A matter of representation


Several readers have brought it up in the comments, and it even cropped up in a secret message group I’m in, so I need to talk about this issue I guess. There is a serious lack of representation in the 2019 winning team from the United State of America in the International Math Olympiad. Except for a token Tocharian, it looks as if every member of the team is of East Asian heritage.

Contrast this with the much more diverse team from 2018, just last year. There were two South Asians on the team! In 2017, there was a <<<Bengali>>> American and a Tocharian on the team.

We’re moving backward. Do better.

1+

17 Replies to “A matter of representation”

    1. Go Serbia!

      Serbian Aryaputra aur Aryaputri ki jai!

      ++++++++++++++++++

      I think the solution to this problem Razib is:

      https://www.brownpundits.com/2019/01/23/is-it-time-for-asian-americans-and-latino-americans-to-ask-to-be-considered-white-b/

      If we are all “white” than representation problem solved. Voila!

      I think that the only “protected classes” as per the 1964 and 1965 civil rights legislation should be Black African Americans. No exceptions.

      The US constitution, Bill of Rights and other amendments to constitution are “protection” enough.

      2+
  1. BTW the team leader and the deputy team leader of the American team (who accompany and are in charge of the students, perhaps act as sort of advocates if they feel the grading was unfair to one of the team members etc.) were Chinese too. So really it was a China vs China match for the first two positions.

    0
  2. We’re moving backward. Do better.

    From what I observe, “Tiger Parenting” seems to be on the wane among Indians. So my guess is you are going to be disappointed.

    1+
          1. Bro, I am like talking about a real sport now WWE. Didn;t that Canadian Punjabi guy already won the WWE Champion,couple of years back ?

            1+
  3. First who redesigned this blog. Is it for smart phones.

    I suspect Razib did the redesign, like he kept redoing his blog razib.com

    Huge banner (half the page). Whats with the comments. Old fuxers like me cant even see it on a 17 inch screen.

    Comment box is about 2 inches (1/10th of the screen 1080 wide).

    0
    1. should i go back to the old comments? i kind of get annoyed by the threading.

      will think about making this easier on desktop.

      0
      1. No i agree , even i was annoyed with the old one. Just increase comment box size and font, and you can decrease banner size if you want

        0
      2. Razib,

        Here is my wish list (old geezer who reads only on laptop 17 inch screen).

        a) Bigger Comment Box. So that can see at least two paragraphs (10 lines).

        b) Current Font is OK

        Banner Could be smaller but non issue as can scroll past.

        The reply Icon is huge and detracts from the sequence of comments. Reply Icon should be 25% or less of current.

        Threading, not so much.
        More a like than want.
        eg some threading like in unz.com where you see to whom comment was addressed/replied.

        cheers

        0
  4. Hello, fellas I’m a Gujarati American born & raised in America. I’ve been viewing this page recently & thought I might start joining in the discussions from now on. Particularly, in regards to this post I would say for some reason Indian American kids are not prevalent in competitions like this, but once they grow up and graduate college they seem to make a better impact compared to East Asians. This is similar to Ashkenazi Jews who have been also invisible for sometime now in these competitions. But, as we can still see Ashkenazi Jews are still making an impact such as finding Google & Facebook as companies or winning Nobel Prizes.

    Two Indians in the western diaspora won a Fields Medal, And, there has been more prestigious awards Indians have won so far compared to the East Asians in the western diaspora.Remember, a high verbal I.Q is needed to get by in the western world & Indian Americans most likely have a higher verbal I.Q compared to East Asian Americans. This could also probably be the reason why to there’s more Indian American CEO’s & Politicians compared to East Asian American ones. Basically, we should make these comparisons between South Asian Americans vs East Asian Americans once the kids have finally graduated college & entered the “real” & “professional” world.

    https://news.stanford.edu/2018/08/02/akshay-venkatesh-wins-fields-medal/

    https://www.quantamagazine.org/number-theorist-manjul-bhargava-is-awarded-fields-medal-20140812/

    https://www.uua.org/publications/beacon/153857.shtml

    https://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ani/vikram-patel-awarded-the-prestigious-john-dirks-canada-gairdner-global-health-award-119040300273_1.html

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.