busy day today but I feel Z’s victory is kind of a big (huge) deal. even more than Sadiq’s.. dump ur links about it in the thread
Category: X.T.M
Islam the Religion of Peace part ii
Samir Zitouni, a 48-year-old rail worker, is in critical condition after stepping between a knife-wielding attacker and passengers on a DoncasterâLondon train. Witnesses say he blocked the assailant from stabbing a girl and was slashed across the head and neck.
He has worked for LNER for more than twenty years. His managers call his actions ânothing short of heroic.â The attacker, Anthony Williams, has been charged with ten counts of attempted murder.
A Muslim man (most likely Algerian origin) from the Midlands saw people in danger and acted without hesitation.
Open Thread
The boycott has made Brown Pundits quieter, almost peaceful. I donât mind it. Every few years the site reaches this point; it grows, gains noise, and starts to feel less like a hobby and more like an obligation. Then it falls back to something smaller and saner.
Iâve also realised that the Indo-Pak frame doesnât really fit my life anymore. It was useful once because thatâs where the conversation was; it gave the blog an audience. But most of that talk is stale now; the same arguments, just louder.
What interests me instead are the wider patterns: how post-colonial societies move in a world that is no longer unipolar. The Gulfâs rise, Africaâs experiments, Chinaâs reach, Indiaâs own breadth. How old hierarchies break down, and new ones form.
I donât like following the news. So perhaps BP will drift in that direction. Fewer posts, less noise, more reflection. A space for thinking about what comes after the post-colonial age, when the world starts to finally balance itself again.
Caste, Civilisation, and the Courage to Own It
Kabir suggested that I apologise but for what, exactly? Why should Saffroniate be considered offensive? Own it. I donât see anything inherently wrong with the idea of Akhand Bharat; the concept of a broader Dharmic civilisation makes eminent sense to me.
Likewise, I donât understand why questioning caste identities provokes such sensitivity. Again, own it because the more caste is repressed, the more likely it is to resurface.
At heart, Iâm a reformist, not a revolutionary. I believe in improving and refining what exists, not erasing it. Cultural features should only be abolished when they are truly harmful or deleterious, not simply because they make us uncomfortable.
To be or not to be (Capricious)
The November circular was emailed earlier to all various stakeholders of BP. This will be sticky for a short period as unfortunately publishing all the drafts has pushed the current posts much further down.
You may also use this thread as an unmoderated Open Threads. Topics of interest include JD Vance’s comments, the stabbing in the UK by asylum seekers (presumably), and any other interest. I would suggest everyone engage with the email, after the jump; if you have been emailed it privately, I do expect private replies as well.
The Hidden Migrations of BahĂĄâĂs in Northern Iran: AyyĂĄm-i-HĂĄ Reflections
Today marks the beginning of AyyĂĄm-i-HĂĄ, a time of generosity, renewal, and joy in the BahĂĄâĂ calendar. While speaking in Farsi with a local BahĂĄâĂ friend in the Boston-Cambridge area, she mentioned she was born in Gonbad-e-Kavus, a town near the Turkmenistan border. I had never heard of it before, but as we spoke, the connections began to form.
![]()
The UNESCO Gonbad-e-Qabus (Tower of Qabus)
A Lost BahĂĄâĂ Connection
Just across the border in Turkmenistan (then part of the Russian Empire) lies Ashqabad, one of the earliest BahĂĄâĂ settlementsâa city where, in the 1920s, BahĂĄâĂs openly practiced their faith, established institutions, and flourished.
But what struck me was that this BahĂĄâĂ woman had roots in Semnan Province, a region historically associated with the Faith. How did her family end up in Gonbad, a town that, in my ignorance, had no known BahĂĄâĂ presence?
Her answer unveiled a hidden chapter of BahĂĄâĂ migrationâone that reflected centuries of adaptation, resilience, and survival in the face of persecution.
Continue reading The Hidden Migrations of BahĂĄâĂs in Northern Iran: AyyĂĄm-i-HĂĄ Reflections
Was Madhya Pradesh Designed to Dilute Muslim Concentration?
A Post-Partition Theory of State Formation in the Hindi Belt
Indiaâs state formations have often been explained as products of linguistic reorganization (1956), administrative convenience, or colonial inheritanceâbut what if there was an unspoken demographic dimension shaping the boundaries of certain states?
Madhya Pradesh, the so-called *heart of India*, presents an interesting case: it was deliberately constructed to dilute the political and demographic influence of its historically significant Muslim populations, particularly in Bhopal, Malwa, and Nimar. If this theory holds for MP, could the same logic apply to the entire Hindi belt?
As a side note, this idea originally stemmed from a Brown Pundit commentator many moons ago, who suggested that Uttar Pradesh was structured to dilute Muslim concentrations around Delhi and Rohilkhand.
Continue reading Was Madhya Pradesh Designed to Dilute Muslim Concentration?
Greco-Roman Perceptions of the Iranic Peoples (And India): A Cross-Cultural Breakdown
April 21st: Flowers, Flags, and the Fight for Names
Saadi, Riá¸vĂĄn, Azizam, and the Architecture of Memory
Today marked a strange and layered convergence: the 1st Day of Riá¸vĂĄn, Saadi Day in Iran, Easter Vigil, and the release of Ed Sheeranâs Persian-coded âAzizamâ.
Each momentâspiritual, literary, liturgical, and algorithmicâcarries its own weight. But taken together, they tell a deeper story:
A story about naming, memory, and the silent wars over cultural survival in a world addicted to erasure.
Three Gardens
For BahĂĄâĂs, Riá¸vĂĄn commemorates BahĂĄâuâllĂĄhâs divine declaration in the Garden of Najibiyyihâtruth revealed under the shade of roses.
In Iran, thousands gather around the tomb of Saadi Shirazi, who composed the GulistÄn in 1256âa literary garden of parables, ethics, and eternal couplets.
And then, in a third gardenâInstagramâEd Sheeran drops the word Azizam, surrounded by Googoosh, Andy, and the digital applause of a million exiles.
Three gardens.
Three registers of meaning.
All still blooming.
Team Jesus, Westminster, and the Persian Schism
That night, I found myself at Easter Vigil in Westminster Cathedralâan accident of scheduling, but also a moment of clarity.
One of the baptisms was a name I recognized: Mahyar Tousi, a conservative Iranian YouTuber, publicly announcing:
âTeam Jesus assemble for Easter Vigil âď¸ Iâm getting officially baptised tonight with the very sound @andrejpwalker as my Godfather.â
The incense hadnât faded. The Latin still echoed. And yet this moment felt unmistakably Persianâa spiritual pivot made visible under the vaulted English sky.
Meanwhile, back in Iran, the pendulum swings harder:
GharbzadegiâWestoxificationâpulls one half of the diaspora toward performative Westernization. The homeland, meanwhile, is doubling down on Shiâism.
There is no âmiddle way.â
Just a widening chasm between the aesthetic and the absolute.
Memory Isnât the Problem. Misnaming Is.
A viral tweet this week sneered at a Tajik child reciting the Qurâan by heart:
âThis is our intellectual culture: just memorization, no critical thought. And we wonder why we fall behind.â
But this critique misunderstands whatâs happening.
The problem isnât memory.
The problem is dislocated memory.
Not roteâbut rootless.
Not repetitionâbut removal.
A child reciting scripture is not a failure of pedagogyâitâs a civilizational act.
What fails us is when memory becomes performance, and performance becomes currency.
The Dupatta, Rebranded
This week, a Nordic fashion label released pastel âScandinavian shawls.â
Theyâre clearly dupattasâdrained of history, rebranded without context.
A thing is renamed.
The origin is erased.
The prestige is reassigned.
Itâs not homage.
Itâs aesthetic laundering.
Civilizations like India and China can survive this.
Smaller ones disappear.
Naming is power.
When you lose your name, you lose your story.
The Iranian Line Holds
Hereâs something Iâve always noticed:
Iranians donât venerate their conquerors.
Hazrat âUmar is not a hero in Iran.
Hazrat âAli is exalted. YĂĄ âAliyyuâl-AâlĂĄ is whispered in every corner of the soul.
This matters.
It means Iran has retained civilizational self-respect in a way many post-colonial nationsâespecially Pakistanâhave not.
Pakistanâs endless identity crisis can be suffocating.
But it also allows a kind of flexibilityâa permeability I benefit from, writing this from a Pakistani-owned dessert cafĂŠ, scrolling through Persian-coded reels on Instagram.
Iâm not confused.
Iâm multilingual in civilizational memory.
Ed Sheeran and the Algorithmic Garden
Letâs be honest: Ed Sheeran is strategic.
He didnât just throw in a Persian word for fun.
By invoking Azizam and featuring Googoosh and Andy, he tapped directly into nostalgic Persianate elite longing. The pop version of Persian soft power.
What the Shah once wanted for Iranârecognition through eleganceâSheeran delivers via a viral reel.
Itâs not appropriation.
Itâs diplomacy, dressed as a duet.
But still:
Is it possible to be seen without being renamed?
The Long Decline and the Rejected Prophet
Sometimes I wonder:
Had colonization not derailed the Islamic world, how far would Islam have gone?
Manila was a Muslim sultanate. Islam reached the Balkans, sub-Saharan Africa, Indiaâs courts.
Would salÄt have matched the cross in global scope?
Weâll never know.
What we do know is that Islamic decline has been swift. And for those of us in the BahĂĄâĂ Faith, thereâs an explanation:
The rejection of the BĂĄb and BahĂĄâuâllĂĄh wasnât just religious.
It was civilizational.
And decline often follows refusal.
A Juxtaposition on Persian Identity
In the wake of my co-writerâs piece on the Pakistani bourgeoisie, Iâve been struck by how much Iran has held the center. Not just geopoliticallyâbut culturally.
Persian identity today splinters into three visible currents:
-
Reform Shiâism â Grounded in Iran, adapting slowly.
-
The Western Converts â Catholics, exiles, seekers of Rome and respectability.
-
The Azizam Crowd â Secular, stylish, steeped in Googoosh-era nostalgia.
I straddle none of these cleanly.
BahĂĄâĂ by faith, Persian by blood, Hindu by philosophyâmy life has become a braid of paths.
Not a crisis.
A choice.
As Anandamayi Ma once said:
âEveryone is right from his own standpoint.â
âAll paths are my paths. I have no particular path.â
There is freedom in that.
But also responsibility.
Because to walk a path, you must name it.
And to name it, you must remember where it began.
The Day of Gardens, and the Naming of Things
So today, we honor:
-
Riá¸vĂĄn: the divine garden of truth revealed
-
GulistÄn: the literary garden of ethical beauty
-
Instagram: the algorithmic garden of cultural remix
And we ask:
Can memory survive translation?
Can identity survive remix?
Can sacred names remain sacred when said by strangers?
The Persianate world hasnât answered these questions.
But itâs asking themâurgently, beautifully, painfully.
And sometimes, the most radical act is simply this:
To grow new roots, in soil of your choosing.
The Skyborne Castes
Power, Race, and the Architecture of Global Inequality
I pulled down my last piece owing to a a streak of bad luck. I was on verge of being denied boarding owing to the airline’s administrative error. At any rate once I got over that hurdle, the experience made me reflective again. Transiting through Cairo, an even harder metaphor hit me:
The world isnât a battleground, a marketplace, or even a village. Itâs a plane. A giant 300-seater Airbus. Maybe even a cruise ship in the sky (imagine a sky ship of sorts). Always moving. Never arriving. Continue reading The Skyborne Castes
