The 100th Browncast with Amey the Maratha

Well, here we are. Razib and Amey talk about Sri Lankan genetics, casteism or lack thereof in the USA, the FUBAR of American immigration and finally how William Dalrymple triggers Amey’s Maratha pride.

Since I haven’t asked in a while, please review positively on Apple and Spotify.

Also, if you want to support the hosting fees for the podcast as well as recording software, please consider joining the Patreon.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Raja
Raja
6 months ago

Razib, firstly there seems to be a problem with the website. It’s home page is frozen in August. I had to manually change the date to September to get to this post. You might want to look into this

Regarding the Sinhala DNA discussion, the claim that Sinhalese is descended from Marashtri prakrit is not consensus among linguists, there is actually more evidence pointing to a eastern prakritic origin, check these references out:

Muhammad Shahidullah, “The Origin of the Sinhalese Language,” The Journal of the Ceylon Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain & Ireland, New Series, Vol. 8, No. 1 (1962): 108-111, accessed on JSTOR at https://www.jstor.org/stable/45377492.

Sisil Walimunidevage Karunatillake, “Historical Phonology of Sinhalese: From Old-Indo-Aryan to the 11th Century A.D.,” Ph.D. diss., Cornell University, 1969, Language and Literature, Linguistics, 140-141.

Also in this particular study they have seemed to have be biased by this preconceived notion that Sinhala is from Marashtri prakrit and centered their study on this theory.

They only compared SL Tamils, Sinhalese and Marathas in terms of IBD sharing. Of course Sinhalas will share more with any northern population regardless of whether it’s east or west.

They never compared SL Tamils, Sinhalese and Bengalis together in an IBD analysis. If they did they would almost certainly get the same conclusion.

23andme itself points to majority Bengali DNA among the Sinhalese northern ancestry:

https://sldna.blogspot.com/2020/03/sinhala-dna-results-2019-update.html

It’s the same with Maldivians who are descended mainly from Sinhalese:

https://www.tiktok.com/@about.maldives/video/7196997738431597825

I think you would do a much better analysis than the authors of this study.

Raja
Raja
6 months ago
Reply to  Raja

Further to the above, if you look at the supplementary tables of the study by Singh et al, the lowest f3 score was with the combination of bengalis and savaras, not marathas and kurumbas in regards to the Sinhalese. Even their own data points to the Bengal affinities. They really should have done a full comparison with all the info Aryan speaking coastal populations.

Brown Pundits