Brown PunditsA Deccani miniature of a dancing girl tying her hair, Golconda, about 1700

The Indian Subcontinent Argues with Itself

Imran Khan

  • Regency, Not Rupture in Pakistan (Open Thread)

    Open thread: X.T.M reads interior minister Mohsin Naqvi’s claim that Pakistan’s governance system has collapsed as a sign the army needs no coup, arguing that the Twenty-Seventh Amendment already makes…

    BP Admin Team · opened by X.T.M6 August 2026113 comments
  • The Prussia of the Ummah

    Building on RNJ’s comment that Munir’s consolidation makes a second Pahalgam unlikely, the post argues Pakistan’s army-led settlement is not a pause before collapse but a durable hybrid regime, ‘the…

    X.T.M19 May 20268 comments
  • Bangladesh Election Open Thread

    Bangladesh election open thread. The opening comment asks how the vote can be fair with the Awami League banned, compares it to Pakistan’s democracy with Imran Khan jailed, and calls…

    X.T.M13 February 202617 comments
  • Open Thread (Birthday)

    Open thread opening with Imran Khan’s sons describing his prison conditions as awful, a question on Pakistani nationalism and Indophilia, and X.T.M’s birthday news, travel and the second viral BRAHM…

    BP Admin Team · opened by X.T.M17 December 202514 comments
  • Imran Khan – open thread

    Open thread opening with X.T.M’s reaction to a rumour that the Pakistani military killed Imran Khan in jail, which he says would make Khan a martyr greater than Zulfikar Ali…

    BP Admin Team · opened by X.T.M1 December 202525 comments
  • Wag the dog?

    Playing devil’s advocate, the author argues that Pakistanis blame the military establishment for every failure, citing the false claim that half the budget goes to the army, and says that…

    Furqan Ali2 November 202526 comments
  • Pakistan’s Inner Logic

    The author argues that Pakistan is feudal and class-bound, that caste persists though denied, and that the postcolonial state never had a leftist rupture. He suggests Pakistanis seem happier because…

    BP Admin Team · opened by X.T.M11 October 202523 comments
  • 💔Sana Yusuf Did Not Have to Die

    After the murder of TikTok creator Sana Yusuf in Karachi, X.T.M argues that violence against women in Pakistan is an outcome of a society built on honour and male entitlement,…

  • An Electoral Earthquake in Pakistan

    Omar Ali reads Pakistan’s February 2024 election as a shock to the army, which he says engineered Imran Khan’s rise in 2018 and removal in 2021, and credits Khan with…

    Omar Ali9 February 20241 comment
  • Browncast: Election Time in Pakistan

    A BrownCast in which the host and Maneesh Taneja talk informally about Pakistan’s upcoming elections and the general situation there, ending with Imran Khan’s latest conviction for marrying before the…

    BrownCast · with Omar Ali4 February 20240 comments
Brown Pundits