqi MP, Vian Dakhil, told reporters in Baghdad:
“We have one or two days left to help these people. After that they will
start dying en masse.”



The Iraqi Army is running several aid missions every day, bringing supplies
including water, flour, bread and shoes.
The helicopter flights aim to airlift out refugees on each flight, but the
mountains are sometimes too rocky to land on, meaning they return empty.



Even when it can land, the single helicopter can take just over a dozen
refugees at a time, and then only from the highest point of the mountain
where it is out of range of jihadist missiles. Barely 100 have been rescued
in this way.



 



The flights have also dropped off at least 50 armed Peshmerga, Kurdish forces,
on the mountain, according to Captain Ahmed Jabar.



Other refugees have made their way through Islamic State lines, evading the
jihadists to reach safety, or travelling through Kurdish-controlled sections of Syria to reach the town of Dohuk. 

So far the
Yazidi refugees left behind have survived by hiding in old cave dwellings,
drinking from natural springs and hunting small animals, but with families
scattered across Mount Sinjar, a barren range stretching for around 35 miles
near the border with Syria, there are fears aid will not reach them all
unless the humanitarian relief operation is significantly stepped up .

Hundreds can now be seen making their way slowly across its expanse, carrying
what few possessions they managed to flee with on their backs. Exhausted
children lie listlessly in the arms of their parents, older ones trudging
disconsolately alongside while the sun beats down overhead.




The small amount of relief the peshmerga militia can bring up into the
mountain is not simply enough.



One pershmerga fighter, Faisal Elas Hasso, 40, said: “To be honest, there’s
not enough for everyone,” he said. “It’s five people to one bottle.”



….
The refugees who made it out described desperate scenes as they awaited help
from the outside world.
“There were about 200 of us, and about 20 of that number have died,” said
Saydo Haji, 28. “We can live for two days, not more.”




Emad Edo, 27, who was rescued in an airlift on Friday at the mountain’s
highest point explains how he had to leave his niece, who barely had enough
strength to keep her eyes open, to her fate.
“She was about to die, so we left her there and she died,” he said.



….
Others shared similar stories. “Even the caves smell very bad,” Mr Edo added.
According to several of the airlifted refugees, the Geliaji cave alone has
become home to 50 dead bodies.
Saydo Kuti Naner, 35, who was one of 13 Yazidis who snuck through Islamic
State lines on Thursday morning, said he travelled through
Kurdish-controlled Syria to get to Kurdistan.



….

He left behind his mother and father, too old to make the rough trip, as well
as 200 sheep. “We got lucky,” he said. “A girl was running [with us] and she
got shot.” He added that this gave enough cover for the rest of them to get
away.



….
Mikey Hassan said he, his two brothers and their families fled up into Mount
Sinjar and then managed to escape to the Kurdish city of Dohuk after two
days, by shooting their way past the jihadists. Mr Hassan said he and his
family went for 17 hours with no food before getting their hands on some
bread.



….
The Yazidis, an ethnically Kurdish community that has kept its religion alive
for centuries in the face of persecution, are at particular threat from the
Islamists, who regard them as ‘devil worshippers’, and drove them from their
homes as the peshmerga fighters withdrew.



….
There have been repeated stories that the jihadists have seized hundreds of
Yazidi women and are holding them in Mosul, either in schools or the prison.
These cannot be confirmed, though they are widely believed and several
Yazidi refugees said they had been unable to contact Yazidi women relatives
who were living behind Islamic State lines.



…..
Kamil Amin, of the Iraqi human rights ministry, said: “We think that the
terrorists by now consider them slaves and they have vicious plans for them.”



….
Tens of thousands of Christians have also been forced to flee in the face of
the advancing IS fighters, many cramming the roads east and north to Erbil
and Dohuk. On Thursday alone, up to 100,000 Iraqi Christians fled their
homes in the Plain of Ninevah around Mosul.



….
Refugees said the American air strikes on IS positions outside Erbil were too
little, too late. They said they felt abandoned by everyone – the central
government in Baghdad, the Americans and British, who invaded in 2003, and
now the Kurds, who had promised to protect them.



….
“When the Americans withdrew from Iraq they didn’t protect the Christians,”
said Jenan Yousef, an Assyrian Catholic who fled Qaraqosh, Iraq’s largest
Christian town, in the early hours of Thursday. “The Christians became the scapegoats. Everyone has been killing us.”

The situation in Sinjar has irreparably damaged the notion of home for the
Yazidis. For a large portion of them, the unique culture of the area will
never return, and they will therefore have nothing to go back for.



….
“We can’t go back to Sinjar mountain because Sinjar is surrounded by Arabs,”
said Aydo Khudida Qasim, 34, who said that Sunni Arab villagers around
Sinjar helped Islamic State take the area. Now he as well as many of his
friends and relatives want to get out of Iraq altogether. “We want to be refugees in other countries, not our own,” he said
.

….

Link: http://Iraq-crisis-It-is-death-valley.-Up-to-70-per-cent-of-them-are-dead.html

….

regards

Third World Invasion of Canada (by Sikhs)

We all know that Canada is welcoming of immigrants, but something like this is still a matter of concern. …

Sikhs are noted as a prosperous community in India (and in the West) but they are facing considerable violence, recently three Sikhs died in Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh, India and one in Peshawar, Khyber Pakhtunwa, Pakistan. Six members of a Sikh congregation were killed and four injured two years ago (August 05, 2012) in an attack on a Gurudwara in Oak Creek, Wisconsin. One Sikh veteran (Gulf War) was killed by the police in Lodi, California in January, 2014. Sikhs (two) were also killed in Sacramento in 2011.
 …………

 ….
It is clear that being a model minority will not save Sikhs, especially when native (white) populations are feeling threatened everywhere by the changing face (more and more browns, blacks) of their communities, in the Americas and in Europe.

……

 …….
It is also interesting to speculate on how much animosity is directed against Sikhs because they are being confused with Muslims. Indeed, Sikhs in USA and UK have from time to time campaigned on the theme of Sikhs are not Muslims!!! Needless to say, brown-on-brown ill-feeling has been brought over from the old country. When the time comes, it is wise to remember, the crocodile will be unsparing.
…….
Police are investigating a racist anti-immigration flyer recently distributed in Brampton. “Peel Regional Police have become aware of the most recent flyer that
is now in circulation in our region depicting insensitive and racially
intolerant messaging,” a police release put out Saturday stated.
Cops don’t know who the creator of the flyer is, Const. George Tudos said. “Obviously we’re going to look at all avenues,” he said.


According to a statement by the Canadian Race Relations Foundation,
the flyer in question singles out the Sikh community that resides in
Brampton.
“By crossing out the image of a Sikh individual while raising the
fear of a ‘massive third-world invasion of Canada’ and claiming that
‘white Canadians’ were being reduced to a ‘minority’, the creators of
the flyers have crossed the line from dialogue into outright racism,”
the CRRF statement said.


….
This is not the first time an anti-immigration flyer has been spotted in Brampton.

In April this year, a group called Immigration Watch Canada
distributed pamphlets showing a picture of white people and a picture of
Sikhs, with numbers indicating immigration population growth as well as
a caption: “Is this what you really want?”


….
IWC spokesman Dan Murray said Saturday the group “did not authorize the distribution of the flyer in Brampton.” Tudos said police still plan to speak with IWC andthe author of the latest flyer is still unknown.

….
Once the investigation is complete, “investigators will be consulting
with the Ministry of the Attorney General to seek the authorization, if
applicable, to lay hate-crime-related charges,” Peel police said in
their statement.


….
Brampton NDP MPP Jagmeet Singh criticized the flyer in a tweet on
Thursday: “Brampton, let’s reject this racist flyer’s message of hate
& instead stand united for diversity & acceptance of all.”


A Rally Against Racism – organized by a group called Brampton United
Against Racism and attended by Singh – was held on Friday outside
Brampton City Hall in response to the flyer. 

….

Link (1): http://www.torontosun.com/police-probe-racist-flyers-in-brampton

Link (2): http://antiimmigration_flyers_single_out_sikh_community_in_brampton.html
….

regards

Kashmir “not ours” (re-draw the lines)

…..Kashmir and Telangana…..annexed to the Indian union….After 1947, we became a part of India…Then
the troubles really started…..We need to
come out clean on Kashmir….Few parts were not ours….we should redraw the lines and move on……Development is suffering…. frequent bombings….R2.50 lakh crore allotted to defence…..If we have a peaceful environment we can spend money on education, women’s development or sanitation……


To be duly noted that K Kavitha is (i) Hindu, (ii) a Member of the Parliament (Lok Sabha, Nizam-abad constituency from Telengana district, member of Telengana Rashtra Samithi party, daughter of TRS founder K Chandrashekar Rao), and (iii) a woman.  

Kavitha is also – as a strong, independent woman should be- standing up for her sisters and for the Uniform Civil Code!!! Eat your heart out, Arundhati Roy.
……
Let us try and unpack the statement (for transcript excerpts, see below) and the history behind it. Telengana (Muslim ruler, significant Muslim population) and Kashmir (Hindu ruler, majority Muslim population) wished to remain independent post-1947 (Jodhpur, Bhopal and Travancore had similar ambitions). The powerful combination of Patel, Menon and Mountbatten persuaded most royals to join India, in exchange for payment of an annuity (the “privy purse”). This privilege was abolished by Indira Gandhi (arguing for a socialist state) through a constitutional amendment in 1971.
……
There were also a number of irregularities as to how parts of Bengal and Punjab were awarded to India or to Pakistan. In the Sylhet district (then East Pakistan, now Bangladesh) Hindus lost in a close vote. It is alleged (by Hindu Bengalis) that this process was aided by Asomiya (Hindu) leaders who were worried that Sylhet as part of India would lead to Bengali domination in the North-East.OTOH Gurdaspur district (East Punjab) was awarded to India (allegedly because of romantic link between Nehru and Edwina Mountbatten). Similarly it was possible that Lahore would be go to India while Calcutta would be go to Pakistan.

Any Indian law-maker who says today that some territory should be an independent nation is liable to face sedition charges. This
is because Kavitha (unlike Roy) has sworn by  the Indian constitution
to protect the nation. It will be interesting to see what the courts
make of her statements.

However on free speech grounds
it is simply remarkable that in today’s climate (if left-liberals are to
be believed), one can even think of making such statements. Indeed she
should have pointed out that Goa, Sikkim, and Junagadh were also
annexations, albeit with varying levels of coercion.

Where Kavitha (in our opinion) goes off-track is the claim that all “troubles” started after 1947- meaning oppression of Telengana people by Andhra people. People may conclude from this that she is making a pro-royalist argument in the form of either the British (de-facto), or the Dogras (Kashmir) and Nizam (Hyderabad). Actually we suspect it is something far more sinister.

If the plea is for devolution of power to the lowest level of administration, we would agree in full measure. Panchayati Raj (village rule) was what Gandhi had wanted. Instead what we have are 29 powerful states with a lot of inequalities at the district (and lower) level.

What she really means is that in a state where her dad is the (genuine) people’s hero, she can’t wait to be king. Just like Odisha where Naveen (Patnaik) Babu has benefited from the legacy of Bjiu Babu. Also see Punjab (Badal) and Tamil Nadu (Karunanidhi). The paid goondas of her party would be merrily going around extorting money from Andhra business-people (just like Kashmiri muslims are pelting stones at Pandits who plan to visit temples). This is why Hyderabad should have been declared an Union Territory but then Congress was busy playing (desperate) vote games. 

If the proposed BJP plan to forcibly settle Pandits in Kashmir goes through (we are not in favor, many many more killings aka “sacrifice” on both sides) it will only work if they are settled in Union territories (feel free to draw Palestine analogies).  True peace will not come to Kashmir unless Pakistan Army co-operates and that is unlikely to say the least.

Finally one thing that did bother us…a lot. Kavitha mentioned the defense spend and we agree that we should spend much less on defense and more on social justice. But then she talked about “frequent bombings” as a justification for (unilateral) surrender. It is our opinion that extremists will always find a reason to bomb us, Kashmir or no Kashmir. The same bunch of jihadis are responsible for “frequent bombings” in Pakistan, destroying shrines and killing fellow muslims (forget for the moment, the atrocities against non-muslims). There are very good reasons why we should settle the Kashmir problem but violence is not the answer and violence will be met with more violence (as has been indeed the case).
…………….

K Kavitha, Anupriya Patel and Pratap Simha, first-time MPs of
TRS, Apna Dal and BJP respectively, talk about the hurdles they face in
Parliament and their views on J&K and Article 370. This Idea
Exchange was moderated by Senior Editor D K Singh



K KAVITHA: I am a Masters in Computer Science and I
was part of the Telangana movement for seven years. I run an NGO called
Telangana Jagruthi, and we have tried to revive ethnic festivals that
are getting lost in these Valentine’s Day, Mother’s Day etc
 

After the
formation of the Telangana state, our TRS party formed the government.
Then I won the (Lok Sabha) election from Nizamabad. My area of interest,
other than representing the aspirations of the people of Telangana, is
the Jammu and Kashmir issue. I hope that this government, which has a
massive majority, will take serious decisions and implement them.


….
ANUPRIYA PATEL: My journey is not very old in
politics. I joined politics after my father’s demise in 2010, and 2012
was the first election of my life. I spent two years as an MLA and now I
am an MP from Mirzapur, UP. One of my prime concerns is uplifting the
living conditions of tribals in Mirzapur. 

There are other issues — the
poor standard of education and medical facilities — which I will try to
bring to the notice of the government. I’m one of the allies of the BJP,
a very small ally with only two members in the House. So I have my
party issues as well. My party is working for the backwards, tribals and
Scheduled Castes. I feel the government is not giving attention to this
aspect. I have tried to speak to the Prime Minister on these issues,
that a major section of the OBCs and the SC/STs turned in your favour.
They quit the SP, BSP, and turned to you because they found that you’re a
man of hope.


….
Coming to Parliament is a great experience because now you know what a
big responsibility it is and how the House works, the rules,
techniques, devices. It’s an enriching experience and, as a young MP,
exciting also. You become anxious because you don’t know lots of things
and at the same time you feel good too because it’s such a big platform,
the entire nation is watching you and you can learn  and contribute so
much.


….
PRATAP SIMHA: I represent Mysore-Kodagu constituency in Karnataka.
I’m a Kannada journalist. My column is called Bettale Prapancha, which
means ‘naked world’, it bares facts. I write on contemporary issues,
sports, politics — anything, except science and technology. 

When the
general elections were announced, the state and central BJP were looking
for an image makeover, so they looked for achievers from other fields.
Two or three names were announced, and one was mine. I’m also the
biographer of the first unofficial biography of Narendra Modiji. I
published it in 2008 and it was released by Arun Jaitley. It got
translated into Gujarati and Marathi. That is how I came in contact with
Modiji. 

My constituency comprises two districts, Mysore and Coorg. In
one part of my constituency, they grow world-class tobacco, a majority
is exported. Coorg is the hometown of coffee breweries. Mysore has eight
engineering colleges, but only one major software firm. We need to
provide jobs to graduates. Also, the road connectivity between Mysore
and Bangalore is quite bad.


…..
D K SINGH: Being the son/daughter of a politician is an
advantage. But do you think it also becomes a baggage because people
have huge expectations from you and even if you do something great, it’s
attributed to your parents?


K KAVITHA: It’s an advantage because whatever
positive things come from my father (K Chandrasekhar Rao) are attributed
to me. At the same time, I’m compared to him. He’s a very good orator.
So whenever I pick up a mike, everybody, especially in Telangana, looks
at me with expectation. 

The fear of failing is horrible and takes a toll
on your own creativity. To come out of that shadow is very difficult.
On a lighter note, people who cannot reach my father to either vent out
their anger or appreciate him come to me. Somebody who’s really upset
with my father will say, ‘Arre, his daughter is not good’. Politically,
it’s an advantage because we already have our own agenda, set map,
ideology. We practically grew up in a political atmosphere. I’ve seen
people flocking around my father from my childhood. So I understand the
dynamics of the system.


…..
ANUPRIYA PATEL: I don’t fall in Kavita’s or Pratap’s
category. Although my father (Sone Lal Patel) started the Apna Dal, the
party didn’t achieve success. He was not an MLA or MP. He left me with
the legacy of some votes which never converted into a powerful position.
So I see myself as a beginner. There’s nobody in my party to guide me.
But people perceive that Anupriya comes from a political background, so
she knows all.


…..
Pratap Simha: Having a political background
certainly helps you on the way. If my father was a politician or had
money, I would’ve gone to St Stephen’s or another good college. My
English would have been better. I would have learned other languages,
and studied in foreign colleges. 

Whenever I enter the premises of
Parliament, there are a lot of photographers. No one takes our
photographs. When Jyotiraditya Scindia comes in, some daughters and sons
of great politicians, they’ll rush towards them, they’ll take their
photographs. If I have to raise my voice in Parliament, I have to
struggle to ask questions, or struggle during the zero hour. If there’s a
quota in every job sector, in Parliament also, we should be allotted
some time. Those who come up on their own should be allowed to speak.


……
Manoj C G: Kavitha, you said you feel strongly about Jammu
and Kashmir. As young MPs, how do you feel about issues like Article 370
and the uniform civil code which are on the BJP’s agenda?


K Kavitha: Jammu and Kashmir and Telangana were both
forcefully and at the same time annexed to the Indian Union. When I say
I feel strongly, it’s because we were both separate countries, but were
merged with the Indian Union after Independence. 

In 1947, we were not a
part of India.  After 1947, we became a part of India. Then the
troubles really started. None of our people was very rich before. So
it’s from the people’s perspective that I’ve started reading about Jammu
and Kashmir. We need to solve issues, particularly the Kashmiri
Pandits’ issue which is put up in the agenda of the BJP. They say we can
all take them back home, but it is just a political statement. You have
to create a safe environment before you take them there. 

We need to
come out clean on Jammu and Kashmir. Few parts were not ours, we should
agree, we should redraw the international lines, and move on.
Development is suffering and you see frequent bombings.



 
Our economy takes a toll. Even in the Budget, almost Rs 2.50 lakh
crore has been allotted to defence.  If we have a peaceful environment
in our bordering states, we don’t have to spend so much on defence. We
can spend that money on education, women’s development or sanitation.
Today, if I talk about no bathrooms in girls’ schools, I should be
ashamed of being a citizen of this country.


…..
MANOJ C G: What about uniform civil code?
K Kavitha: A lot of Muslim organisations are opposing
it, but I am for uniform civil code. We cannot control anybody’s
religion, but when it comes to law and order, to controlling the
internal security issues, a citizen is a citizen and should be dealt
with that way. So certain clauses need to be included in the uniform
civil code, some could be debated about. Only the marriage clause could
be excluded and dealt with separately.


…..
ANUPRIYA PATEL: To me, this idea is very strange
that we are a nation and we have a separate system in a state that falls
within the boundary of the Indian Union. However, I totally agree where
Article 370 is concerned. I heard the honourable PM say that, ‘Why
can’t we talk about it? Why can’t we discuss it?’. I feel that there
should be debate over Article 370, its existence and its relevance.


….
PRATAP SIMHA: As far as the uniform civil code is
concerned, the BJP has a stated stand on this, I don’t want to talk more
on this issue, and Modiji has called for a debate on Article 370. Has
Article 370 achieved what it intended to? If a Kashmiri woman marries
someone not from J&K, her children will not have the right to her
property. We need to raise our voice against this kind of
discrimination. There are no industries in Jammu and Kashmir because
they will not allow the industries to flourish there. And in 2009,
during the Amarnath Yatra, the pilgrims were not allowed to have a
permanent structure there.


…..
K KAVITHA: On the issue of not owning land or
property, Kashmir and Telangana have similar laws. We also had a
condition, a council, which said that no outsider could hold land in
Telangana. 

But when N T Rama Rao came to power and scrapped the council,
he violated the Constitution, nobody was there to hear our voice, it’s
all gone. But Kashmir still has that law and council, so natives have
that protection. 

But when you want to completely remove it, we have to
seriously think of the capacity of the natives regarding the issue. The
same thing we had in Telangana, but once it was removed, we suffered
very, very seriously. So when we are talking about the property rights
of Kashmiris, the opinion of the natives should be sought.


……

Link: http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/no-one-guides-us-in-parliament/99/

….

regards

Raksha-bandhan (for tots and trees)

….credit for Taru
Bandhan
festival goes to Mahadev Mahato from Dudhmatia village……Mahato has helped restore 25,000 acres of
forestland…..“for natives of Jharkhand, forest is a part of life…why not include trees as part of our family and rituals”…. 

 


Of the many traditions that cut across communities in India, Raksha-bandhan or Rakhi is probably the most popular and one with the longest historical record (unfortunately that does not protect such traditions in Pakistan…for example).  There is the story of (Rajput Queen) Karnavati sending a rakhi to (Mughal Emperor) Humayun seeking protection against Bahadur Shah (Muslim ruler of Gujarat). The rakhi legends extend even further back to Alexander the Great (see below).

….

 ….
As part of an unique movement for conservation in the eastern, tribal
dominated state of Jharkhand, even the trees get a rakhi (see below).
If it works, it has our blessings. 

…..

….
Are girls (especially didi-s or elder sisters, even little girls of those sisters) born to be matriarchs? It may be a stereotype, but it certainly holds true in our extended family. Many a time we restore
our oppressed spirits by mumbling “hitler” sotto voce, but if the lady
is perceptive, she will come back with a ki bolle? (what did you say?).

…..

 ….
Regardless, sisters are very precious and getting a band from a
sister is a privilege. Sad to say, these traditions are dying out, however, we
did update the practice so that in our home brothers tie a band on the
sisters as well. Wishing all the brothers and sisters out there all the best. Everyone have lots of fun and stay safe.
 
….

The Taru Bandhan ritual being
practised in the tribal heartland of Jharkhand has helped restore and conserve
hundreds of acres of forestland in the state

The tribal heartland of Jharkhand in
eastern India has evolved a unique tradition of forest conservation — tying
rakhis to trees. Rakhi is an Indian festival for siblings where the sister ties
an auspicious thread of love on her brother’s wrist, amidst great revelry and
feasting. The latter, in turn, promises her protection throughout his life.

….
Jharkhand’s indigenous people
harbour such strong feelings towards the forests and trees that villagers tie
the same auspicious rakhi thread around the trunks of trees. The ritual, called
Taru Bandhan or Vriksh Raksha Bandhan, is aimed at preserving trees from the axe
and the saw. In return, the forest offers people a sustainable way of life.

….
Hundreds of villages in Jharkhand
practise this unique ritual on the eve of the state’s foundation day fortnight,
starting November 15. And, thanks to the villagers’ enthusiasm, the
celebrations continue right up to the New Year.

….
In the tradition of the Rakhi
festival, this ritual too starts on an elaborate note as the women of the
village, dressed in their colourful best, gather in the forest. A bedi
(altar) is erected on an elevated patch of land, at the forest entrance. It is
decked with flowers and embellished with motifs created out of coloured rice
paste and other grains. It is here that the Van Devi (Goddess of the Forest) is
invoked with offerings of fruit, incense sticks and holy threads that are later
wound around the trees.

“For them (the villagers) the event
is also an occasion to celebrate and rejoice,” says Amarnath Bhagat, Ranger,
Hazaribagh. Amidst the sounding of the nagara, dhol and mandar
(tribal musical instruments), vermillion is applied on the trunk of the tree. A
garland of hibiscus or marigold is suspended from the tree and an aarti
(ceremony done with incense sticks and earthen lamps)performed in much the same
way as that which takes place during the Rakhi festival.

The festival is incomplete without
children who take part in large numbers, not only for the continuance of the
tradition but also to spread awareness. They enact small plays at the venue,
and design posters and banners that are displayed at the site.

….
The ritual is most commonly
practised on a sal or sakhua tree (Shorea robusta) or the mahua (Madhuca
latifolia), karaunj (Pongamia pinnata), kathal (Hallocarpus
indicus), neem (Azadiracta indica), etc. “Sal is regarded as
the ‘king of the forest’. It greatly promotes conservation and proliferation of
various types of plant species, thereby improving biodiversity and conservation
of nature,” says Kanhai Mahato from Tuktuko village, Bagodar block in Giridih.
“Our village forest management and protection committee has restored 800 acres
of forestland,” he adds with pride.

….
The villagers choose a patch in the
forest where the rakhis will be tied to trees. “Once a tree is ‘ritualised’ we
do not pluck even a leaf from it,” says Anju Devi from Mangro village,
Vishugarh block, Hazaribagh.

….
The credit for initiating the Taru
Bandhan festival, nearly a decade ago, goes to a local villager by the name of
Mahadev Mahato from Dudhmatia village in Jharkhand’s Hazaribagh district. A
schoolteacher by profession, Mahato has helped restore nearly 25,000 acres of
forestland. “For the natives of Jharkhand, the forest is an inseparable part of
their life; why not include trees as part of our family and rituals,” he asks. 
Mahato expresses satisfaction that his passion has not only spread to his
fellow villagers but also to the forest department that has acknowledged his
efforts. Palamau, Dhanbad, Chatra, Koderma and Hazaribagh are some of the
districts that have taken the initiative in propagating this unique “green
tradition”.

….
Chief Conservator of Forests B R
Rallan, from Hazaribagh where the practice is most common, says: “The concept
is basically the brainchild of Mahato, which we are carrying forward in other
districts too.” It has proved very effective in bringing about villagers’
participation in forest conservation, which forms the basis of joint forestry
management.


…..

Raksha Bandhan means “Knot of Protection,” and the festival ceremonies include the sister tying a rakhi
bracelet around her brother’s wrist, which symbolizes the sister’s love
and the brother’s lifelong duty to protect his sibling. The festival is
often simply referred to as “Rakhi” after the name of this ceremonial
bracelet.



Saturday, the President of India, Pranab Mukherjee, and the Prime Minister of India, Narendra Modi, issued a greeting
for tomorrow’s celebration, focusing on women: “May the festival be an
occasion for re-dedication to the well being of women, particularly the
girl child.”




Raksha Bandhan is an ancient celebration and its history is inter-woven with various stories and myths.
One story tells the tale of Mughal emperor Humayun and widowed queen
Rani Karnavati of Chittor. In the 16th century AD, Sultan Bahadur Shah
of Gujarat rode with a conquering army into Chittor, prompting Rani
Karnavati to sent a rakhi to Emperor Humayun in a request for help. 


Touched by her plea, the Mughal emperor rode to her defense but was too
late, as the princess and all the other women of the fortress had
committed suicide and the fortress had been captured. Humayun defeated
and expelled Sultan Bahadur and placed Rani’s son on the throne, and the
rakhi subsequently became a symbol of brotherly protection.




Another legend even involves the West, invoking the figure of Alexander the Great. When Alexander invaded India in the 4th
century BC, the story holds that his wife Roxana sent a rakhi to King
Porus of Paurava. Roxana implored the king not to harm Alexander in
battle, and Porus respected her request, staying a killing blow to
Alexander on the battlefield while wearing the rakhi. Historically, the
Greeks won the battle and Porus continued to rule Paurava in service to
Alexander.



….
During the festival,
participants wear fine Indian clothing and prepare many traditional
Indian foods and snacks. During the rakhi ritual, the sister will first
tie the bracelet around her brother’s wrist, then bless him and pray
over him. She will then feed him, usually with some sweets that have
been prepared. The two will then hug and exchange gifts, thus ending the
ritual. The brother will keep the rakhi and wear it for the rest of the
day as a reminder of his duty to protect his sister.



….

Not only Hindus, but Sikhs, Jains, and even some Indian Muslims
celebrate Raksha Bandhan as well. In recent decades, Raksha Bandhan has
spread to other parts of South Asia, developing different regional and
cultural variants and practices. For many, it has extended beyond the
traditional brother-sister relationship and is used to celebrate the
love of ones cousins or even very close friends.
 

….
The festival takes
place in the Hindu calendar month of Shraavana, and falls on August 10
this year.

….

Link (1): http://hindus-prepare-raksha-bandhan-annual-celebration-brother-sister-love

Link (2): http://infochangeindia.org/environment/stories-of-change/a-rakhi-for-trees.html
….

regards

Monsoon mood mellowing in Mumbai

….Amarinder Singh said, “We are facing failure of monsoon. I wonder if it’s god’s will….I  wonder if it’s El Nino or El
Modi effect…….There has been some sin. God does not like that. We all
remember what happened in Gujarat in 2002” …..

…..
A bit of music, philosophy and policy riddles to take a bit of your time away from all the cheers and gaiety spread across India and the diaspora today.

A monsoon (bollywood) tune pictured on the iconic Marine Drive in Mumbai (movie: Manzil, song: Rim Jhim Ghire Sawan, Year: 1979, music: RD Burman, voice: Kishore Kumar, Lata Mangeshkar, lyrics: Yogesh, actors: Amitabh Bachhan, Mousumi Chatterjee).
…..

…..
For people who prefer the instrumental version, here is a nice one by Mubasher Hasan Syed
…..

…..
Incidentally Yogesh was a brilliant lyricist (see Wiki profile below) and composed for some of our best loved songs (Kahin Door Jab Din Dhal Jaye and Zindagi Kaisi Hai Paheli from Anand, also the songs of Rajnigandha and Baton Baton Mein). 
…….
Rains in Mumbai is also the best time to pursue (non-academic grade) philosophy. We
pause to contemplate on the twin concepts of instant karma (revenge
pulao served hot) and instant moksha (sweet kheer for absolution).

It was in June of this year that the newly elected MP from Amritsar, Captain (Sardar) Amarinder Singh Sahib [son of late Maharaja Yadavindra Singh and Maharani Mohinder Kaur of
Patiala] declared that the penalty for electing sinners will be a failed
monsoon. Voting the wrong way will cost millions of farmers their livelihood and in many cases their lives.

In order to avert the worst drought in a decade there came a deluge of rain-invoking pujas in
Varanasi (Sankat Mochan deity – one who removes all stress and grief –
Shiva), Kathmandu (Pashu-Pati-Nath deity – one who takes care of all
living beings – Shiva) and elsewhere. The rain-Gods were apparently mollified and Mumbai recorded one of the wettest July-s ever, in the past 50 years.
……

According to India Meteorological Department (IMD) rainfall figures
since 1959, Santacruz received 1547.5 mm rainfall in the month of July,
breaking the previous highest total rainfall measured in the month of
July, at 1455.5 mm (Santacruz, 1965). Similarly,
Colaba this year, recorded a total July rainfall of 1401.7 mm, the second highest total rainfall in July (1441.3 mm in 1974).

……..

….
Now that the monsoon has recovered in large measure does it follow that the stains from 2002 have been washed away by the rains in 2014….no, we do not think so.  We respectfully suggest that Sardarji should re-think his claims of divine retribution and focus like a laser on getting justice for the victims of 2002, 1984,….there are too many of them to count.

……

….
It is the (strange but true) case that peninsular India depends significantly on hydro-electric power. If rainfall is lacking there will be a four-way competition for water (residential, industrial, agricultural and for power generation). Things are now thankfully better, however drought persists in Telengana and Andhra Pradesh (is this due to the sin incurred by Partition?). But here is hoping that rain gods keep smiling and the bounty of water is available to all…..for the sinners and for the pure.
………
That brings us to the main question at hand. Even after so many decades following independence, India is sunk without a good monsoon. Why is this? Because of corruption on a gigantic scale, agriculture and religion are probably the two areas where the money is maximum (and so is the corruption).

Dialing down the dependence on monsoon may be difficult but is a must for a nation that demands a high seat at the United Nations (another incomprehensible problem: India grows sufficient food but loses 30% due to inadequate storage).
……………

The sudden sharp increase in Southwest Monsoon
rainfall for the week ending August 6th 2014 has come as a blessing for
the farmers who have been reeling under the threat of a looming drought.
The Indian Meteorological Department data released on Friday evening
shows that the rainfall for the week ending August 6, 2014 was a
substantial 19% higher than the normal rains during the period. 

This is a
substantial gain as the rainfall for the previous week ending 30th
July, 2014 was 9% lower than the normal for the period.




Consequently the overall shortage in cumulative rainfall for the
country as a whole since the start of the south west monsoon has dipped
from 23% on July 30, 2014 to a more manageable 18% by August 4, 2014.
Overall it is certainly safe to say that though the rainfall in the
current South West Monsoon is still short of the levels received in 2013
it is still better than the rains in 2012.



….
However the gains from the revival of the monsoon are mixed as the
trends vary substantially across the states. Though the overall trends
have turned positive with the number of meteorological subdivisions that
have registered a cumulative excess or normal rainfall in the current
monsoons suddenly shooting up from 15 to 20 over the last one week and
the number of subdivisions with deficient or scantly rainfall has
slumped from 21 to 16.



….
Though rains have been in excess in only one sub division, namely
Orissa where the total rainfall since June 1st has been 25% of the
normal, a lot of other regions have also gained substantially. Important
sub divisions which has now received normal rainfall in the current
season and which can contribute substantially to agriculture output
include East and West Madhya Pradesh, East and West Rajasthan,
Uttarakhand, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Sub Himalayan West Bengal and
Gangetic West Bengal.



….
The top agriculture regions where rainfall continues to be in deficit
include Punjab (-59%), Haryana (-54), Himachal Pradesh (-36%), Western
UP (-43%), Eastern UP (-43%) and Bihar (-28%). While the extensive
irrigation facilities in Punjab, Haryana and Western UP may help make up
for some deficiency in rainfall it will still continue to impact
agriculture output.



….
The prospects of agriculture in peninsular India are more mixed.
While Madhya Maharashtra and Vidharbha have had normal rainfall the
scenario in Marathwada is precarious with the rainfall being 57% below
normal. This would also have implication for the state elections later
in the year. The scenario is similar in Karnataka with the Coastal and
South Interior Karnataka receiving normal rainfall while North Interior
Karnataka registered a deficit of 24%.



….
The worst affected in the region was Andhra Pradesh and Telengana
where all the three sub divisions registered deficit rainfall ranging
from 27% to 48%. However, both Tamil Nadu and Kerala continued to have
normal rainfall.



….
The improvement in rainfall bodes well as the water levels in the
important reservoirs have also risen. Most recent estimates show that
the current storage levels in the reservoirs is about 82% of the last
year level and 116% of the average storage levels during the last
decade. 

This is certainly a substantial improvement from the scenario
that prevailed in early July and will help limit the anticipated decline
in agriculture output during the year. With the IMD having projected a
better rainfall in August as compared to July there is certainly reasons
for more optimism.

…..

[ref. Wiki] Yogesh was born in Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh.



He moved in search of work, his cousin was a screenplay director. His first work was with Hrishikesh Mukherjee, and wrote Kahin Door Jab Din Dal Jaaye. He wrote songs like Zindagi Kaisi Hai Paheli and Rimjhim gire Saawan, Kai baar yunhi dekha hai from Rajnigandha and Na bole tum na maine kuch kaha from Baaton Baaton Mein.


..
Yogesh also worked in television serials as a writer.



Lyric writer Yogesh Gaur was a man in great demand among the slice-of-life filmmakers like Basu Chatterjee and Hrishikesh Mukherjee.
The story goes that Mukherjee heard the lyrics of two songs Yogesh had
written for producer LB Lachman’s film, and wanted them for Anand.




Lachmanji was adamant about keeping the songs, but Rajesh Khanna,
Amitabh Bachchan and Mukherjee pleaded with him. Bachchan, who was a
young man then, would say to me, Please get us these two songs somehow.
Finally, Lachmanji relented and gave them one of the songs, says Yogesh.




The song, Kahin door jab din dhal jaaye, shot the lyricist to
overnight popularity. Mukherjee was so happy he got Yogesh to pen
another song for him, Zindagi kaisi yeh paheli for Anand too. Soon, the
fan mail was pouring in.




Funnily, people also sent me flowers for Maine tere liye, which was written by Gulzar,
says the man, popularly known as ‘shaayar’ by actresses of that time.
The nickname happened because the heroines, when they reported on the
sets, would insist he recite some of his shaayari. “Producers thought
the heroines were getting distracted by my poetry, especially when I
waxed eloquent about their beauty,” he laughs.



….
Known as the ‘sensible film lyricist’, Yogesh worked primarily with Chatterjee and Mukherjee, rather than ‘masala’ filmmakers. My
problem was similar to that faced by the filmmakers themselves. My work
was appreciated, but was restricted to ‘art’ films. But they were more
real than arty, he says.




Working with Basu Chatterjee was not the easiest, says Yogesh.  

Basuda
was a master of his craft, but brainstorming sessions with him weren’t
all that fun. While discussing a song for Rajnigandha, he would say, in
true Bengali style: ‘Uske baad, Vidya wahan se aata hai.’ I had to stop
him and ask if he meant heroine Vidya Sinha’s character or hero Amol
Palekar’s. He got angry and said he was referring to Vidya. I didn’t
bother explaining to him that he had actually mixed up the gender while
speaking in Hindi, Yogesh says. 

But the collaboration was a fruitful
one. Yogesh wrote some of his best songs for Chatterjee, like Kai baar
yunhi dekha hai from Rajnigandha and Na bole tum na maine kuch kaha from
Baaton Baaton Mein.

…..

Link (1): http://strong-monsoon-recovery-rains-hopes-on-food-front

Link (2): http://Poor-monsoon-Gods-punishment-for-Gujarat-riots-Amarinder-Singh

……

regards

“Why cant a woman be more like a man?”

…..Erdogan lashed out at
Zaman, calling her a “shameless
woman”…… “A militant in the guise of a journalist, a shameless woman… Know your place!” he declared…….“They gave you a pen… and
you insult a society that is 99 per cent Muslim”…..

….

….
This is why we like to see women on top, not because all men are bad, not because women are superior, but just to show that women are (in public life) in every way possible equal to men. To show that women can be LOL funny, and….they do not need permission from men to LOL in public.
……..

….
Indira Gandhi (also Margaret Thatcher) was referred to as the only man in her cabinet. We prefer Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s comparison of Mrs Gandhi to Goddess Durga. Legend has it that when all the men failed, it was up to the Goddess to stop the Mahish-Asura. We need women to help out as Mahish-Asura-Mardini (demon slayer) today….because the men are just not competent enough.

Erdogan is just a three-penny bully in the Turkey shop, and most South Asian politicians probably think like him (if not talk like him). In our opinion Middle East would be a better place if it was led by women. Golda Meir was thousand times the “man” that Bibi Netanyahu ever would be. She made the prescient comment: Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us. Except that she was only half right, peace requires the Jews to stop hating Arabs as well.
…..
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan faced a new outcry on
Friday over his attitude to the media and women after he branded a
prominent female journalist a “shameless woman” and told her “to know
your place”.

Just ahead of Sunday’s presidential election which
he is clear favourite to win, Erdogan savaged Amberin Zaman,
who writes for the Economist and the Turkish daily Taraf, over comments
she made in a television debate. She had asked the main opposition
leader Kemal Kilicdaroglu in the debate whether any Muslim society was
capable of challenging its authorities.

Erdogan lashed out at
Zaman, without mentioning her directly by name, at an election rally in
the eastern city of Malatya on Thursday, calling her a “shameless
woman”.

“A militant in the guise of a journalist, a shameless woman… Know your place!” he declared.
“They gave you a pen and you are writing a column in a newspaper… and
you insult a society that is 99 per cent Muslim,” he said, drawing loud
boos from the crowd.

This is not the first time Erdogan has
lashed out at journalists, who have come under increasing pressure in
Turkey, which has more reporters behind bars than any other country in
the world.

The government’s attitude towards women is also under
heavy scrutiny, after Deputy Prime Minister Bulent Arinc caused a furore
by suggesting women should not laugh loudly in public.

The Economist released a statement in response to the salvo, saying “we stand firmly by” its correspondent of 15 years. “The intimidation of journalists has no place in a democracy. Under Mr
Erdogan, Turkey has become an increasingly difficult place for
independent journalism,” it said.

Zaman responded to Erdogan
through her column in the Taraf newspaper, writing: “You are lynching a
Muslim woman who described what you are doing.

……
Turkish Deputy Prime Minster Bulent Arinc is the latest government official to put his foot in his mouth.


In a speech last week, this high-ranking official preached his perverted
version of morality to Turkish women by telling them not to laugh in
public!
“Chastity is so important,” Deputy Prime Minister BĂŒlent Arınç said. “A
woman will know what is haram and not haram. She will not laugh out
loud in public. She will not be inviting in her attitudes and will
protect her chasteness.”


….

Arinc, a co-founder of the ruling AK Party, continued his chauvinist
sermonizing: “Where are our girls who slightly blush, lower their heads,
and turn their eyes away when we look at their faces, becoming the
symbol of chastity?”
He ridiculed women for discussing cooking recipes
and other “frivolous things” on cell phones. Imitating a female voice,
he squeaked: “What happened to Ayse’s daughter? When is the wedding?” He
told the women to talk about such insignificant matters “face to face,”
not on the phone!


….

The Deputy Prime Minister’s demeaning remarks spread like wildfire. In
defiance, tens of thousands of Turkish women went on social media
(Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram) posting ‘selfies,’ pictures of
themselves, laughing out loud. Rather than stopping their laughter,
women started laughing … at him!

….

Link (1): http://www.dawn.com/uproar-over-erdogans-remarks-against-woman-reporter

Link (2): http://www.huffingtonpost.com/harut-sassounian/turkish-deputy-prime-min

…..

regards

“Our children should at least look like us”

….What the NRIs get is often the `rejects’ of the Indian
parents

NRIs insist on having fair-skinned children….police found nine infants and a pregnant Thai woman….most of the children appeared Western...Lertkrai said: “The babies all look different…hard to
believe they share the same blood
”…..


Are “fair-skinned” children really the be-all and end-all of
adoption and is it the case that a “fair skinned child” always “look like us”?
 

We do not know how to say this politely, but in the pale-world
all browns are sand-niggers.
Our cousins – one of whom can be fairly
described as golden white in complexion – who grew up down under were
called “chocolate” in school.
…….


Meanwhile…a huge surrogacy scandal. One golden-hearted Australian couple – with the dad-to-be, a remorse-free, child sex offender – had twins through surrogacy. One of the kids has Down’s syndrome and was abandoned (see below). In response, Thailand plans to ban commercial surrogacy effective yesterday, and 200-odd aussie parents-to-be will be facing maximum pain (and monetary loss).

India is the only other nation widely open to surrogacy. Recent rules have been tightened here as well, this path is supposedly blocked for same sex couples or single parents-to-be. But knowing how the rules work in India, one can always find a way out, if you know what we mean. Unlike Thailand, you may even be able to dump the kid if you do not like her, pay off the agency a bit of hush money and no one would be wiser.

Here is the thing that is truly bothersome. Why is adoption such a headache? Leaving aside the fair-skinned child supply-demand mismatch, how is it fair that Non Resident Indians are finding the adoption process to be more cumbersome than Ethiopia? Why not have a fast-track process available for people who can afford it? NRIs have a lot of clout with Indian babu-dom, remittances from abroad is a precious lifeline for India.There should be a full-fledged effort to settle children as quickly as possible. Who knows, with the right incentives in place, people may fall in love with a dark-skinned child as well!!

If the new rules treat everyone at par, then that counts as progress. We are a bit scared of Shrimati Maneka (first animal lover, wife of Sanjay) Gandhi but we are rather pleased with her efforts in this direction.
……
Five
years after they submitted documents for adopting a child in India, Devi
and Joseph will finally get to see their six-year-old ‘daughter’ when
the non-resident Indian couple settled in Dallas in the United States
comes to Delhi next month to take her home.

……
It has been a long
wait filled with home studies, delays and court procedures. “The
adoption agency in Delhi has been regularly sending us pictures of
Siara, but we feel we have missed out a good part of her childhood,”
said Joseph, 43, who hails from Bangalore and works as software analyst
in the US. 

   “At one point, we had decided to adopt a child from China or
Ethiopia, where the delay is much less, but my wife was insistent our
child should at least look like us,” said Joseph, speaking over the
phone. Indian expatriates hoping to adopt a child from their home
country may soon have to submit to a much less gruelling experience than
Devi and Joseph.

NRI couples could be treated on a par with
their resident Indian counterparts following changes being made to
adoption rules by the Ministry of Women and Child Welfare.
As a result,
NRI couples could have equal opportunities for adopting a child in
India. This will spell a major change from the existing rules, under
which the first preference is given to India-based couples.

Maneka Gandhi, whose ministry is working towards finetuning the Juvenile
Justice (JJ) Act with an entire chapter on adoption for the first time,
has already written to adoption agencies in states, child welfare
committee heads and judges not to delay the processing of adoption
applications.

A few years ago adoption agencies were asked to
stick to a ratio of 80:20, with only a fifth of the eligible children
for adoption abroad, in a move introduced to curb overseas child
trafficking in the garb of adoption. This led to a fall in overseas
adoptions from 628 in 2010-11 to 430 in 2013-2014.

“What the
NRIs get is often the `rejects’ of the Indian parents. NRIs insist on
having fair-skinned, healthy children less than one year of age but such
children are to be first picked by couples here,” said a senior
official at Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA), the body that
handles and monitors adoptions in India.

The official, who did
not wish to be identified, added, “The NRIs, even after waiting for many
months, are left to choose from children with medical issues, which is
why they choose to go to other countries or give up on the process.”

In the past ten years, over 8,000 NRI couples have applied for Indian
children but only a few have been shortlisted. “We screen the NRI
couples many times to keep the number very small because we know due to
the existing rules we don’t have many children to list for adoption. We
will expand the list once the new rules are notified,” the official
said.
 This should change as the company’s restructuring paves the way for growth
 .

 ……..

HUNDREDS of Australians with infants
newly born or being carried by pregnant Thai surrogates are in limbo
after Thailand moved to outlaw commercial ­surrogacy.

The National Council of Peace and Order interim military government
yesterday announced the drastic measure, aimed at shutting a burgeoning
industry mostly catering to foreign biological parents, in the wake of
the baby Gammy scandal.

Surrogacy Australia executive officer
Rachel Kunde estimated there were up to 200 Australian couples whose
surrogates were pregnant in Thailand or whose infants had been born in
recent days and weeks.

In Surrogacy Australia’s network, there were close to 100 ­couples in that situation. “We
are very concerned for those people and we hope that they can bring
their babies home without any trouble from Thai authorities,” Ms Kunde
said.

Last night an Australian woman whose surrogate is 30 weeks pregnant
in Bangkok said she was highly anxious about the prospect of the
surrogate “going underground” if she were pressured.

“I called the
nurse at the clinic this morning and she told me all the surrogates are
still coming in for their scans,” said the woman, who asked for
anonymity to protect her daughter, born to a Thai surrogate. “It is a
horrible wait for us. We are due to go there in eight weeks but we are
really worried about whether we will be able to leave with the baby.”

The
foreign surrogacy scandal was triggered a week ago by the revelation a
West Australian couple, Wendy and David Farnell, had left behind in
Thailand a Down syndrome baby with his birth mother.

The birth
mother, Pattaramon Janbua, 21, claims the couple refused to accept the
boy, Gammy, now seven months old, but returned home with his twin
sister.

The Farnells have denied this account but in a statement and through a friend have given varying accounts.

Ms
Pattaramon, on hearing Mr Farnell had in the past been convicted of
child sex offences, has demanded the girl be returned to her.

The
new law is currently in draft form — it has been proposed since 2012 but
the previous democratic government “sat on it” ­according to one of its
drafters — and could take several months to pass and implement.

In
the meantime, the government says it will strictly apply Thailand
Medical Council regulations that prohibit surrogacy except for blood
relatives and on condition there is no payment.

This effectively
prevents Thai fertility clinics and doctors from offering the service,
which has been used by an estimated 200 Australians — couples and
potential sole parents — a year in recent years.

However, serious
questions remain about the implementation of the law as it affects
foreign ­people’s children just born to Thai surrogates, or fetuses
still being carried to term by birth mothers.

NCPO spokesman
Colonel Winthai Suvaree said yesterday the law would allow infants who
have just been born to be suckled by their birth mothers for six months,
but then would allow the baby to be taken home by parents.

Health
Ministry general-secretary Samphan Komrit was very vague about how the
law would apply to the foreign biological parents of fetuses being
carried by Thai women for payment, however. He would only say those
cases would be dealt with “according to morality”.

Colonel Winthai
said: “Commercial surrogacy is illegal, according to the Medical
Council. We don’t know the whereabouts of the (currently pregnant)
surrogate mothers, so it is a difficult question to answer.” He
said the new law was aimed at protecting infants and Thai women,
although Ms Kunde said she was concerned also about the potential for
Thai surrogates to be harassed or persecuted.

The new law will punish doctors and fertility clinics carrying out the procedures, and surrogacy agents, from today onwards. Under
the current TMC regulations, enabling commercial surrogacy is
punishable by one to three years’ imprisonment and fines of 20,000 to
60,000 baht ($670-$2000).

Currently there is no law specifically
covering surrogacy, although Thai Medical Council regulations specify
any such pregnancy must be altruistic — not for payment — and the birth
mother must be a blood relative of the ­donors.

Police are
investigating the Bangkok clinic, agent and doctors involved in Ms
Pattaramon’s pregnancy with a view to laying charges under current TMC
­regulations.

The scandal escalated on Tuesday when police and
welfare officers found nine infants and a pregnant Thai woman,
accompanied by nannies, in several apartments at Latphrao, a northern
Bangkok condominium block. Police were yesterday still trying to establish the identities and parentage of the babies. They are planning DNA tests. 

A
lawyer acting for a Japanese man he claims is a wealthy businessman
said his client wanted the babies for himself and planned to raise them
in Thailand. He claimed the Japanese father was planning to pay about
one million baht for the 10 surrogacies.

However, a Japanese woman
interviewed at the scene on Tuesday claimed one of the children was
hers and several witnesses said most of the children appeared Western.

Yanee
Lertkrai, the director-general of the Department of Social Development
and Welfare, said: “The babies all look different and it is hard to
believe they share the same blood.
Personally, I think the surrogacy of the babies is illegal.”

Surrogacy Australia’s Ms Kunde yesterday blamed rogue operators for causing the crackdown.
 â€œThe
people in our network have all used reputable clinics and they have
talked to other couples first — most people do the right thing,” she
said.

Yesterday, West Australian Child Protection Minister Helen
Morton declined to reveal whether her department was still considering
leaving the twin sister of baby Gammy with their Australian parents
following fresh details about the child sex offences of the husband,
Bunbury electrician David John Farnell.

His offending spanned a 10-year period and a magistrate found he had no remorse for his youngest victim.

….

Link (1): http://New-adoption-rules-NRIs-to-be-treated-on-par-with-Indians

Link (2):  http://thai-crackdown-strands-surrogacy-couples

…..

regards

No beards (burqas) on the (Xinjiang) bus

…..prohibit those who wear veils, head scarves, jilbab, clothing with the crescent moon and star, long
beards from boarding buses
in the northwestern city of Karamay...Urumqi ban….cigarette lighters, yogurt and water,
in a bid to prevent violent attacks.
….

We are admittedly in favor of banning religion-inspired parties. After receiving feedback from liberty-conscious people we have reformed a bit (all lefty-s are secret Stalinists) and propose a more incremental (and hopefully, practical) approach.

….
We have in mind a directive principle (constitutionally desirable but not enforceable, just like the uniform civil code) that India being a federation of states, all political parties (as represented by their state units) must strive for cross-community representation both in primary membership as well as candidates for positions at all levels (gram-panchayat, municipality, state assembly).

A nationally recognized party (there are specific qualification rules in place) must (in addition to the above) work towards having a designated number of cross-community candidates for Lok/Rajya Sabha. Currently, the BJP does not have a single muslim MP in the Lok Sabha (there were a few muslim BJP candidates), and only a couple of MPs in the Rajya Sabha.

Thus in Bengal, where muslims are 40% of the population, the BJP has to ensure a certain minimum of party members and candidates which are muslims. Same goes for hindu representation in Muslim League (Kerala), AUDF (Asom), AMIM (Telengana), National Conference (Jammu and Kashmir) and Akali Dal (Punjab). If the minority numbers fall below some threshold in a state this principle may not apply.

The idea is to encourage broad based agenda for political parties and discourage polarization as a vote-winning approach. If we do not take this seriously then the social fabric will continue to be damaged over time. Food for thought.

There is another way ahead and the Chicoms have just indicated how they would like to tackle the “diversity problem.” We feel that such a heavy-handed approach is counter-productive, but it is certainly better than shooting/starving tens of thousands of people (like what is going on in Iraq right now). Not that the Chicoms are shy about killing, 59 people were gunned down in reaction to the recent uprising last week.

………………..
A city in China’s restive western region of Xinjiang has banned
people with head scarves, veils and long beards from boarding buses, as
the government battles unrest with a policy that critics said
discriminates against Muslims.

…………

Xinjiang, home to the Muslim
Uighur people who speak a Turkic language, has been beset for years by
violence that the government blames on Islamist militants or
separatists.

Authorities will prohibit five types of passengers —
those who wear veils, head scarves, a loose-fitting garment called a
jilbab, clothing with the crescent moon and star, and those with long
beards – from boarding buses in the northwestern city of Karamay, state
media said.

The crescent moon and star symbol of Islam features
on many national flags, besides being used by groups China says want to
set up an independent state called East Turkestan.

The rules were
intended to help strengthen security through August 20 during an
athletics event and would be enforced by security teams, the ruling
Communist Party-run Karamay Daily said on Monday. “Those who do not comply, especially those five types of passengers, will be reported to the police,” the paper said.

In
July, authorities in Xinjiang’s capital Urumqi banned bus passengers
from carrying items ranging from cigarette lighters to yogurt and water,
in a bid to prevent violent attacks.

Exiled Uighur groups and
human rights activists say the government’s repressive policies in
Xinjiang, including controls on Islam, have provoked unrest, a claim
Beijing denies.

“Officials in Karamay city are endorsing an
openly racist and discriminatory policy aimed at ordinary Uighur
people,” Alim Seytoff, the president of the Washington-based Uyghur
American Association, said in an emailed statement.

While many
Uighur women dress in much the same casual style as those elsewhere in
China, some have begun to wear the full veil, a garment more common in
Pakistan or Afghanistan than in Xinjiang.

Police have offered money for tips on everything from “violent terrorism training” to individuals who grow long beards.

Hundreds
have died in unrest in Xinjiang in the past 18 months, but tight
security makes it almost impossible for journalists to make independent
assessments of the violence.

About 100 people were killed when
knife-wielding attackers staged assaults in two towns in the region’s
south in late July, state media said, including 59 “terrorists” shot
dead by police.

…….

Chinese police gunned down 59 people and
arrested 215 during a violent uprising last week in the Xinjiang region,
the government said Sunday, in a statement that shed fresh light on
what dissident groups had earlier described as a major clash in the
area.

In coordinated predawn actions on
July 28, unnamed assailants attacked civilians, state buildings and
vehicles in two Xinjiang towns, including Elixhu, according to police
descriptions reported by the government-run Xinhua news agency.

The agency said 37 civilians were among the
96 people who were killed during the attack. Sunday’s statement called
the assailants terrorists and said the attack had foreign support.

The
new figures, which emerged from a high-level meeting of the Communist
Party over the weekend in Xinjiang, according to Xinhua, illustrate the
seriousness of continued violence in China’s largely Muslim province of
Xinjiang. The area abuts Central Asia and has seen minor clashes
reported weekly.

The Xinhua report said
assailants displayed banners declaring a “holy war” and were coordinated
by a banned group called East Turkestan Islamic Movement that China’s
government says aims to make Xinjiang independent. Sunday’s report said
civilians were stopped at roadblocks and slashed with knives if they
refused to join the rally.

The
mastermind of the attack was Nuramat Sawut, the report said. Xinhua
described him as the local leader of the movement and responsible in the
past year for spreading audio and video calls for separatism and
religious extremism. Mr. Sawut wasn’t reachable and Xinhua’s report
didn’t say whether he specifically participated in the attacks.

The
report didn’t say where overseas the group had obtained assistance,
though in the past China’s government has cited training of separatists
by religious extremists in Pakistan.

Ethnic tensions between Han Chinese migrants
and Xinjiang’s Turkic-speaking, mostly Muslim Uighur ethnic group have
remained high for years, with religious, political and economic
overtones.

But as violence has at times
spilled outside Xinjiang and appeared to target civilians, China’s
government in May launched a one-year crackdown on terrorism and has
since reported numerous raids, arrests and clashes, often involving
Uighurs.

Uighurs complain that Han
Chinese control the government and economy, crimp religious activity and
are too aggressive with policing. China’s government cites its
financial investments in the region.and says only a small majority of
Xinjiang’s people are responsible for the troubles.

During
last week’s clash, near the city of Yarkand, took place a day before
the mostly Muslim area was set to celebrate the end of Ramadan.

Assailants
with knives rampaged through town slashing people and smashing symbols
of government power, state media said. In its initial reporting on the
attack, Xinhua had said dozens of civilians were killed while at least
36 cars were smashed or set on fire. The initial report also called it
“an organized, premeditated and carefully planned terrorist attack of
vile nature and tremendous violence.”

Later in the week, assailants, identified by Chinese authorities as Uighurs, knifed to death the government-appointed imam of Id Kah Mosque in the nearby city of Kashgar. On Friday, police in Xinjiang had shot dead nine suspected terrorists and captured another in Xinjiang’s Hotan prefecture.
……

Link(1): http://china-bans-beards-veils-from-xinjiang-citys-buses

Link(2): http://china-says-violent-xinjiang-uprising-leaves-almost-100-dead

…..

regards

Brown Pundits