[A note before we begin: We held back out of respect for Iran Zamin and the weight of what was unfolding. Pakistan has now acted where others would not, and the moment deserves acknowledgement.
This should have been India’s role. No other power sits closer to both Tehran and Washington. No other civilisational bridge existed with the credibility to hold both sides. That fatal trip, PM Modi’s visit to Tel Aviv, poisoned those waters permanently. It did not merely signal a foreign policy choice. It signalled comfort with regime change in a neighbouring civilisation. The opportunity cost is historic and will not be recovered.
What Pakistan has achieved is without precedent in its modern history. The Muslim Prussian Republic, forged in argument, held together by will, perpetually doubted, walked into the gap the subcontinent’s greater power vacated and stopped a war. The world owes a debt to Quaid-e-Azam and Allama Iqbal’s creation that it will not rush to acknowledge. That is how it goes. But we are noting it here, now, while the moment is live.]
History named the last one. It was called the Twelve-Day War. Clean. Surgical. A rehearsal. This one will be called the Forty-Day War. It began on 28 February 2026 with a decapitation strike that shattered Iran’s command structure in a single night and a brutal attack on a girl’s school. It paused on 8 April, when a Pakistani Prime Minister’s tweet achieved what five weeks of bombardment, ultimatums, and a pope’s intervention could not.

Pakistan forced the pause the world could not secure.
This is not sentiment. It is structural. Islamabad was the only room both sides could enter. Pakistan maintained working diplomatic channels with Tehran throughout the war. It shared enough institutional credibility with Gulf capitals to be trusted as a mediator. It was sufficiently operationally relevant to Washington; Field Marshal Munir’s name appeared, unremarkably, in Trump’s own ceasefire announcement, to be taken seriously rather than patronised. No other state sat at that intersection. Egypt tried. Turkey tried. Neither had all three legs of the stool.

Over forty days, escalation outran control. Oil surged past $110 a barrel and briefly touched $117. Insurance markets seized. Traffic through the Strait of Hormuz reduced to a trickle. American signalling moved from coercive to apocalyptic, “a whole civilization will die tonight.” Iranian signalling hardened even as its leadership structure absorbed shock. Each side retained the capacity to raise costs further. Neither had a clean exit.

Pakistan supplied one.
The mechanics of the pause reveal everything. Tehran accepted a two-week window in which maritime traffic would resume under its coordination. Read that precisely. Coordination, not surrender. The Strait remains, in Iranian framing, an instrument of state power. That is not the language of defeat; though states rarely speak the language of defeat in real time, regardless of battlefield reality. What matters is what the text actually says. Iran controls the reopening. Iran does not yield it.
Washington will declare victory. The machinery is already running.
The United States will point to degraded military infrastructure, disrupted command networks, and restored passage through the Strait. The messaging will be coherent by morning. It will say force worked. Chronologically, force preceded the deal, which is not the same as causing it.
The record is less clean. Maximalist demands gave way to a framework that resembles proposals already on the table days earlier. Deadlines expired and were reset. Iran’s 10-point plan, dismissed as “not good enough” on 6 April, became “a workable basis for negotiation” on 7 April. The plan did not change. The clock ran out. This is not unusual. It is how late-stage coercive diplomacy resolves: pressure peaks, then converts into a deal that would have been rejected at the midpoint.
The long-term advantage belongs to Tehran; if it navigates the next two weeks.
The structural fact underneath both narratives is geography. The Strait of Hormuz cannot be bombed out of existence. It is a twelve-mile navigable corridor through which a fifth of the world’s energy supply must pass. Disrupting it does not require military victory. It requires capability and intent. Both survive battlefield attrition. Iran demonstrated this. Oil markets understood it immediately and priced it in for five weeks.

The US struck over 90 military sites on Kharg Island, handling 90% of Iranian crude exports, and left the oil infrastructure standing. That was not mercy. It was leverage preservation. The threat to destroy it remains active. But a threat held in reserve depreciates the longer it goes unused, and the moment formal talks begin in Islamabad on Friday, the depreciation accelerates.
This is not peace. It is a controlled interval. The underlying questions; Iran’s nuclear posture, Hormuz sovereignty, Gulf security architecture after a direct strike on the Iranian state, are unresolved. Both sides have reason to extend the window indefinitely. Managed ambiguity is, in the Middle East, often the best available outcome.
The war moved from missiles to a room in Islamabad. That is where it will be decided.
Lest we forget, our starting point:

the sad thing about all this is, even if Iran wins, (like north Vietnam ), the ruling setup will be weak and will eventually open up like Vietnam to the west and Arabs.
perhaps – but even so the Revolutionary Characteristics are preserved perhaps?
times have changed. Many characteristics will remain in name only.
Current china is a good example of being both communist and….??
Communist, Chinese & capitalist?
+ Han nationalism
If nothing else, the Iranian regime can be proud of its achievement in converting Donald Trump to Islam π .
Something amiss. a C130 and some helicopters landing in iran.
Looks like there US special forces are already in Iran probing.
For the rescue?
something more. how can Iran miss a C 130 landing. this is a huge aircraft.
there might be an attempt to retrieve nuclear material.
From the mountain fortress of Yazd? Or was it Isfahan?
Isfahan
“Are Films Political Tool?|Nope w/Kunal Kamra ft Anand Patwardhan|076”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LofD333rDo
What isnβt political?
as long as the films are ‘progressive ‘, shows poverty, struggle etc it is OK.
Once the so called right takes over the narrative, it is called political and propaganda these days.
There can be leftist as well as rightist propaganda.
On this very forum, we have consistently seen people call The Wire and Scroll “propaganda”.
I don’t agree with that characterization. Yes, both publications are generally anti Modi and anti BJP. They represent a centre-left viewpoint.
There are other publications that represent a right-wing viewpoint.
This is the new normal.
Critics will eventually make peace with it.
The overton window has shifted massively rightwards and will keep shifting.
Dhurandhar The Revenge makes Dhurandhar look fluffy and light.
Even RRR which apparently had “propaganda” looks quaint now.
Aditya Dhar has a blank cheque now and is making a Chandragupta Maurya movie.
His protege will also get a bigger cheque I guess.
He made Article 370 and Baramulla, both very well made movies.
Even critic Rahul Desai who is an extreme leftist found no technical flaws.
https://www.hollywoodreporterindia.com/reviews/streaming/baramulla-movie-review-horror-lies-in-the-eyes-of-the-beholder-in-manav-kaul-led-film
The left is pissed that the right has found craft.
The crying over Dhurandhar is not because it is “propaganda”. It is because it is “good propaganda” unlike Kashmir Files, Kerala Story level slop.
The duck and his local hatchet man ought to be tried as war criminals. Targeting any civilian infrastructure is a war crime.
What amazes me is that there’s not a squeak from Russia or China. Of course, this charade of a war gives legitimacy to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the Chinese are most likely waiting to strike Taiwan at an opportune moment. Given that the US has blown up billions of dollars worth of fancy weapons, unlikely they can ramp up production for a reasonably long time.
https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/over-11000-munitions-16-days-iran-war-command-reload-governs-endurance
China is supplying the missiles and technology to Iran
Proxy war like in Ukraine.
Talk of Russia and North Korea of having given ICBM’s to Iran
========
Listen to every word carefully.
A huge game changer
500 North Korean Hwasong ICBMs delivered to Iran
US has just 400 Minuteman II ICBMS
https://youtu.be/UZpkU6hrzcM
+1
Sino-Russia & North Korea helping their fellow Quad member like crazy.
Most of the world is being Iran fwiw.
Yes, the hardest part of wisdom is to keep quiet when the ego wants to speak. A lesson well imbued by Iran and undoubtedly Russia China. The NK Sino-Russian actions speak volumes.
But the deafening silence to this blatant violation of international law and complete ignorance of war crimes is appalling to me. Not one has stood up to the rogue President be it the Dems or any other country. Only Spain showed spine if I recollect correctly.
The bigger is issue is that the US has gone rogue (much like another country in 1940’s). Now it is blatantly committing War crimes and threatening further War Crimes
They are ignoring and circumventing International Law. This has been going on for some time under other Presidents too. But now ignoring International Law is blatant.
But who will Bell this Crazy Cat and send them to the Hague
But the deafening silence to this blatant violation
Whats the point of speaking up when you can do nothing about it. Doing some thing is WW3. The big players are waiting so that the US falls internally. Trump helping immensely
Hague and the UN (much like it’s predecessor the League of Nations) is a toothless tiger controlled by the US. US has gone rogue for a long time now as you point out. If the rest of the world doesn’t bell the cat, its anyway WW3.
The US is geographically isolated which clearly allows it to be the bull in West Asia’s China shop. No consequences for the bombing of so many countries in West Asia till date.
Nations collapse at leisure, so expecting the US to show a sharp downward trajectory not happening for at least the next couple of decades.
It is complete chaos now. With the latest nutcase pronouncement not sure what tomorrow’s going to bring.
XTM, can’t comment on your new open thread just fyi…
Agree with everything you wrote.
Opened the thread. Thank you.
This a nice AI on Modi, Trump and Netanyahu
https://web.facebook.com/reel/907193021899113
as formerly brown said
there might be an attempt to retrieve nuclear material.
Educated Speculation as to the actual “reason” behind the F-15 Airman rescue The speculation this was an operation to steal the Iran’s Enriched Uranium
https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/04/iran-war-trump-makes-even-more-unhinged-threat-as-details-of-f-15-pilot-rescue-point-to-much-bigger-plan-say-to-seize-enriched-uranium-trump-legitimacy-crisis-grows-as-battered-gulf-states-pull-ba.html
the world is holding its breath..
but the very fact that huge aircrafts landed deep inside Iran is troubling. the level of support to regime from the local population is suspect.
India entered the second stage of its nuclear program with the 500 MWe Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor (PFBR) at Kalpakkam attaining criticality on April 6, 2026. Using plutonium waste from Stage 1, these fast breeder reactors generate more fuel than they consume, enabling the transition towards, and ultimate utilization of, India’s vast thorium reserves.
This was Homi Bhabha’s original three stage plan.
Stage 3 involves using Thorium (India holds 25% of the world’s resources) to generate energy.
India has so much thorium it can use it for at least 400 years.
Aridhaman gas been comissioned. India should implant acoustic sensors in indian ocean seriously! The Chinese have literally wired the Pacific around Guam.
wired the Pacific?
Jai Hind
Huge Kudos to Pakistan.
Gave the excuse Trump to exit and declare victory
Meanwhile Hormuz will continue to remain under Irans control.
Maybe they will continue to charge money to go thru.
Iran sanctions removed (read the Irans conditions)
The US will not want to take on Iran again (I think)
For Trump too much economic pain (stock market, oil prices)
Hopefully this leads to a permenant peace agreement between Iran and USA. If a president like Trump could not defeat Iran, any upcoming US president would have no appetite to be antagonistic towards Iran. It bodes extremely ill for Israel and UAE who would now be trying to play spoiler here.
But if this becomes permenant, then this will be Pakistan’s greatest diplomatic achievement.
I see lots of hate & ridicule coming from Indian accounts and Indian media towards Pakistan which seems pretty unwarranted. My suggestion for them is that they should watch Dhurander 1, then watch Dhurander 2, and then watch Dhurander 1 again to feel good.
I hope this ceasefire leads to an end to the war. I’m not very optimistic about US or Israeli “ceasefires”. As we know, there is technically a ceasefire in Gaza right now but that conflict is not over.
I am genuinely surprised that the threat to “destroy civilization” was averted simply because Shahbaz Sharif requested a two week delay. But if this provides a face-saving exit for the US, it’s all to the good.
As for your last paragraph: Hopefully those Indians will realize “Dhurandhar” is not real life. Pakistan is in a much stronger diplomatic position than it was prior to last May. That’s simply reality.
All of the kills shown in in Dhurandhar were real
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/apr/04/indian-government-assassination-allegations-pakistan-intelligence-officials
“Stronger diplomatic position” while reality is:
Petrol prices reach record high (India 0 percent increase)UAE asks for money backQatar suspends visa on arrivalFinland close embassyAlso Trump already stopped immigration visa
The US will not want to take on Iran again (I think)
For Trump too much economic pain (stock market, oil prices)
Hormuz will continue to remain under Irans control.
They will continue to charge money to go thru.
Iran sanctions removed (read the Irans conditions)
IDF, Hezbollah Hamas can continue to fight each other if they want. It is an internal matter. Again I doubt the US will intervene directly.
I doubt Israel has the will to fight local wars. Maybe kill more in gaza
Pakistanis should watch Dhurandhar too as everything shown in those movies is real – corroborated by Pakistani sources and international media. π
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/apr/04/indian-government-assassination-allegations-pakistan-intelligence-officials
Pakistanis as always love their Lahori churan – saw the same in the T20 WC when they had “brought world cricket to their knees”.
Result – Walked back the boycott, didn’t even get handshakes as a concession, lost the match and watched India win the whole thing.
In the last few days
But “Pakistan great geopolitical player, paijaan”.
Pakistanis often have a habit of declaring premature victory without achieving anything. Only purpose it serves is the awaam enjoy some temporary happiness in the midst of their drudgery.
Saw same thing in the T20 WC.
“Pakistan had brought the cricket world to its knees”
‘International cricket hinges on Pakistan”
Quietly walked back the boycott, played the match and lost heavily, didn’t get a single concession in return including handshakes, watched India win the World Cup.
Pakistanis can enjoy saving the world for these two weeks I guess to distract from their petrol prices.
Apparently IMF will even ask the PKR to be free floated.
1 INR = 5 PKR soon?